Personalized and creative bakery that is so easy to work with. For the 3rd year in a row, they have surpassed our expectations. Many gluten friendly options also available!
Looooove this bake shop. Ever since I moved to the area, they are my go to for all celebrations . Best bakery hands down. If you are in doubt, I am here to tell you to go for it. Well worth it everytime
Kid-friendliness: Bright and airy shop to go in and order or pick up cake orders
Wheelchair accessibility: Very accessible via wheelchair
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Carrot Cake, Bakery, Birthday Cake, Cookie, Macaron, Custom Cakes and Birthday Cakes, Specialty Cakes, Red Velvet Cupcake
Kevin Hidalgo
Beautiful cake and Karin was easy to reach and communicate with, would absolutely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Martha Aponte
Where do I begin....from the moment I emailed my query to pickup, Karin was awesome!! She is very attentive and a pleasure to work with. The cake for my daughter's 40th was a hit. The cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious. Everyone was raving about the cake and asked where did I get it. Karin and her team did an amazing job. Blue Sheep Bake Shop is my new place to go for cakes. I'm so happy I found this little gem. You will not be disappointed.
Kid-friendliness: Cupcakes were perfect for young kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake
Vee
I wrote an inquiry for a cake and I communicated back and forth and the only thing left was for them to send me an invoice. I waited 2 weeks to receive one and never did so I decided to stop by the shop one day to check it out and since no one ever emailed me. I get there, make a purchase and ask about the invoice since I was already given a price quote and wanted to make payment since I was there and they wouldn't let me. As a result, I had to scramble and find another bakery that would be open on a Monday that would be able to make that cake. Due to the lack of customer service and how careless they were I'm giving them one star. The bakery is super small and underwhelming. Also, the brownie I ordered was average. I'm glad I went to check it out because I found a more responsible and reasonable business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Adrian Bermudez
I was beyond excited to see the final design of my graduation cake from Blue Sheep Bake Shop and it did not disappoint! The owner (Karin) was wonderful to work with and was very enthusiastic about all of my input for possible designs for the cake. All of my guests were very impressed with the cake, and it was very delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
Francesca Pacheco
I have ordered from this bakery over 5x and they never disappoint! Beautifully decorated cakes and delicious flavor Whenever we serve their cake at our party there is always someone who asks where we got the cake from. So happy that this bakery is in my town, and the owner is very communicative and works with you. 10/10 reccomend 🤩
Great cakes! Amazing customer service! Exactly one week before my son-in-law‘s party I put a request in to blue sheep, knowing it was a long shot to get a cake that was custom in only a week. To my surprise they answered my email on a Sunday evening, and in fact, called me to discuss the details of my order. We received an exceedingly beautiful cake as promised at 11:30 AM the next Saturday 1/2 hour before the party. The details on the cake were exquisite and the taste was outstanding. We have paid three times the amount for a cake with fondant decor elsewhere but those did not taste very good, and the inside portion was dry. The blue sheep bakery is our new go to for our entire family. That’s a pretty tall order!
I ordered a Friends themed cake and cookies for my daughters 30th birthday! I was amazed at how wonderful they came out. So much better than I could have imagined. Working with Karin to create the perfect cake design was fun, she had great ideas and was so patient! The fondant couch on top of the cake came out looking like a real mini sofa! The cake filling.....oreo cookies and creme.....was a huge hit with everyone. The cake served everyone at the party and we had almost half still for everyone to take home to enjoy. Im glad I had put aside 2 of the cookies before the party, they were perfect with my coffee this morning. Absolutely will order my cakes from Blue Sheep in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cookie
jackie reinhart
We ordered for the first time at Blue Sheep for Christmas goodies. We live an hour away and I must say it was definitely worth the drive!!! This is our new go to bakery!! The Christmas tree not only tasted so delicious it had actual Christmas lights that turned on. It was the highlight at our table by all our family and friends. Everything in the bakery looked amazing! Can’t wait to go back and try more goodies!! Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon France
I stumbled upon this shop while I was having an out-of-state date weekend with my partner, and we were absolutely blown away! It was late, there was a very kind and sweet person working by themselves (I wish I caught your name!) They were so kind, patient, and welcoming. My partner got a brownie and I got some macarons. The person working recommended the honey fig macaron and WOW it was so delicious. I tried the lemon raspberry, creme brulee, lavender chai, and my partner got a birthday cake macaron (it happened to be his birthday). 10/10 would absolutely love to return. In fact, I did go back the next day to get more macarons but the same person was not working. Thank you again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaron
