Gallery Pizza

2905 New Brooklyn Erial Rd, Sicklerville
(856) 346-0040

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amina B

I am obsessed with Gallery Pizza! Ever since I moved to south jersey I was scouting for the best local pizza joint and I am so happy I found Gallery. Every single order is done perfectly, fresh, hot, and on time! All the staff are very kind and attentive. The pizza is amazing! We have tried so many different items here and enjoy every last bite! Keep up the amazing work, this is definitely the best pizza in the area! 5 stars all around and you are missing out if you dont come here.

Darryl Ackerman

Best pizza in the area

Nicole Gwen

We’ve been regular customers for several years now. The pizza, cheesesteaks and wings are our favorite. Overall pretty consistent food. The service really depends on who answers the phone. Most of the time the person is really nice and helpful but there are a handful of times where a girl who answers isn’t as nice. So the experience isn’t always a 5 star between the food and service, but most days it is.

Christine Prendergast

Gallery is a Erial staple, been coming here since I was a kid.

Lisa Randolph

nothing like waiting for your food 1st you get well your order is not here must be on its way well after well over n hour when i know it never took this long before. I call back n the girl never put in my order idk what she did with it.

TBizkit

The BEST Sicilian pizza around!

Mike Both

I think im addicted to their pizza. It’s delicious and the staff are always friendly and welcoming.

Dan Keyes

Ordered a Sicilian pizza, well it seemed bland and really not alot of cheese, that being said we have bought this item before. And loved it and I posted on it. So good goes with the ..Soso !!

Shani

Took my family to this place, we always loved their pizza. My husband had been going here since he was a child. It was completely normal for us to either take a pizza to go or dine in. We went in the place to dine in a few days ago and it was a nightmare. I ordered two pizza’s one with pepperoni and the other plain total 58$ just for two large pizzas and one Sicilian slice. Horrible price, the lady at the register was decent enough. When we got our pizza they tasted like dish soap. At first I thought it was my taste buds because I am pregnant so I just threw it aside and tried another, that cheese one tasted like it was nothing but dish soap I couldn’t keep it in my mouth. My husband and kids smelled it but for some reason the lady at the register couldn’t smell it or as she put it, she didn’t have “super smell.” First of all you don’t need to have super smell to smell and taste dawn detergent. My kids, could not finish eating either pizza. They took the cheese off an it was still bad. They replaced, the cheese pizza, we took it to go because come on that was not cool and I couldn’t get the soap taste out of my mouth. Owner was nice and understanding. Once we got home, we tried the remake and it still had the hint of soap but we just threw it out. We definitely will not be going back at all. I don’t know what happened between years ago and now but everything has gone downhill. Edit to response to owner, Sir, yes you did. You came out and told us they must have didn't wash their hands correctly. You apologized, my whole family smelled the soap. The pizza was absolutely inedible. This was my husbands and daughter’s favorite place to go. Instead of just being honest you chose to call my family and I liars??? My husband was right there! He's the one that told you how intense the smell was because you refused to make eye contact with me. You went directly to him. I don't need to lie about pizza or even on your place but you messed up. Instead of apologizing you choose to safe face by calling the people that actually tasted it liars. Great business management.

Stasia Jewell

Whether you choose pizza white or red, both are awesome. The cheese steaks are great, too.

Alyssa Lynch

Received my food in a timely manner only to cut it open and realize it was not what I ordered. I called the store, the girl got the manager on the phone who then argued rudely with me about what I ordered. I’m done with this place

Boss Chino

The best pizza and cheese steak Stromboli in the surrounding area.

Paul Mitch

They got some consistency going here. Keep it up! Good pie for everyone in the family.

chris castillo

Absolutely fabulous food and friendly people

Jaclyn Bradley

Great food

Loading...