Mystic Lobster Roll Company / Park Central Market / Mystic Subs

Great lobster roll!!...clean restaurant and friendly service!!..will visit again when in town...

First time ever, I visited this place with a friend from out of state as well as the first time I ate a lobster roll and some big 'ol crab legs.
We ordered the one that was warm with butter, and it was delicious! Being new to crab legs as well, this was a whole different flavor field. (You would think all these years in Jersey, I'd be more into seafood, lol)
I enjoyed the whole experience. My friend ordered the Manhattan clam chowder, and he said it was delicious. I tasted the chowder part, and it was tasty, but I wasn't taking in clams and lobster on the same day. 😭 baby steps. The two females that worked there were super nice and loquacuous. Very very friendly. Place is small. Would definitely try again.

Great service
Best lobster roll
We will be back

Damn right delicious.i went with the classic Lobster roll with Butter!!!! The Crab legs were amazing and the New England clam chowder was next level.

Best lobster in the NJ shore and very kind staff

Nice place, very friendly staff, they were so helpful and informative. Couldn’t wait to check this place out and so happy I did. The lobster roll was so fresh, so warm and delicious. 😋

We started dining here as a family this past summer and fall. The food is always delicious and the service is very friendly and attentive!

We started dining here as a family this past summer and fall. The food is always delicious and the service is very friendly and attentive!

BUYER BEWARE!!! Jersey Italian Gravy Review A recent review highlights the lack of integrity, character, and classless action, of owner of Mystic Lobster Roll Company We sold a number of cases of our product to Mystic Lobster, and despite multiple follow-ups, we have not been paid. After reaching out numerous times, we’ve only received vague promises that they’ll “get around to it,” but it’s clear there’s no intention to settle this debt. As a small business, it’s incredibly disappointing to experience this lack of integrity. Rather than honoring their commitment and being upfront, they’ve chosen to ignore our calls and avoid resolving the issue. We can’t recommend working with a business that disregards agreements and disrespects honest partnerships

Shame on you. A recent review highlights the lack of integrity of the owner of Mystic Lobster Roll Company. Not honorable. BUYER BEWARE!!! Customers, Vendors, Partners Jersey Italian Gravy Review We sold a number of cases of our product to Mystic Lobster, and despite multiple follow-ups, we have not been paid. After reaching out numerous times, we’ve only received vague promises that they’ll “get around to it,” but it’s clear there’s no intention to settle this debt. As a small business, it’s incredibly disappointing to experience this lack of integrity. Rather than honoring their commitment and being upfront, they’ve chosen to ignore our calls and avoid resolving the issue. We can’t recommend working with a business that disregards agreements and disrespects honest partnerships

We stopped in Saturday evening and the lady working who has served us before throughout the summer smelled of Marijuana so strong it made the area we sat smell like it each time she walked past. The food. was ok not hot like previous times we've stopped here and the menu is different tastes are a little different from the summer.
The hostess/waitress was overbearing with trying to talk to us and joke with us when all we wanted to do was eat and leave....
We asked to speak to the manager she said she was one of the managers.
We sat in our car outside and could see her vape smoking something I guess was Marijuana.
That's why we will no longer go here or return with family friends or our children in the summer.
Customers should never be subjected to that kind of environment at an eating establishment.
Whoever the owners are they should be more hands on with who they hire because i would fire any employees of mine who came in smelling of Marijuana or used it on company time........ recreational legal or not that's not the place to subject families, business associates or children to that kind of behavior.

Great lobster rolls and the chicken wings were delicious! I’m a local and appreciate them being open this time of year in our sleepy town.

Best mf breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had

Friendly staff and delicious food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went for dinner tonight and the experience was very positive. Two of us had soup for appetizers (1 clam chowder and one lobster bisque.). Two of us had the warm lobster rolls and the third has a pound of snow crab legs. The food was very good and the waitress was very attentive and charming. I highly recommend this restaurant!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: blt Lobster Roll, Connecticut Lobster Roll