Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls

I ate it so fast and it was so good that I couldn’t even get a picture of it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quincy’s Lobster Rolls in Sea Isle City is definitely worth a stop! The lobster rolls were delicious, and I didn’t have to wait long at all. Everyone working there was friendly and welcoming, 5 stars for food and service!

I’d give the atmosphere 3 stars only because there’s no indoor seating. You either take your food to go or eat outside. I personally would have preferred an indoor option to eat quickly, but I understand the space may be used for other needs.

That said, the lack of indoor seating didn’t stop me from going back for more!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lobster and shrimp rolls are always excellent - our favorites of all rolls in the PA, NJ & MD areas! The crab roll was bland - needs lump backfin with a little Old Bay. The restaurant is undergoing a remodel which is expected to last through the year. Carry out only. Bummer.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

most delicious lobster ive ever had and also big shoutout to the staff they were super nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quincy’s Lobster Roll at Waterside Place: As someone who grew up in the Northeast and knows a thing or two about authentic New England-style lobster salad, I can confidently say that Quincy’s Lobster Roll at Waterside Place is absolutely delicious. The lobster was incredibly fresh, perfectly sweet, and generously portioned. The roll itself was just the right texture—soft and slightly toasted—and let the quality of the lobster shine. This was a true taste of home, and I’ll definitely be back!

We looked up lobster rolls on the internet, and stopped by the one at Cape May, NJ. Wow, what a let down. Little bit of bland lobster, no flavor, on a hotdog bun. Over 40 bucks for my wife and I. Save your money.

I had my 1st EVER lobster roll at the Cape May location over Labor Day weekend. It was something I always wanted to try bc you see other people eating it and want to see what is all about. It is expensive compared to getting a whole pound and a half steam lobster with salad, roll, fries AND Coleslaw for $8 more, just down a few ways at the Cape May location. It was meaty, the roll was tasty, great flavor, it was a nice treat. All I know is that next time I am in the mood for lobster, I will get a whole pound and a 1/2 with all those sides for $8 more.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

This place is a joke. We ordered the Connecticut roll and it was TINY. We paid $25 and asked for extra meat and my boyfriend ate it in two bites. I’ve had lobster ills before and this one was a joke.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Crab and lobster roll pretty tasty but very small. I think they used hot dog buns?? The chicken tenders were disgusting! I’m sure frozen from a store and not hand made. Fries were good. Disappointing!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

I ordered 2 lobster rolls and 1 mac n cheese. Both were on point. The roll was what I expected for that style. The meat was great and it was filled the roll. For those who say it isn't cheap enough, if you go to New England you pay more. I have had rolls in ME and MA as comparisons.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The employees here are the best! Sooo welcoming and friendly. The food is also delicious! Hard to wrong with the classic (can get it warm too ?). They also recently started serving smoothies . So refreshing on a hot day!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

People are friendly. Store is clean for dine in or quick for take out. Sometimes it's busy but they keep hustling. Great quality, tasting food for price

Kid-friendliness: Atmosphere can be busy, but ample seating with high chairs for my little girl

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll Opted for 50 More Lobster Wonder What It Looks Like at 50 Less, Lobster Mac N Cheese

We stopped in for a bite to eat around lunch time after being at the beach for a couple of hours. We both ordered the Jumbo Classic Lobster Rolls. It came with a bag of chips. The lobster was plentiful and delicious. Though the dish is very pricey it’s good to treat yourself especially when on vacation.

Got the lobster bisque and for $8 it had maybe one piece of lobster in it … definitely not a great value. Everything else was okay ??‍♂️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

A bit pricey but very delicious lobster! Wish they had a gluten free roll option