Fresh Fish Market

1510 Main St, Rahway
(908) 487-3003

Recent Reviews

rise

Ordered food here last night and my stomach still hurt. I do not recommend

Tamika H

I usually like getting fish from here but lately it's been very disappointing. The fish sandwich is like 7 dollars and some change. They used to give you 3 pieces of fish on the sandwich and now it's 2 small pieces.

Lebohang M

I paid $25 for the worst seafood boil ever. I’m still pissed. She literally boils it and gives you butter on the side. No flavor or nothing. Not even a sprinkle of pepper. I can still smell the boiled fish. The corn was mush and tasteless, the potatoes were rubbery because the were cooked rotten. They even had the black stuff inside! Gross! Save your self a heart break and drive 5 more minutes to hook n reel in route 1-9. I’m so upset I wanna call my bank to dispute the charge! Just shameless!!!

Marxus C.

They really have good porgy and whiting. Haven't tried much else but I'm sure that's rockin too! And the lady at the counter is mad nice! Shoot I'm going today!

Gabriel Soto

Food was good but they didn’t give me my complete order . By the time I realized I was to far away! ? you owe me some crab sticks!! ?

TATYANA HAROLD

i asked for fried scallops & they weren’t how they normally are cooked. not sure if they are under new management or maybe a different person made it, but the scallops felt very rubbery. almost as if the outside was the only thing that was cooked. i’ll come back eventually bc i usually get good results but that really threw me off lol

The Bloos

I always get the shrimp and rice platter and it’s always delicious. And the lady at the front desk is a sweetheart.

Lu Rom

For the price you pay they complain to give you sauces for your order but for was good only issue was with the sauce

Alonso Miller

Fresh food and friendly service to go. For easy take out meal you can't go wrong.

Andrew Jones

I like how well the fish are fried. The only complaint is too little tartar sauce was given.

Destiny Nichols

Bad ExperienceOwner has unpleasant attitudeThrows their product around when you are asking them to assist you with weighing the seafoodDo not recommend their productsExtremely high price for such rude serviceSpend your money elsewhere ❗️

Felicia Kelly

I ordered a dozen steam blue crabs. Yes I know they are off season. And yes they were awful. What I ate of them were dead amd they tasted like grit and grease. I threw most of them away.

Jasmine Malloy

Amazingly good fried fish sandwiches with good sides.

Forgem Nos

Great tasting food. I found this by chance. The portions are decent. They clean their fish well, so there no fishy taste or smell.

s d

I really didn't enjoy my food. Too salty, small portion of the seafood -- it was mostly a bland mushy rice. Plus the restaurant was very dingy. The staff was nice. Price was fine . I didn't have high expectations but I had hoped for more. Won't be going back.

Load More