Coney Island Pizza

40 Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale
(973) 725-0990

Recent Reviews

Sort by
M Flo

Tried their pizza at the Hoboken saint annes festival. This was probably top 10 pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. Going to make a trip up to Riverdale on my next day off!

erika stevenson-farrah

We had there pizza at Sand Storm. Soooo good

Nicole Talmo

Hired Coney Island Pizza for my daughter's first birthday. We had 75 guests and they nailed it!! Everyone raved about the food. They did a great job and it took so much off my plate to have them there!

To A Fla

So delicious and plenty of food. Loved it!

d cas

End of an era... used to love picking up food here and i just learned they only do catering now....

David

Delicious pizza! Crust was perfect.

Kristen Salvi

There are not enough words of praise. We had a party and used their mobile wood fired oven catering. The prices were fair, the food was delicious and everyone was such a pleasure to work with. All of our guests raved about what a cool idea it was and how delicious everything was. 5 stars all around!

Reema Modi

After calling multiple times found out that they are closed. Only do catering service.

Pamela Doyle

The pizza was excellent. The staff are young and super friendly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

T P

Most delicious pizza I ever ate! The guys said try the bbq chicken pizza and pulled pork pizza but I didn’t!! I got white pizza and meatball pizza from recommendations!! So yummy and fresh!! But I’ll be back soooo yummy!!

Tiffini Portillo

Most delicious pizza I ever ate! The guys said try the bbq chicken pizza and pulled pork pizza but I didn’t!! I got white pizza and meatball pizza from recommendations!! So yummy and fresh!! But I’ll be back soooo yummy!!

yeh (yeh)

This place is a true gem. I feel lucky to live so close by. I love pizza. All pizza. This place makes pizza the way it should be made. It's wood fired pizza. It took me as long to drive there (15 mins) as it did for them to make the pizzas I ordered! Staff is always really nice. Can't wait to order again.

Kayla Marie

High quality & Delicious pizzaBrick oven is my favorite

Matthew Gancher

Just amazing food and pies from this place as always

Beatriz Aguiar

Best pizza EVER!!!

Loading...