Causeway Ice Cream

113 Causeway St, South River
(732) 254-2130

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Linda Lam

Love how they have a variety here. I ordered pistachio ice cream and it came with real pistachios

Marcela Gonzalez

I'm so disappointed. I've been going to the causeway for awhile now. This is the 1st time I went where the ice cream is horrible, didn't get what I asked for,. Was looking forward to a great treat and sad to say just didn't do it. šŸ˜ž

Julianne Perry

My family and I enjoy causeway! I love that there is a drive thru. I’ve been coming here since I was a kid. My mom would take us on ā€˜mystery rides’ and we’d end up at causeway! Such a fun past-time. I now do the same with my kids. We love supporting a local business.

Fred Barnetas

Causeway Ice Cream – South River, NJ

Causeway Ice Cream is a hidden gem in South River that I can’t believe I just discovered after living in the area for 15 years. It’s an affordable, family-friendly spot offering both soft serve and about 30 flavors of hard ice cream. The menu covers all the classics—sundaes, banana splits, waffles, and waffle cones—making it the kind of place where everyone can find something they love.

We went on a warm Sunday night, and the place was packed with families enjoying themselves. There’s plenty of seating—some in front by the ice cream counter, more on the side of the building, and even a tent setup in the back where a separate food cart serves dinner items. Both the ice cream shop and the food cart were busy, which gave the whole place a lively, welcoming vibe.

I ordered a medium chocolate chocolate chip hot fudge sundae with sprinkles, whipped cream, and a cherry, while my girlfriend went with pistachio ice cream in a waffle cone with sprinkles. Both were delicious, and the price was very reasonable—just $13 total for the two of us.

No, it’s not the fanciest ice cream parlor, and it may not be the ā€œbestā€ ice cream I’ve ever had, but the charm is in the atmosphere. It feels like a homestyle, established neighborhood spot where families and couples have been coming for years—and will continue to for many more.

I’d absolutely recommend Causeway Ice Cream if you’re looking for a comfortable, affordable place to bring your kids, a date, or even your grandkids. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel at home.

Michael Dennie

The employees are awesome. Ice cream is top notch. Haven't tried the ices yet, but looking forward to it.

Martin Spielman

Yummy. Big selection of treats. Hard and soft ice cream.

Isabella Mento

Service is great! Every time I come I’m satisfied with my experience

christina soliman

This is me and my family’s favorite ice cream place! The staff is so friendly and the ice cream is much better than magnificos.

Madison Maher

Causeway has the BEST ice cream! The new owners are so kind and friendly. The staff are so wonderful and always have a smile on their faces! I could not recommend this place enough!!!

Jes Jon

Local ice cream spot. Convenient location. Parking lot. Drive-thru available. Delicious and savory sweet treat. 9.8/10

Penny H

Causeway is hands-down our favorite ice cream spot!
They offer an incredible variety of flavors and toppings, so there’s always something new to try. The convenience of the drive-thru is a huge plus, especially on hot days or when you’re in a hurry.

Today, I tried their special Dubai Sundae—and wow, it was unbelievably good! Rich, flavorful, and totally unique. If you’re an ice cream lover, this place is a must-visit.

(Used their social media photo as we ate it too quickly!)

Matthew Eggers

Diffently not one star awesome friendly made my sundea just the way I ordered

Susan

The best ice cream, best sprinkles with melted marshmallow, best service! Thank you for the extra sprinkles today! I needed all this sweetness on not such a great day. Thanks for making my day !

Raymond Bansemer

I love this place, the best around.

Eric Presnal

Today I bought what I thought was homemade butter pecan 2 scoops in a sugar cone.what I received was vanilla ice cream with couple of whole pecans tossed in the cup with the sugar cone upside down in the container.

Loading...