Heidi
I recently ordered two gluten free cakes to celebrate my twins birthday. Upon arriving at the bakery to pick up the order, the cakes were not ready. They weren’t ready because despite receiving an order confirmation and receipt for payment of the order, there was a technology glitch that caused the order to not be received by the bakery. This glitch wasn’t discovered until the day my cakes were due to be picked up. In addition, the pickup day was Thanksgiving eve, i.e. the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. Once the bakery staff realized the significance of the issue, they contacted the bakery owner. The bakery owner allowed the staff to provide me with her cell number so I could contact her directly to discuss how to rectify the issue. The bakery owner was extremely apologetic and offered to bake the cakes Thanksgiving morning to ensure my kids had their cakes for their birthday. I was hesitant to take her up on her offer because I felt terrible that she had to work on Thanksgiving, but she assured me that she was happy to do so. The cakes were amazing (as usual) and our crisis was averted. I’ve been going to Blue Sheep since they opened…not only are their baked items delicious, but they also provide high quality customer service. I wholeheartedly appreciate the owner offering to bake the cakes, especially on Thanksgiving morning. Lastly, there was clearly a technology glitch which caused the issue. Some people would’ve gladly used that as an excuse to not hold themselves accountable, but she did not do that. She was adamant about making the situation right even though it wasn’t directly her fault. I highly recommend Blue Sheep for their quality/delicious baked goods, but also because customer experience is important to them. Thank you again for making my kids 15th birthday so special!!
What can I say about the Blue Sheep and their cakes that has not probably been said. My wife enjoys Captain Morgan and Coke so for her 50th birthday I tasked Blue Sheep to make me a cake off a picture I provided. The cake looked so realistic that guests thought it was a barrel that I bought as a decoration. Karin and her employees did a wonderful job and even put my wife’s picture on the bottle as labels. The cake was moist and tasted great. But I must highlight Karin again. She was responding to my emails over the weekend which I thought was just amazing. Blue Sheep is a must to consider for your next party.
Personalized and creative bakery that is so easy to work with. For the 3rd year in a row, they have surpassed our expectations. Many gluten friendly options also available!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten friendly options!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Bakery, Birthday Cake
Looooove this bake shop. Ever since I moved to the area, they are my go to for all celebrations . Best bakery hands down. If you are in doubt, I am here to tell you to go for it. Well worth it everytime
Kid-friendliness: Bright and airy shop to go in and order or pick up cake orders
Wheelchair accessibility: Very accessible via wheelchair
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Carrot Cake, Bakery, Birthday Cake, Cookie, Macaron, Custom Cakes and Birthday Cakes, Specialty Cakes, Red Velvet Cupcake
Beautiful cake and Karin was easy to reach and communicate with, would absolutely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Where do I begin....from the moment I emailed my query to pickup, Karin was awesome!! She is very attentive and a pleasure to work with. The cake for my daughter's 40th was a hit. The cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious. Everyone was raving about the cake and asked where did I get it. Karin and her team did an amazing job. Blue Sheep Bake Shop is my new place to go for cakes. I'm so happy I found this little gem. You will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Macaron, Custom Cakes and Birthday Cakes, Magic Bars
Beautiful cake and cupcakes!
Kid-friendliness: Cupcakes were perfect for young kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake
I wrote an inquiry for a cake and I communicated back and forth and the only thing left was for them to send me an invoice. I waited 2 weeks to receive one and never did so I decided to stop by the shop one day to check it out and since no one ever emailed me. I get there, make a purchase and ask about the invoice since I was already given a price quote and wanted to make payment since I was there and they wouldn't let me. As a result, I had to scramble and find another bakery that would be open on a Monday that would be able to make that cake. Due to the lack of customer service and how careless they were I'm giving them one star. The bakery is super small and underwhelming. Also, the brownie I ordered was average. I'm glad I went to check it out because I found a more responsible and reasonable business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I was beyond excited to see the final design of my graduation cake from Blue Sheep Bake Shop and it did not disappoint! The owner (Karin) was wonderful to work with and was very enthusiastic about all of my input for possible designs for the cake. All of my guests were very impressed with the cake, and it was very delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
I have ordered from this bakery over 5x and they never disappoint! Beautifully decorated cakes and delicious flavor
Whenever we serve their cake at our party there is always someone who asks where we got the cake from.
So happy that this bakery is in my town, and the owner is very communicative and works with you.
