Mystic Lobster Roll Company / Park Central Market / Mystic Subs

We started dining here as a family this past summer and fall. The food is always delicious and the service is very friendly and attentive!

BUYER BEWARE!!! Jersey Italian Gravy Review A recent review highlights the lack of integrity, character, and classless action, of owner of Mystic Lobster Roll Company We sold a number of cases of our product to Mystic Lobster, and despite multiple follow-ups, we have not been paid. After reaching out numerous times, we’ve only received vague promises that they’ll “get around to it,” but it’s clear there’s no intention to settle this debt. As a small business, it’s incredibly disappointing to experience this lack of integrity. Rather than honoring their commitment and being upfront, they’ve chosen to ignore our calls and avoid resolving the issue. We can’t recommend working with a business that disregards agreements and disrespects honest partnerships

Shame on you. A recent review highlights the lack of integrity of the owner of Mystic Lobster Roll Company. Not honorable. BUYER BEWARE!!! Customers, Vendors, Partners Jersey Italian Gravy Review We sold a number of cases of our product to Mystic Lobster, and despite multiple follow-ups, we have not been paid. After reaching out numerous times, we’ve only received vague promises that they’ll “get around to it,” but it’s clear there’s no intention to settle this debt. As a small business, it’s incredibly disappointing to experience this lack of integrity. Rather than honoring their commitment and being upfront, they’ve chosen to ignore our calls and avoid resolving the issue. We can’t recommend working with a business that disregards agreements and disrespects honest partnerships

Best mf breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had

Friendly staff and delicious food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went for dinner tonight and the experience was very positive. Two of us had soup for appetizers (1 clam chowder and one lobster bisque.). Two of us had the warm lobster rolls and the third has a pound of snow crab legs. The food was very good and the waitress was very attentive and charming. I highly recommend this restaurant!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: blt Lobster Roll, Connecticut Lobster Roll

I had the pleasure of meeting someone on a Tuesday afternoon a few weeks ago outside the local 7-11. I casually asked what a good place to eat for the family was. He recommended mystic lobster roll seaside to me.
Around 630, I took the family in, and we were seated in a very nice environment. Clean, good lighting, and great smelling food. We placed our orders, and everything came to our table fresh, hot, and exactly the way it was ordered. Before we left, i happened to see the person I had spoken to in the kitchen cooking.
I asked to speak to him, smiling. I said thank you for your insight to give this place a try.
He smiled and said, "I hope you enjoyed everything. All of us work hard to make sure you will love coming here and return, I could not think of a betterplace to recommend than here, knowing everything is fresh. We also were told they will be open throughout the winter daily."
I thanked him and everyone else.
We look forward to returning here again.
Not listed, but we had fried calamari, raw clams, and flounder wrapped around a lump crab meat cake that was the best tasting crab cake I've ever eaten. They had filet and snow crab specials and a few others that were available that evening also. Slider burgers and fries for the kids.
I'm returning in a cpl weeks and looking forward to one of the cold cut subs they make they are huge to say the very least.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Connecticut Lobster Roll, French Fries

This place blows me away every time we stop there starting with the clean well lit environment to every staff member and the kitchen staff as well.
Every item is made to order fresh hot and put together professionally.

Everyone has a smile on their face and you can tell a happy work environment.

From the daily specials to the 5☆ seafood served as well as breakfast sandwiches ? we found a local pot of gold for the entire family to enjoy.
We're relaxed letting our kids go there for lunch get together with friends knowing it's a safe family environment for them to eat at.
We just found out they will be open year round for us that's great news.
Don't miss out on stopping in this business and enjoying one of the best meals you or your family can have in the entire area.

Thank you everyone at mystic lobster roll.

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free rolls...
All the food is cooked to order.
I like that it's not pre prepared sitting around.
Everything tastes amazingly fresh, hot, 5 ☆ rating compared to other locations close by.
Key factor is they will remain open year round we love knowing that.
Thank you everyone we will definitely let others know how good it was and return ourselves.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken and Waffles, Connecticut Lobster Roll, The blt Roll, French Fries, Maine Roll, K Chicken Fingers

Amazing lobster rolls, the crab cakes are to DIE for ?

Vegetarian options: Salads and veggie bao bun

Kid-friendliness: There’s a kid menu

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: New England Clam Chowder, Chicken and Waffles, blt Lobster Roll, Shrimp Chowder, Connecticut Lobster Roll, Pastrami, The blt, Deep South, New England, The blt Roll, Maine, Connecticut, French Fries, Roast Beef, Connecticut Roll, Maine Roll, Chicken Sandwich, The LBI Roll, K Chicken Fingers, New England Roll

Delish! So glad we gave Mystic a try. Our group of 8 enjoyed every single bite!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Connecticut Lobster Roll

I went here the other day to quick grab some food for my ride home up to north jersey with a massive hangover after a less-than-ideal family vacation and I have to say the woman who took my order was amazing. She was so nice and even brought the food out to my car cause she saw I went out to sit. Then, look at these freaking fries (crab cheese fries). These were FIRE. and they did not skimp on the crab meat at all, as you can see. Also got 2 lobster rolls which unfortunately I didn't get pictures of but again, amazing. 10 out of 10, delicious.

Food: 5

Service: 5

I think Mystic Lobster/ Park Central is a fantastic much needed addition to our beach community. The food is great, sandwiches are terrific.
I only wish that you offered a regular sit down breakfast, especially during the summer months. If you look around there are not too many breakfast locations in our area.
Also you need to give it a chance. Changing things in a NY min doesn't help!

We've been twice for the early bird special. The crab cakes and Connecticut lobster rolls are fabulous. We've had great servers both time...thanks Joan for great service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Omg ....the crab cakes and lobster rolls are to die for as well as the Chicken Parm for those who don't partake in seafood. Joan was the best server ....so friendly. Can't wait to come back next

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Connecticut Lobster Roll, New England

Wife and I stopped in cuz we love lobsta and we’re not disappointed. Had the conn lobsta roll and it was full of the delicious meat. Little container of Cole slaw and pickle was perfect. Finger lickin good. We will be back for a sit down meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Connecticut Lobster Roll