If you are from North Jersey you know that pizza down in South Jersey is just not the same. Not Just Pizza blows the South Jersey competition out of the water. They are the only pizzeria from the South Jersey area that can compete with North Jersey food. 10/10 must try.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
ian blair
Definitely our new place! The cheese steak is delicious. I can't wait to try more things off the
Food: 5
Zakyah B
Not just pizza my favorite pizza restaurant!!
Michael C.
Food was horrible,chicken Parm was burnt,bread was like a brick,my wife's popcorn shrimp was over cooked and hard and dry. Never again worst food I ever had. Gross one star is too much. I took a couple bites and threw it in the trash where it belongs.
Dannylee mendez
Pizza was just how I like it (thin crust) delivery was quick and the delivery driver was the cutest and the sweetest Wish we got his name ❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Brooke Owens
Just moved near by.I am so disappointed I spent 30$ on breakfast.....One sandwich easily fed the three of us. ?Thank God, the rolls are really fresh, because we have so much food leftover.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Earp
John keeps a tight ship at his store .. love the food and
LOVE this place. Breakfast, lunch, or dinner, BUT!!!! HUGE BUT, why do you guy's repeatedly not give marinara dipping sauce with your panzeroti?!?!? It says right on the menu that it comes with it. I've even paid extra to have "extra" sauce but it still comes with no sauce. Your front end staff is awesome, they are not responsible for the kitchen staff to fill a cup with sauce and throwing it in the bag. Are y'all angry about something? Do you hate the consumer? Is it some weird secret vengeance? Did you not get enough xp in your last game of Warzone? I don't get it.
Joe Ricca
Poor customer service. I called 10 seconds after placing my order on DoorDash to make a special request since they don’t allow requests on the app. I asked the lady if my cheesesteak pizza could be made without sauce and she told me absolutely not a problem. 20 seconds later she calls me back saying they already made the pizza and it was in the oven. I asked if they could remake it the way I requested and she said no I would have to cancel my order. I told her to cancel the order and she said no problem. As soon as we hung up the phone she called back saying she can’t cancel it and I would have to do it through DoorDash. I said if they can just remake the pizza without sauce I would be more than happy to not cancel the order. She said it’s not possible. Apparently there isn’t any management on site to help and customers definitely don’t come first at this establishment. First time ordering and it’ll be my last.
Joe R.
Customer satisfaction means nothing to this establishment. They would rather loose an entire order over making a pizza the way the customer wants it. All I wanted was a cheesesteak pizza without sauce but they couldn't do it because the pizza was already in the oven. I literally called the store 10 seconds after I placed my order online to request it be made without sauce and they said no problem. Seconds after we hang up they call me back to say it was already in the oven. I asked if they could remake it without sauce and she said no because it was already made. So if that's true they are 1- extremely slow on a Sunday at 5:00 during an eagles game or 2- their pizza is premade. Either way it's unacceptable and they lost a customer.
The food was good and O thought the wait time was a little more than usual but the food made up for it
James Spooner
DoorDash messed up delivery of order, and Karen was more than helpful and even offered a 2 liter for the inconvenience. Great food, and better customer service.
Dominic D.
I usually had a good experience when I order from not just pizza !! I've lived in sicklerville for 5 years and a one min drive and 7 min walk to the place and it's my go too when I'm ordering food . I don't know what's going on there but for the pass Atlease 6 months the food has been nasty , its over or under cooked and it just doesnt taste the same . I dont know if there's a new cook or maybe the summer season but it's just not the same . I also am a familiar face and when I call they knows it's me and with that being said I usually wouldn't do this because this is usually a good place to order food from but lately it's been off and not to mention last night I order food from the online website and they took my money and gave me a tracking slip and i waited for a hour and half . I was calling nobody was answering and my food never came . i waited so long on njp that the other stores around my area closed so I didn't get to eat last night !! I go in today after I got done work to see why my phone never came and the manager was very rude and told me he doesn't have time to talk and that I the lady at the register can give me a slip that they gave me money back and that was it . I find it very rude that u couldn't listen to what I had to say let alone i order Atlease 200 - 300 plus a month there from my household for the past five years and they know me by name when I call or walk in and I was treatEd like it didn't matter what I had to say of that I didn't get my food that I ordered and paid for !! I'm highly disappointed in the why this was handle and I will not ever spend another dollar at this establishment and my school that orders big orders there every other weekend will now come to end !!! it might not be a lot or it might not matter too you but when people come to spend there hard working money at a establishment that's food hasnt been the best in the past six months !! but still ride it out because I know what the place and food could be you should take into consideration that your a business and when you mess up you make things right or atlease acknowledge your mistakes !
Bernadette D.
The food is delicious and the way it is prepared makes it Very appealing. I highly recommend them. Very accommodating also.
Sherri Evangelista Bonafiglia
We love Not Just Pizza in Sicklerville. We also like that they have a rewards system and email coupons often.
