Coney Island Pizza

40 Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale
(973) 725-0990

Recent Reviews

Reema Modi

After calling multiple times found out that they are closed. Only do catering service.

Pamela Doyle

The pizza was excellent. The staff are young and super friendly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

T P

Most delicious pizza I ever ate! The guys said try the bbq chicken pizza and pulled pork pizza but I didn’t!! I got white pizza and meatball pizza from recommendations!! So yummy and fresh!! But I’ll be back soooo yummy!!

Tiffini Portillo

Most delicious pizza I ever ate! The guys said try the bbq chicken pizza and pulled pork pizza but I didn’t!! I got white pizza and meatball pizza from recommendations!! So yummy and fresh!! But I’ll be back soooo yummy!!

Chris T.

When you've got Pizza Exhaustion and you need something New & Different that comes with a crust around it -- think of Coney Island Wood Fired Pizza!

Richard D.

I would give this place 4 starts for there pizza. There is no way I could possibly give them a good review they are they worst run business I ever came across. Any given day they will tell you there not delivering and this goes on every week but they advertise delivery. They use to have eat in but since the pandemic they just said the heck with it we won't have sit down anymore so ok no sit down and deliver when you feel like it. Then they close any day they feel like it. Very good pizza very bad business.

Marc M.

Tasty wood fired pizza. We always enjoy ordering several pies and everyone gets to try a different slice.

yeh (yeh)

This place is a true gem. I feel lucky to live so close by. I love pizza. All pizza. This place makes pizza the way it should be made. It's wood fired pizza. It took me as long to drive there (15 mins) as it did for them to make the pizzas I ordered! Staff is always really nice. Can't wait to order again.

Kayla Marie

High quality & Delicious pizzaBrick oven is my favorite

Nick S.

Pizza is great for its kind. Not your average Pizza joint. No Slices or anything, just 12" Pies. Good variety. A solid spot. A must Try

Carly Fisher

Coney Island mobile pizza truck came to our son's 1st birthday party and they were fantastic! Throughout the planning process, Robert always made us feel comfortable by assuring us they would be there to help rain or shine! Robert and his guys were great to our guests, ensuring everyone had what they wanted. They even gave us so many pies left over that we could enjoy throughout the rest of the day/evening. We cannot wait to work with them again for future parties and would highly suggest them to anyone looking for a unique, fun party idea!

Orlando Zayas

First time here and loved the personal pizza offerings and combinations! Had the 3P and Verde Pizzas and we LOVED THEM BOTH!This is a must try !

Brad C.

Hired them to bring their wood fired oven to my daughter's college graduation yard party this past weekend. As usual their pizza was amazing. The sign of a good restaurant is consistency and it was just like being in their place. Phillips, Brandon & Marisa were awesome. Had about 65 guests and they had the pies flying out of that oven. We did have a taco truck too but there was very little waiting. So many of the guests were raving about the pizza. Great job! Thank you.

David Vespole

We got Coney Island Pizza to bring their wood fired pizza truck to our home for a friends and family party and boy was it a hit! From the very beginning part of the process, all our questions were answered in a timely manner. Their prices were very competitive and they put together a solid display of pizza for our guests. Everyone had great things to say about the taste, the smell and overall ambiance the food truck brought to our party. It was nice to not have to grill for 50 people! Rob and his guys were awesome to work with. Thanks so much!!

Erin E.

Family run. Amazing, authentic food. Love dropping in here to pick up pizza and meatball sliders

Load More