The Portuguese Fisherman

11 Jackson St, South River
(732) 238-5188

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kendal

We hadn't been to the Portuguese Fisherman in almost 30 years. We ordered the paelha mariscos and enjoyed it. Dining area is loud. We recommend a later meal for a quieter, more intimate experience.

Ira

The place is amazing and the food is very good. The one petty thing by that really annoys me is that they don't do free refills on soda. One time me I ordered a soda and then the waiter asked if I would like a refill so I said yes and then there was a charge for two drinks. The waiter should at least tell us that the red would be a charge for the refill. Know that before you order

Jack

While I usually order the Chicken in Port Wine/Mushroom sauce because it never disappoints, had grilled sea bass which was a special last night. Food Quality, Quantity, Service, and Pace were all excellent. Great bar vibe as well at this restaurant.

Richard

Our food was delicious. One person had the Sardines, I had the Octopus - awesome. Someone else had the Stuffed Shrimp and the other parties had the Salmon. Everyone was very pleased. The servers were very professional and knowledgable

David

Good food and service....didn't like that they didn't put in appetizers first and needed the whole order...never happened before

John

My wife and I went for our anniversary dinner. They went out of their way to make us feel special. They even gave us an anniversary card signed by all of the employees. The food was great, and the service was fantastic.

Armando

We are traveling from Connecticut to celebrating my husband's birthday, and everything was absolutely wonderful. The food was delicious, the waiters were very attentive, and the atmosphere was truly beautiful. We are very grateful to everyone who worked to make my husband feel so welcome.

Melissa

Portuguese fisherman is our favorite restaurant. They never fail to make an amazing meal & experience.

Joseph

Really good Portuguese food, enjoyable experience all around, the peach champagne sangria was delicious. Will definitely be back soon.

Cynthia

This restaurant was highly recommended to me and in the end it did not disappoint. We went for our anniversary and I will definitely be returning. The service was impeccable from all the waiters we had and the atmosphere was welcoming. The food was amazing from the seafood soup, shrimp in garlic, clams casino, filet mignon, lobster tail, skirt steak and saffron rice with potatoes and veggies. Drinks were good as well. The Anniversary card was definitely a nice touch! Thank you!!

Sandy

We've been to this restaurant many times but this was our first visit that we couldn't wait to get out of there. We were a party of 6 seated next to another party of 6 grown men that were the rudest, loudest, drunkest and obnoxious men we've ever encountered. We couldn't hear each other to have a conversation which is the reason we had to get out of there as quickly as possible.

Gloria

Three of the four entrees were very good. The fourth left some things to be desired. The oysters were very small and not a good value. I cannot verify the taste of the fish soup but the person who ordered it was not satisfied. He took a few sips then did not eat any more. It looked good but that's all I can say. I believe our waiter was a new, inexperienced person. He did try to help but he was not able to answer our questions readily. After our food was served it was difficult to get his attention again. I have had lunch there in the past and had much better service at that time. Would I return?maybe.

Glynn

We keep going back because the food is excellent, the service is exceptional, and it a relaxed atmosphere. Love it. Highly recommended.

William

This was my second time at the Portuguese fisherman and the meal was just as good as the first. Their garlic chicken was excellent.

Fred

We have been going to the Portuguese fisherman for years. We love the food,ambience ,service and staff.Everything is outstanding. You will not be disappointed.

Loading...