Mario's Famous Pizza

140 Rte 10 West, Randolph
(973) 537-0444

Recent Reviews

Emmett Noe

Excellent pizza, subs and salads. Grab takeout here frequently.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Monica Laynes

Great food and fastest delivery

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

robert fuchs

The food is great.

Food: 5

Frank Yost

Don't order delivery from this place online it will take an hour for your food to arrive and when you call to talk to them about it the lie to you about why its cold. They told us it went out right after it was done and there is just no way the pizza is cold and what ever they call bruschetta is not bruschetta its garlic bread with melted cheese

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Hanover Powersports

if i could leave 0 stars i would. Terrible staff and horrific

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Edbafi

Good place, excellent parking, very delicious food, very welcoming, good service, but a little bitter, you have to teach them to give the customer a smile, even if it's fake.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Andres G

Horrible penne vodka pasta with

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

alex G9991

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE , I ordered 50$ worth of food for New Year’s Eve they dropped it off at the wrong address and insisted that they gave it to my “roommate” WHICH I DO NOT HAVE I continued to call them to get a refund and they told me they weren’t going to give me one because they gave the food to my “roommate” again I do not live with a roommate , and they proceed to block my number and ROB 50$ from me so happy F’N new years to you to NEVER ORDER FROM HERE

Ana

Never got my pizza !!! My husband send me dinner and they said they leave at the wrong address !!!

Service: 1

Crystal Vecchio

Very disappointed in the quality of the food. The food used to be so delicious!! What happened …

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mario Arocaceli

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Pizza

Heather S

Ordered Veal Frances’s with linguine and they gave me the veal and lemon butter sauce in one container and the pasta in a separate container with red sauce on it. Why would I want a red sauce on the pasta when I got lemon butter sauce? When I called to see if they would fix it I was told that it was MY fault that the mistake was made and that’s how they always make the food… you always make the food with two different sauces? That isn’t correct. We order here before and have never had the pasta separately or with a different sauce. Didn’t even offer to make plain pasta for us to come get. Customer service is extremely lacking.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Heather S.

Ordered Veal Frances's with linguine and they gave me the veal and lemon butter sauce in one container and the pasta in a separate container with red sauce on it. Why would I want a red sauce on the pasta when I got lemon butter sauce? When I called to see if they would fix it I was told that it was MY fault that the mistake was made and that's how they always make the food... you always make the food with two different sauces? That isn't correct. We order here before and have never had the pasta separately or with a different sauce. Youre telling me it was an "accident" that they put the linguine in with the dinner previously? Youre telling me that the menu saying the entree comes with pasta is a mistake too? You're supposed to magically know to ask for your pasta without red sauce? BS! Didn't even offer to make plain pasta for us to come get. Customer service is extremely lacking.

Tyler A.

I will never turn down a good slice of pizza. Naturally, I was very excited to try this new spot when I was over a buddy's house. I'm from Hudson County born and raised, so good pizza is available rather easily here, and it is relatively abundant if you know where to look. I can't speak to the inside of the restaurant or the decor, as we had delivery. However, this place was prompt and had the food ready on time. Given where we were, we were pleasantly surprised by the food! Stromboli was excellent. It was cooked perfectly and very flavorful. As for the pizza, toppings were abundant and generous. Olive, pepperoni, sausage, Buffalo chicken, and plain cheese pizzas were all quite good. Cheese blend is also very nice and sauce was well-seasoned and flavorful. If you ask me, it was a bit of a departure from true New York pizza given that the crust was very crisp, making the pizza difficult to fold. However, that isn't a deal breaker, just a preference. Needless to say, would be happy to enjoy pizza from here again!

ModifySociety /MODSOC

Too pricey!!! almost 3 a slice tax included and $2.59 for Kirkland purified water. Trash, no one should spend their time on break here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Load More