Design was beautiful! Flavors were right on point! Service was prompt and professional! Communication was timely. Would definitely order from Blue Sheep Bake Shop again. Everyone at the party raved about the cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Lori Kusterer-Farley
10/10! Ordered a custom cake for my daughter’s confirmation. It was gorgeous ! And it tasted amazing ! The buttercream was so fluffy, the cake was perfect texture and the Oreo filling was delish ! The design detail was amazing. I would definitely order again for other occasions. Thanks for making it special for her.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jolaine Moffitt
Blue Sheep Bake Shop had a very tall order with the cake I had requested. I wanted it for a wedding rehearsal dinner and asked that the cake include both the bride’s and the groom’s many personal interests. They also worked around a 3D printed image of their dog that I had made and wanted to include as a cake topper. BSBC came through and went above all expectations! The cake was what pulled the whole dinner theme together. The bride and groom were so touched and the guests had jaw dropping reactions. But equally if not most important, the cake was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend Blue Sheep Bake Shop.
Absolutely LOVE Blue Sheep! Their cakes are pure magic—gorgeous, scrumptious, and the star of every event I host! Karin and her team are super friendly and always nail my design vision. 10/10 Can’t recommend them enough!!
Stephanie Perruzza
Delicious selection of cupcakes, ice creams and brownie/speciality bars! My kids loved the death by chocolate and Oreo cupcakes and my husband and I were big fans of the magic bar, Dubai chocolate brownie and the Italian tri-colored bar was INSANE! Let them get to room temperature if you’re storing them in the fridge. Great little spot for a sweet treat!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Specialty Cakes, Brownies, Magic Bars, Oreo Cupcake, Death by Chocolate Cupcake
Krystle Bowers
Karin Giamella and her team are nothing short of perfection when it comes to customer service!
This birthday cake was requested for a snickers fan as well as a wonderful human being and though I couldn't order in person there was no need because they delivered as if I had!
Also having an awesome sense of humor when it came to the insignia! 🤣🤣🤣
Not only can I wait to order again, I will be paying a visit the next time I'm in NJ. You guys are awesome, keep doing what you're doing!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
Kassandra Burgos
Karin and Blue Sheep Bake Shop are absolutely amazing! She not only created the most beautiful wedding cake for me, but personally delivered it as well. She completely captured my vision, was incredibly helpful, and communicated with me every step of the way—answering all my questions with patience and care.
Karin is so personable and genuinely makes the experience special. She actually did my baby shower cake almost 9 years ago, and I knew I could trust her again for such an important day. I chose the coconut guava cake and it was a hit—enough to feed all 40 of my guests with leftovers (people even took cake home!).
If you’re looking for a baker who goes above and beyond, I highly recommend Karin and Blue Sheep Bake Shop. You will not be disappointed!
The only place I’ll ever get my cakes. Karin is so responsive and I completely trust her to add a special twist when I don’t have a picture but a vision in mind. Her cakes always look stunning and taste even better. Our guests rave every time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Fabiula Silva
Good (and delicious) variety of brownies and ice-cream. Theirs cakes are beautiful.
Everyone raved about the cake at my Son’ baptism! Not only was it delicious, but it was so beautiful! Can’t wait to use them for my daughter’s birthday party!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Specialty Cakes
Debb Leticia
The Blue Sheep Bake Shop was absolutely amazing to work with! From the very beginning, their communication was excellent—they took the time to go over every detail of the cake design and made sure everything was exactly as I envisioned. They coordinated everything seamlessly, from the design process to the delivery, and made the whole experience stress-free. The cake not only looked incredible but also tasted just as good. Their professionalism and exceptional service truly stood out. I highly recommend Blue Sheep Bake Shop to anyone looking for a special cake or baked goods—you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Alexa Ciattarelli
Karin and the Blue Sheep team were excellent to work with! They made a fantastic custom cake for our wedding and it was just perfect! Highly recommend supporting this local business for all your cake and ice cream needs!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Ofelia “Alee” Olivas
Blue sheep bakery. You should give your employees a raise. Today it was crazy and they never lost their smile 😊 Great Minecraft cake 🎂
Shamyrah Carreker
My daughter's birthday cake was delicious and beautiful. We received non stop compliments on the taste and how gorgeous it was. Karen went above and beyond to make sure all the details were correct and we had the cake in time. I can't wait to use Blue Sheep again for my next event.
