Black River Barn

1178 Route 10, West St, Randolph
(973) 598-9988

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rylee Jackson

Not safe for women! Please be very careful if you are a woman visiting this establishment. There is a creep in the parking lot who will leave nasty notes and pictures of his genitalia and the owner will dismiss your claims!

Lora Dultz

This is not a place a woman can go and feel safe. The owner thinks it’s ok for a man to place pornography on multiple customer’s windshields. It’s not ok and this guy is stalking and harassing women. The owner is a POS too. He should go away. Far, far away. Maybe he thinks this behavior is ok because he’s the one harassing women. The police were not concerned. Do not frequent this establishment!!!

Natasha Nancy

No a safe environment for women to attend

Joe Cusick

Nice for sports

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roman Cool Tech Control

I like this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stark InDisguise

Good service and friendly staff. Thanks Wilber very much for the good 1st time experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Aster Pheonyx

This place is amazing. I love that you can sit outside, get delicious food and look at the water! They have so many food options for every dietary need. Service is always great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patty Padakis

I get that it’s holiday season but we were seated next to partial wall and service station. Too much traffic. We usually sit at tables in bar area, nothing was available
A large party was being set up, then party arrived and traffic was worse. My husband got bumped and nudged serval times this was NOT an enjoyable dinner. We do stay for coffee or tea but we needed to leave. Became too much

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Sheila Hill-Ramp

Wonderful family restaurant ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Honest Truth

Been twice recently & everything was perfect. Staff awesome, food hot & delicious, & not overpriced.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Death by Chocolate, Chicken Wings, Burger

Rayne Marie

Truly disappointed with this place, and recommend you do not come here. They incorrectly charged my credit card for MUCH more than I was supposed to be charged for. My partner and I both gave our cards to the waiter, and told him how much to put on each card, he repeated what we told him- so, we said correct, and he came back with our cards- both of us had a receipt and wrote our totals on it. So, how in the world can you be so air headed as to charge one credit card the entire amount of the meal? What if that was someone I couldn’t easily contact again that I was having dinner with to repay me?

I’ve called and spoken to a women named Tammy who is barely sincere in her apologies and stated “this happens sometimes” so it seems like a regular occurrence. She told me she would refund me and charge the other card. However, I haven’t even received my funds back, they aren’t even pending in my account. The way this was handled was really unprofessional. And, the fact that I am still paying for this after such a mistake is quite disgusting to me, especially because the food wasn’t even that good. We boxed up our food and took it home to throw out because our waiter was so incompetent, I didn’t even want to ask for something else. Just paid out bills and went home to eat our own food at home. Which we should’ve done in the first place.

Hope I do get my money back like Tammy said I would. Otherwise I’m reporting this to my credit card company. This was entirely a scam.

But like I said, I really recommend you go somewhere else if you want to sit down and relax and eat a good meal.

Edit: 4 days have gone by. Still nothing. What disgusting people. Now I have to pay a fee for going over my credit limit. Which was not my fault at all, or my intentions last night. I was supposed to be charged $21. But was charged $76. Appalling.

Edit: 5 days. Still waiting. Every time I call they tell me Tammy isn’t available.

Edit: on Nov 20th they refunded me $76 and CHARGED ME $50 SOMETHING WHEN I ONLY OWE $21.

They made me drive to the barn to sit down with the general manager named Andrew who is telling me how my bank account works with no resolve and they still made me pay for my meal which is funny. No wonder the reviews are so low on this place. I drove 40 minutes for this.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Marc Somelofski

Food is always good here. I had a chicken sandwich with mozzarella and balsamic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jen R.

Absolutely love this restaurant!!! Whether sitting at the bar or a table, the service is impeccable and the food is delicious. There really are not many spots in the area with such a diverse menu and exceptional seasonal specials. The meatball skillet is to die for and I love their new fall hot cocktails

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Brown

It's basically a diner with a nice patio. We've eaten here for the last 20 years it's mediocre food with a nice view.
1. Huge menu with so many cusines so no way to specialize in anything.
2. Today our waiter missed items in our order twice so half the table was eating while the other half had to wait to eat.
3. We ordered a BBQ chicken sandwich to go for my son. It wasnt broght to the table. When we were leaving we had to ask where it was. The waiter put it on another check and sent to another customer. Sadly, the chicken was leather it was cooked so long. Too bad we didn't get laces with it.

It's OK but don't have high expectations.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Maria Stapperfenne, CMKBD

We hired out the back room for a professional trade event, and it was great! Very attentive service and a BBQ style buffet that made everyone happy 😊. 2 servers met each guest with a drink request just as the host committee showed. Great social. Would love to come back outside when warmer!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...