If you are from North Jersey you know that pizza down in South Jersey is just not the same. Not Just Pizza blows the South Jersey competition out of the water. They are the only pizzeria from the South Jersey area that can compete with North Jersey food. 10/10 must try.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Definitely our new place! The cheese steak is delicious. I can't wait to try more things off the
Food: 5
Not just pizza my favorite pizza restaurant!!
Food was horrible,chicken Parm was burnt,bread was like a brick,my wife's popcorn shrimp was over cooked and hard and dry. Never again worst food I ever had. Gross one star is too much. I took a couple bites and threw it in the trash where it belongs.
Pizza was just how I like it (thin crust) delivery was quick and the delivery driver was the cutest and the sweetest Wish we got his name ❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Just moved near by.I am so disappointed I spent 30$ on breakfast.....One sandwich easily fed the three of us. ?Thank God, the rolls are really fresh, because we have so much food leftover.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John keeps a tight ship at his store .. love the food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak, Pizza Fries, Steak, Chicken Tenders, Turkey Club, Sicilian Cheese Pizza, Onion Rings, Pizzas
LOVE this place. Breakfast, lunch, or dinner, BUT!!!! HUGE BUT, why do you guy's repeatedly not give marinara dipping sauce with your panzeroti?!?!? It says right on the menu that it comes with it. I've even paid extra to have "extra" sauce but it still comes with no sauce. Your front end staff is awesome, they are not responsible for the kitchen staff to fill a cup with sauce and throwing it in the bag. Are y'all angry about something? Do you hate the consumer? Is it some weird secret vengeance? Did you not get enough xp in your last game of Warzone? I don't get it.
Poor customer service. I called 10 seconds after placing my order on DoorDash to make a special request since they don’t allow requests on the app. I asked the lady if my cheesesteak pizza could be made without sauce and she told me absolutely not a problem. 20 seconds later she calls me back saying they already made the pizza and it was in the oven. I asked if they could remake it the way I requested and she said no I would have to cancel my order. I told her to cancel the order and she said no problem. As soon as we hung up the phone she called back saying she can’t cancel it and I would have to do it through DoorDash. I said if they can just remake the pizza without sauce I would be more than happy to not cancel the order. She said it’s not possible. Apparently there isn’t any management on site to help and customers definitely don’t come first at this establishment. First time ordering and it’ll be my last.
Customer satisfaction means nothing to this establishment. They would rather loose an entire order over making a pizza the way the customer wants it. All I wanted was a cheesesteak pizza without sauce but they couldn't do it because the pizza was already in the oven. I literally called the store 10 seconds after I placed my order online to request it be made without sauce and they said no problem. Seconds after we hang up they call me back to say it was already in the oven. I asked if they could remake it without sauce and she said no because it was already made. So if that's true they are 1- extremely slow on a Sunday at 5:00 during an eagles game or 2- their pizza is premade. Either way it's unacceptable and they lost a customer.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was good and O thought the wait time was a little more than usual but the food made up for it
DoorDash messed up delivery of order, and Karen was more than helpful and even offered a 2 liter for the inconvenience. Great food, and better customer service.
I usually had a good experience when I order from not just pizza !! I've lived in sicklerville for 5 years and a one min drive and 7 min walk to the place and it's my go too when I'm ordering food . I don't know what's going on there but for the pass Atlease 6 months the food has been nasty , its over or under cooked and it just doesnt taste the same . I dont know if there's a new cook or maybe the summer season but it's just not the same . I also am a familiar face and when I call they knows it's me and with that being said I usually wouldn't do this because this is usually a good place to order food from but lately it's been off and not to mention last night I order food from the online website and they took my money and gave me a tracking slip and i waited for a hour and half . I was calling nobody was answering and my food never came . i waited so long on njp that the other stores around my area closed so I didn't get to eat last night !! I go in today after I got done work to see why my phone never came and the manager was very rude and told me he doesn't have time to talk and that I the lady at the register can give me a slip that they gave me money back and that was it . I find it very rude that u couldn't listen to what I had to say let alone i order Atlease 200 - 300 plus a month there from my household for the past five years and they know me by name when I call or walk in and I was treatEd like it didn't matter what I had to say of that I didn't get my food that I ordered and paid for !! I'm highly disappointed in the why this was handle and I will not ever spend another dollar at this establishment and my school that orders big orders there every other weekend will now come to end !!! it might not be a lot or it might not matter too you but when people come to spend there hard working money at a establishment that's food hasnt been the best in the past six months !! but still ride it out because I know what the place and food could be you should take into consideration that your a business and when you mess up you make things right or atlease acknowledge your mistakes !
The food is delicious and the way it is prepared makes it Very appealing. I highly recommend them. Very accommodating also.
We love Not Just Pizza in Sicklerville. We also like that they have a rewards system and email coupons often.