Goodfellows Pizza and Italian Specialties

UPDATE: Corrected food just arrived. A Goodfellows Wrap. Sorry I didn't go to bed with my son. Chicken is chewy and tasteless. Their stuff is normally very good. Not tonight. I think the Parlin location has gotten us for the last time.This place has so many great items. The prices are kind of high, but it's quality food. However, we live less than a mile from the restaurant and delivery can either be hot or right. Today is my birthday and they screwed up my order. We called right away, they admitted the mistake and are sending the corrected item. Meanwhile it's been over an hour, everyone ate (but me) and my 4 year old is now in bed and I'm still waiting

Excellent staff and service. Delicious food. Even helped me to my car with a ton of food in the pouring rain. New owners but definately awesome place to go.

Overall the pizza was good. If you like a lot of cheese you will like this pizza. It seems like extra cheese even though it wasn't. The crust is soft and a bit doughy but some people like it that way the tomato sauce is not really a tastable factor but it is there. In general I was happy about everything but the price was a little bit High. $40 for two large pies each with one topping and the toppings were a little bit light.

So disappointed i order a $120 worth of food to see 2 meatballs and only ordered 2 burgers 2 sandwiches and a seafood pasta with only shrimp and a pie of pizza half plian half Pepperoni wft

We ordered two large pies on a weekday night. One with pepperoni and one with bacon toppings were good but not quite scarce but certainly not a lot. The cheese was very full as if it was extra cheese so if you like cheese that was awesome. Tomato sauce was good but not a huge presence in the taste. The dough is soft and doughy but the pizza held himself together easily. If you like soft crust it's another bonus. I would say the prices a little bit High because the total is $40 for these two items. Many other local places you would be able to get two large pies with one topping each for closer to $30 and in some cases 25.

We have been ordering from Goodfellows in Parlin NJ for years and it “hit or miss”. Pizza is usually very good though. This was chicken parm picked up today. Burned and old!

Great food. I've been eating there for years.

a picture is worth a thousand words, i only eat the cheese and the meat from pizza, this is what i found on mine extra protein i didn't ask for. Yes they quality has gone down the drain, what a shame

Great food, grandma pie is the best!

Best food around! Their pizza is a work of art (crispy, delicious, and down right mouth watering). Great staff and service

The pizza is awesome and the service is outstanding I highly recommend this place for lunch or dinner.BTW I know it’s a pizzeria but they make a great cheeseburger deluxe

Delicious food and friendly employees. Fast delivery as well.

Very upset, ordered off the website over an hour ago to have the pizza delivered by 840pm , it’s 9:20pm and they still haven’t arrived. Just moved to the area and won’t make the mistake of ordering here again. Looking forward to cold pizza that isn’t even here yet . Thanks guys

I would give 0 stars if I could. Got a Buffalo chicken slice and rook one bite to immediately spit it out and the cheese was all moldy.

My neighborhood go to! Employees are very pleasant and food is always fresh and delicious.