Not a good experience with a delivered Seafood Salad. !!.No Seasoning,dressings or bread . Plain 2 boiled shrimps and boiled calamari, Called to se what happened, EVERINIG NEEDED TO BE ASKED FOR OR ADDED My fault they said ,.The customer is at fault attitude needs to change.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dylan Onorevole
Casa Mia is my go to Pizza spot in Sparta. Above and beyond service. Must try the Tuscany Chicken pie!
Azniza R.S
Best Italian food!! Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kat C
We moved here from the Jersey Shore, so we're more than a little picky about our pizza. I'm also 100% Italian and grew up around authentic Italian food, and Casa Mia doesn't disappoint. Hands down, this is the best pizza around. And we have tried a ton of places. First, the delivery is always awesome. They arrive on time, every time, and they're super polite. Second, if you chose to dine in, the wait staff is wonderful. Even when they're busy (and they get super busy, for good reason), you never have to wait for a table or for your food. And they know how to make everyone feel welcome and at home. It truly is a family establishment. In a town like Sparta where everyone knows everyone, you appreciate restaurants like Casa Mia and the value they bring to the community/all the ways they give back. But back to the food. I recently tried their personal vegan pizza and loved it, and this is coming from a former vegan so I have something to compare it to. They always have your order ready to go immediately and take the time to ask how you your day is going and put in that extra effort. I have a few big events coming up and I'll be having Casa Mia cater them because I know the food will be on point and on time. They catered a party of ours last year and were exactly on time. If you want legit GOOD, authentic pizza and owners/staff they value their customers and know you by name, this is your spot. There is a reason people come from all over to check this place out. They've been here for 31 years and are a staple in the community. Thanks for great service and even better food. And no, I don't work here. I just appreciate good people and brag when I find awesome food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Babich Jr.
Its another italian restaurant. We went there for dinner with some friends of ours visiting. Food was good, server was good to. We didn't care for the stuffed artichoke, it left like just eating bread and not the artichoke it self. Not that bad prices, would go back again to try some different foods.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Nigel Charles
Good staff and food. Difficulty finding parking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Peter
Great little Italian restaurant. Parking cab be tricky though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark
Decent pizza for the location. Quickly served.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mark Pierson
Me & my wife ate lunch here on Sat. 8/29/25. Food was delicious & our server , Dynasty, was awesome. Would definitely go back next time we decide to visit Lake Mohawk.
Absolutely the worst dried out pizza in the area. New pie man? He sucks. Must have forgot the pizza was in the oven.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Kimberly Aiello
This used to be the best pizza in Sparta, but over the last six months it’s completely gone to downhill . The pizza is disgusting now completely dried out and overdone. I don’t know what happened because their pizza used to be so good. I’ve given this place a couple chances thinking that maybe they just had a bad day but the last three times has been horrible so I am now done. They will not get my business anymore. There’s way better places I can go to!! Just look at the picture… This looks like pizza that’s been sitting there all day, but this was made fresh. And the picture was taken only 15 minutes after bringing it home. Dave Portnoy would have spit this rock hard pizza out.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Emmett Wilkes
Best Pizza in New Jersey!!! Great Italian Food!!! I've been a customer for THIRTY years - Mike and Victor (the owners) are great guys and the whole staff is awesome. The whole Casa Mia team is always striving to bring their customers tastey food and they succeed! Thank you Casa Mia. Delicious food. :) And this is important: They shred their own cheese for their pizza and all their offeringss so no worry of it having that anti-mold chemical that the cheese industry is putting in all the pre-shredded cheese they sell to restaurants and other pizzerias.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Manuel Cabrero
The breaded veal dish was excellent the spaghetti and salad accompanied were good too. Good prices as well as military discount.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Rajesh Patil
The people working here are nice but the food is no where close to quality that deserve a revisit. The portion are big but flavorless.
The best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not a good experience with a delivered Seafood Salad. !!.No Seasoning,dressings or bread . Plain 2 boiled shrimps and boiled calamari, Called to se what happened, EVERINIG NEEDED TO BE ASKED FOR OR ADDED My fault they said ,.The customer is at fault attitude needs to change.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Casa Mia is my go to Pizza spot in Sparta. Above and beyond service. Must try the Tuscany Chicken pie!
Best Italian food!! Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We moved here from the Jersey Shore, so we're more than a little picky about our pizza. I'm also 100% Italian and grew up around authentic Italian food, and Casa Mia doesn't disappoint. Hands down, this is the best pizza around. And we have tried a ton of places. First, the delivery is always awesome. They arrive on time, every time, and they're super polite. Second, if you chose to dine in, the wait staff is wonderful. Even when they're busy (and they get super busy, for good reason), you never have to wait for a table or for your food. And they know how to make everyone feel welcome and at home. It truly is a family establishment. In a town like Sparta where everyone knows everyone, you appreciate restaurants like Casa Mia and the value they bring to the community/all the ways they give back. But back to the food. I recently tried their personal vegan pizza and loved it, and this is coming from a former vegan so I have something to compare it to. They always have your order ready to go immediately and take the time to ask how you your day is going and put in that extra effort. I have a few big events coming up and I'll be having Casa Mia cater them because I know the food will be on point and on time. They catered a party of ours last year and were exactly on time. If you want legit GOOD, authentic pizza and owners/staff they value their customers and know you by name, this is your spot. There is a reason people come from all over to check this place out. They've been here for 31 years and are a staple in the community. Thanks for great service and even better food. And no, I don't work here. I just appreciate good people and brag when I find awesome food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Its another italian restaurant. We went there for dinner with some friends of ours visiting. Food was good, server was good to. We didn't care for the stuffed artichoke, it left like just eating bread and not the artichoke it self. Not that bad prices, would go back again to try some different foods.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Good staff and food. Difficulty finding parking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great little Italian restaurant. Parking cab be tricky though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent pizza for the location. Quickly served.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Me & my wife ate lunch here on Sat. 8/29/25. Food was delicious & our server , Dynasty, was awesome.
Would definitely go back next time we decide to visit Lake Mohawk.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely the worst dried out pizza in the area. New pie man? He sucks. Must have forgot the pizza was in the oven.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
This used to be the best pizza in Sparta, but over the last six months it’s completely gone to downhill . The pizza is disgusting now completely dried out and overdone. I don’t know what happened because their pizza used to be so good. I’ve given this place a couple chances thinking that maybe they just had a bad day but the last three times has been horrible so I am now done. They will not get my business anymore. There’s way better places I can go to!! Just look at the picture… This looks like pizza that’s been sitting there all day, but this was made fresh. And the picture was taken only 15 minutes after bringing it home. Dave Portnoy would have spit this rock hard pizza out.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best Pizza in New Jersey!!! Great Italian Food!!! I've been a customer for THIRTY years - Mike and Victor (the owners) are great guys and the whole staff is awesome. The whole Casa Mia team is always striving to bring their customers tastey food and they succeed! Thank you Casa Mia. Delicious food. :) And this is important: They shred their own cheese for their pizza and all their offeringss so no worry of it having that anti-mold chemical that the cheese industry is putting in all the pre-shredded cheese they sell to restaurants and other pizzerias.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The breaded veal dish was excellent the spaghetti and salad accompanied were good too.
Good prices as well as military discount.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The people working here are nice but the food is no where close to quality that deserve a revisit. The portion are big but flavorless.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Loading...