Sciortino's Harbor Lights

We shared a pepperoni pizza and salad with our granddaughters for lunch! So much more fun than McDonald's.
We ate in the dining room and it was quiet and nice.
Great service.

Had the pizza and cold beer excellent night

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They've been around for a long time I love their pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is an edited post. Myself family and friends loved coming here. Over the past six months we noticed a change on the sauce and the pizza the last couple of visits.
Pizza - ordered 2 pies, a small and a large. The large was great but the small was completely different. It tasted like a frozen pizza from the supermarket.
Last visit - ordered 2 large pies, again I would swear I was eating a frozen pizza. Also got a chicken Parm dinner, very bland and average and didn't have that typical sweet sauce taste.
I will definitely give it one more try and hope things change back so I can adjust my rating back up

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Amazing food. Thier hours are incorrect. Tried to go on a weekday lunch and they were closed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My girl and I have been there before...the first time I would've given them a 4...but this last time was horrible, the appetizers were delivered to us with paper plates..and the food had little to no taste, the server/ waitress was very nice and the food came out in an average time...
We will not be going there again.

Sauce doesn't taste the same anymore. Very bland. Texture is thick.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Been going to Scortinos since the Perth Amboy days & its always been my favorite...until last night. Went out with family members for a birthday & have to say it was disappointing. The fried calamari & Caesar salad were great as always, but what used to be the star of the show, the pizza was disappointing. Ordered 3 meatball pies, a family favorite and only 1 was the thin crust the other 2 were thick & soggy. The sauce was the same but overall the thick, spongy crust ruined the flavor of the pie. Not to say I won't try again because I love Sciortinos but if it happens again, I'm done. I can get bad pizza anywhere else in NJ. I go to Sciortinos for a reason. So 😔

I was born in Perth Amboy when the hospital was called General Hospital and now am 50 and live in Chesterfield NJ. I still drive 40 to 50 minutes to pickup a bunch of pies. This place is still great as ever. My grandmother used to take me as a kid when the shop was near the tracks in Perth Amboy. Harbor lights staff is very helpful and pizza is amazing. Today is my birthday and I will always come back to this GEM! Thank you for the still strong delicious pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have been going to Sciortino's for over 50 years, my parents and grandparents before that. Every year I stop in to get a pie, usually hit or miss, but usually still decent. Monday 5/18 I called in for a large plain, I arrived before the time, the hostess said it was not ready yet and it was done at the time I was told on the phone. the pizza was not hot or very good, sauce barley had any flavor, the crust had a burnt taste to it, maybe the oven wasn't clean? In my 50 years of going to Sciortinos I have never thrown a pizza away, this was a first. Maybe this was just a 1 off, but looking at the other reviews, it sounds looks like this has been going on for some time. Hope you guys get your act together. paying $20 for a large plain pie I would have expected better quality and the taste and quality I have know for years. Also would have been nice to have a sign that you charge extra for credit card use.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Good food, friendly staff, Nice atmosphere. Only thing missing was background music; maybe some doo-woop, Billy Joel, Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin etc. overall good experience, definitely recommend.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

If your girl doesn’t know what she wants BRING HER HERE!!!!! Hector always out does himself!!!! Not only does he have a little bit of everything on his menu he will try his best to make something work… always go too!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered takeout. Pizza sauce was too sweet. Gave school lunch pizza vibes. Too expensive for the most mid tasting pie 👎👎👎👎

quality has for sure gone downhill! like other reviews state they are reheating frozen pizza or pizza that has been sitting there. i ordered a half tray and it had overcooked pizza with sprinkled shredded cheese. pizza barely had any sauce another indication it was frozen…dry and burnt. will not order again used to love this pizza

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Good pizza and ice cold beer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5