Design was beautiful! Flavors were right on point! Service was prompt and professional! Communication was timely. Would definitely order from Blue Sheep Bake Shop again. Everyone at the party raved about the cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
10/10! Ordered a custom cake for my daughter’s confirmation. It was gorgeous ! And it tasted amazing ! The buttercream was so fluffy, the cake was perfect texture and the Oreo filling was delish ! The design detail was amazing. I would definitely order again for other occasions. Thanks for making it special for her.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Blue Sheep Bake Shop had a very tall order with the cake I had requested. I wanted it for a wedding rehearsal dinner and asked that the cake include both the bride’s and the groom’s many personal interests. They also worked around a 3D printed image of their dog that I had made and wanted to include as a cake topper. BSBC came through and went above all expectations! The cake was what pulled the whole dinner theme together. The bride and groom were so touched and the guests had jaw dropping reactions. But equally if not most important, the cake was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend Blue Sheep Bake Shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Wedding Cake, Specialty Cakes
Absolutely LOVE Blue Sheep! Their cakes are pure magic—gorgeous, scrumptious, and the star of every event I host! Karin and her team are super friendly and always nail my design vision. 10/10 Can’t recommend them enough!!
Delicious selection of cupcakes, ice creams and brownie/speciality bars! My kids loved the death by chocolate and Oreo cupcakes and my husband and I were big fans of the magic bar, Dubai chocolate brownie and the Italian tri-colored bar was INSANE! Let them get to room temperature if you’re storing them in the fridge. Great little spot for a sweet treat!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Specialty Cakes, Brownies, Magic Bars, Oreo Cupcake, Death by Chocolate Cupcake
Karin Giamella and her team are nothing short of perfection when it comes to customer service!
This birthday cake was requested for a snickers fan as well as a wonderful human being and though I couldn't order in person there was no need because they delivered as if I had!
Also having an awesome sense of humor when it came to the insignia! 🤣🤣🤣
Not only can I wait to order again, I will be paying a visit the next time I'm in NJ. You guys are awesome, keep doing what you're doing!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
Karin and Blue Sheep Bake Shop are absolutely amazing! She not only created the most beautiful wedding cake for me, but personally delivered it as well. She completely captured my vision, was incredibly helpful, and communicated with me every step of the way—answering all my questions with patience and care.
Karin is so personable and genuinely makes the experience special. She actually did my baby shower cake almost 9 years ago, and I knew I could trust her again for such an important day. I chose the coconut guava cake and it was a hit—enough to feed all 40 of my guests with leftovers (people even took cake home!).
If you’re looking for a baker who goes above and beyond, I highly recommend Karin and Blue Sheep Bake Shop. You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Wedding Cake, Specialty Cakes
The only place I’ll ever get my cakes. Karin is so responsive and I completely trust her to add a special twist when I don’t have a picture but a vision in mind. Her cakes always look stunning and taste even better. Our guests rave every time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Good (and delicious) variety of brownies and ice-cream.
Theirs cakes are beautiful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
DELICIOUS!
Restaurantji Recommends
Everyone raved about the cake at my Son’ baptism! Not only was it delicious, but it was so beautiful! Can’t wait to use them for my daughter’s birthday party!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Specialty Cakes
The Blue Sheep Bake Shop was absolutely amazing to work with! From the very beginning, their communication was excellent—they took the time to go over every detail of the cake design and made sure everything was exactly as I envisioned. They coordinated everything seamlessly, from the design process to the delivery, and made the whole experience stress-free. The cake not only looked incredible but also tasted just as good. Their professionalism and exceptional service truly stood out. I highly recommend Blue Sheep Bake Shop to anyone looking for a special cake or baked goods—you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Karin and the Blue Sheep team were excellent to work with! They made a fantastic custom cake for our wedding and it was just perfect! Highly recommend supporting this local business for all your cake and ice cream needs!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Blue sheep bakery. You should give your employees a raise. Today it was crazy and they never lost their smile 😊 Great Minecraft cake 🎂
My daughter's birthday cake was delicious and beautiful. We received non stop compliments on the taste and how gorgeous it was. Karen went above and beyond to make sure all the details were correct and we had the cake in time. I can't wait to use Blue Sheep again for my next event.
Loading...