The Cookie Lady's Cafe

2501 NJ-88, Point Pleasant
(732) 714-9494

Recent Reviews

Sort by
M Cooper

Fantastic and creative menu! Employees are kind and attentive. Cookie lady has really made a turn around- our favorite spot to eat, any time of day. Wednesday trivia is super fun!! Love the outdoor space.

Liam Gavan

Great staff and great people!

Brianna Inguaggiato

First time here and we’ll definitely be back! Adorable spot with a fantastic menu, great staff and fresh squeezed oj!

Tonya LaRocca

The BBQ Brisket breakfast bowl is absolutely delicious! The brisket just melts in your mouth and they give you a very nice size portion for the price. I’ll be coming back for this for sure!! 😋

Came back today under new owners and let me say I’m very disappointed! No peppers and onions and only half the brisket with no bbq but the price is still the same. If you’re not going to make it the same way change your menu. I should not have to ask for peppers and onions like the time I came. This time I didn’t ask if they made it with peppers and onions to see what I got. The first pic from 4 months ago second pic from today 🤬😡

Suzette Sequeira

About 7 minute drive from the Jenkinson's Boardwalk and Beach in Point Pleasant.
Opens at 7am!
Greeted with smiles!
Noticed sign The Cookie Lady's Cafe is under new management!
Head Chef was greeting customers.
Hot latte and eggs Benedict!
Were great!
I like my poached eggs well done- soft!
Thank you just perfect for me!
Fresh squeezed orange juice to go!
Good vibes!
Wishing you much success!

Very clean!

Parking on site!

Matt Sorrentino

Stopped in for the first time for their Wednesday night trivia. Trivia was great and a lot of fun but I came here because I had what was quite possibly the best chicken wings I’ve ever had in my entire life. Chef Morgan was there and I had to know how they made them. Absolutely perfect with the house made buffalo sauce. 10/10.

Matt B

Food was just okay but all the man handling of the food was a turn off. For the ice, they can use a scooper. For the bacon, they can use tongs. I think waitresses were nice just busy to get back to you.

Sarah Woodman

Great food. Such a cute place!

Angel Angelov

Amazing food and great atmosphere

Theresa “Sunshine” Miles

What a great quaint place.. prices were good food was good and the people were friendly definitely going back again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen Knouse

Parking: This is an excellent place to eat. The owner serves good quality food at great prices. Everyone is pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Home Fries, Served with Toast & Home Fries

valerie walsh

Food is very good. A real cute neighborly atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Germaine Kmetz (Cookie)

Very good food
Host was outstanding

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Home Fries, Served with Toast & Home Fries

Jamie

The inside is very tiny and very cute. The French toast is amazing. Like over the top delicious- highly recommend trying them. The potatoes on our scrambler were not fresh and cold ruining the dish. Eggs were ordered over easy so I could break the yolk over the dish but they were served over hard.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Toast

Olivia Case

Great little local place to have breakfast. My boyfriend and I sat outside with our dog and spent a lovely morning here. They have a couple trellises where they grow flowers and vegetables, really enjoyable to look at while you eat.

The staff was friendly and were even nice enough to provide our dog with a bowl of water upon seating us (we didn't even have to ask!).

We'll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...