10/10 reccomend 🤩
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Bakery, Birthday Cake, Cookie, Custom Cakes and Birthday Cakes
Great cakes! Amazing customer service! Exactly one week before my son-in-law‘s party I put a request in to blue sheep, knowing it was a long shot to get a cake that was custom in only a week. To my surprise they answered my email on a Sunday evening, and in fact, called me to discuss the details of my order. We received an exceedingly beautiful cake as promised at 11:30 AM the next Saturday 1/2 hour before the party. The details on the cake were exquisite and the taste was outstanding. We have paid three times the amount for a cake with fondant decor elsewhere but those did not taste very good, and the inside portion was dry. The blue sheep bakery is our new go to for our entire family. That’s a pretty tall order!
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake, Bakery, Birthday Cake
Beautiful and delicious cake for my brother 40 Birthday Celebration and for our daughter 13 birthday 🎂 Highly recommended ♥️❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a Friends themed cake and cookies for my daughters 30th birthday! I was amazed at how wonderful they came out. So much better than I could have imagined. Working with Karin to create the perfect cake design was fun, she had great ideas and was so patient! The fondant couch on top of the cake came out looking like a real mini sofa! The cake filling.....oreo cookies and creme.....was a huge hit with everyone. The cake served everyone at the party and we had almost half still for everyone to take home to enjoy. Im glad I had put aside 2 of the cookies before the party, they were perfect with my coffee this morning. Absolutely will order my cakes from Blue Sheep in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cookie
We ordered for the first time at Blue Sheep for Christmas goodies. We live an hour away and I must say it was definitely worth the drive!!! This is our new go to bakery!! The Christmas tree not only tasted so delicious it had actual Christmas lights that turned on. It was the highlight at our table by all our family and friends. Everything in the bakery looked amazing! Can’t wait to go back and try more goodies!! Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stumbled upon this shop while I was having an out-of-state date weekend with my partner, and we were absolutely blown away! It was late, there was a very kind and sweet person working by themselves (I wish I caught your name!) They were so kind, patient, and welcoming. My partner got a brownie and I got some macarons. The person working recommended the honey fig macaron and WOW it was so delicious. I tried the lemon raspberry, creme brulee, lavender chai, and my partner got a birthday cake macaron (it happened to be his birthday). 10/10 would absolutely love to return. In fact, I did go back the next day to get more macarons but the same person was not working. Thank you again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaron
I recently ordered two gluten free cakes to celebrate my twins birthday. Upon arriving at the bakery to pick up the order, the cakes were not ready. They weren’t ready because despite receiving an order confirmation and receipt for payment of the order, there was a technology glitch that caused the order to not be received by the bakery. This glitch wasn’t discovered until the day my cakes were due to be picked up. In addition, the pickup day was Thanksgiving eve, i.e. the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. Once the bakery staff realized the significance of the issue, they contacted the bakery owner. The bakery owner allowed the staff to provide me with her cell number so I could contact her directly to discuss how to rectify the issue. The bakery owner was extremely apologetic and offered to bake the cakes Thanksgiving morning to ensure my kids had their cakes for their birthday. I was hesitant to take her up on her offer because I felt terrible that she had to work on Thanksgiving, but she assured me that she was happy to do so. The cakes were amazing (as usual) and our crisis was averted. I’ve been going to Blue Sheep since they opened…not only are their baked items delicious, but they also provide high quality customer service. I wholeheartedly appreciate the owner offering to bake the cakes, especially on Thanksgiving morning. Lastly, there was clearly a technology glitch which caused the issue. Some people would’ve gladly used that as an excuse to not hold themselves accountable, but she did not do that. She was adamant about making the situation right even though it wasn’t directly her fault. I highly recommend Blue Sheep for their quality/delicious baked goods, but also because customer experience is important to them. Thank you again for making my kids 15th birthday so special!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake, Bakery, Birthday Cake, Cookie, Macaron
What can I say about the Blue Sheep and their cakes that has not probably been said. My wife enjoys Captain Morgan and Coke so for her 50th birthday I tasked Blue Sheep to make me a cake off a picture I provided. The cake looked so realistic that guests thought it was a barrel that I bought as a decoration. Karin and her employees did a wonderful job and even put my wife’s picture on the bottle as labels. The cake was moist and tasted great. But I must highlight Karin again. She was responding to my emails over the weekend which I thought was just amazing. Blue Sheep is a must to consider for your next party.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...