Nutty over Sweets
6 White Deer Plaza, Sparta
(973) 729-3466
Novelty (Sweets)
Milk chocolate cigars
Sour Flush
Candy plunger with sour powder dip.
Pop Rocks
Strawberry, watermelon, cotton candy, blue razz, and bubblegum.
Gummi Meal Sets
Gummi verse, bakery shop bag, Mexican dinner, lunch bag, and sour lunch bag.
Warheads Super Sour Spray
Watermelon/blue razz and blue razz, green apple.
Rip Rolls
Blue raspberry, strawberry, and watermelon.
Broadway Licorice Strawberry roll
Sour Power Sortz
Sour candy straws. with 4 flavors in a bag, blue raspberry, tutti frutti, green apple, and strawberry.
Cotton candy pops
Caramel apple pops
Unicorn pops
Jumbo candy buttons
Retro (Sweets)
Rock lollies
Grape, cotton candy, strawberry, cherry, green apple, watermelon, and banana.
B-B-Bats
Vanilla and chocolate.
Beach Bucket
4 sand toys and 4 lollipops.
Chocolate Necco
Charleston Chew
Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry.
Zotz
Apple, watermelon, orange, and grape.
Sour satellite wafers bag
Filled with sour powder.
Concession (Sweets)
Yoohoo Chocolate Bar
Candy Bars (Sweets)
Nestlé Crunch
Strawberry Turkish Taffy
Banana Turkish Taffy
Caramel Creams
Chocolate Turkish Taffy
Vanilla Turkish Taffy
Strawberry Charleston Chew
Kit Kat
Hershey's Milk Chocolate
Peanut Chews
Vanilla Charleston Chew
Chocolate Charleston Chew
Gums (Sweets)
Strawberry Big League Chew
Grape Big League Chew
Glee gum
Bubblegum and spearmint.
Bubblicious
Bubblegum and grape.
Starburst gum
Strawberry.
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape
Bubblegum and sour bluerazz.
Sour Apple Big League Chew
Watermelon Big League Chew
Bubble gum cigars
Selected randomly from stock upon purchase.
Jelly Bean Flavors (Sweets)
Raspberry
Crushed Pineapple
Lemon Drop
Orange
Orange Sherbet
Strawberry Jam
Very Cherry
Buttered Popcorn
Chocolate Pudding
Watermelon
Cotton Candy
Peach
Green Apple
Top Banana
Sizzling Cinnamon
Wild Blackberry
French Vanilla
Pink Grapefruit
Berry blue
Strawberry Cheesecake
Cappuccino
Lemon Lime
Coconut
Tutti-Fruitti
Blueberry
M&M's Colors (Sweets)
M&M's Colors
Orange, yellow, green, dark green, blue, light blue, teal, purple, pink, dark pink, white, brown, and black. Per ib.
Candies by the Pound
Cherry cola bottles
Rainbow berries
Reese's peanut butter cups
Gummy chicken feet
Gummy cupcakes
Gummy eggs
Gummy frogs
Gummy ice pops
Gummy jumbo shark
Gummy lobster
Gummy penguin
Gummy pigs
Gummy rainforest frogs
Gummy robots
Gummy sand sharks
Gummy strawberries
Gummy turtles
Gummy worms
Sour apple dots
Sour coated bears
Sour cola bottles
Sour twin cherries
Sour watermeons
Strawberry brick
Nuts
Peanut brittle
Dark Chocolate Cranberries
Dark chocolate espresso beans
Salted Nut Mix
Roasted pistachios
Aloha Mix
Mix of diced papaya, diced pineapple, diced apricots, banana chips, coconut, walnuts, almonds, cashews, and pumpkin seeds. Per 1/4 lb.
Dark Chocolate Orange peel Bites
President Mix
Mix of roasted peanuts, cashews, dried cranberries, and pumpkin seeds. Per 1/4 lb.
Rainbow Mix
Mix of roasted almonds, cashews, peanuts, sunflower seeds, m&m's, and raisins. Per 1/4 lb.
Roasted cashews
Trail Mix Deluxe
Mix of raisins, cashews, pecans, filberts, roasted soy nuts, pumpkin seeds, and peanuts. Per 1/4 lb.
Yogurt Mix
Mix of peanuts, sunflower seeds, raisins, roasted almonds, cashews, pumpkin seeds, and dates. Per 1/4 lb.
Energy mix
Mix of almonds, cashews, hazelnuts, walnuts, filberts, honey & sugar roasted peanuts, and dried raisins. Per 1/4 lb.
Chocolate sunflower seeds
Dark chocolate raisins
Milk chocolate raisins
Fine Dark Chocolate (Specialty)
Coconut Cream
Double Peppermint Patty
Hot Chocolate Caramel
Raspberry Cream
Dark Chocolate Bourbon
Dark Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt
Dark Chocolate Truffle
Raspberry truffle
Jelly Rings
Almond Bark
Boardwalk Crunch
Marshmallow, pretzel, buttered popcorn, and nuts covered in dark chocolate. Per 1/4 lb.
Dark Vanilla Cream
Lemon Cream
Maple Cream
Dark chocolate maple cream. Per 1/4 lb.
Caramel Marshmallow
Pecan Turtle
Strawberry Jelly Sqaure
Mint Truffle
Breakup
Solid dark chocolate. Per 1/4 lb.
Porcupine
Vanilla cream and peanuts covered in dark chocolate. Per 1/4 lb.
Raspberry Marshmallow Twist
Raspberry jelly square
Orange peel
Marshmallow Square
Liquid fudge smoothie
Peanut Butter Smoothie
Fine Milk Chocolate (Specialty)
Peanut Butter Marshmallow sqaure
Pecan turtles
Cherry Cordial
Marshmallow Square
Orange Cream
Strawberry Cream
Butter Rum Caramel
Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel
Vanilla caramel
Almond Bark
Jelly Roll
Milk Vanilla Cream
Virginia Dainties
Vanilla cream and milk chocolate coated in peanuts. Per 1/4 lb.
Peanut smoothie
Breakup
Solid milk chocolate. Per 1/4 lb.
Rasin Clusters
Rice Krispie Cluster
Raspberry truffle
Caramel Truffle
Espresso Truffle
Individually Packaged (Specialty)
S'mores square
Marshmallow and graham cracker covered in milk chocolate.
Jumbo Milk chocolate Peanut butter cup
Almond Butter crunch
Toffee covered in milk chocolate, coated in almonds.
Milk Chocolate Sponge
Sweet molasses honeycomb sponge covered in milk chocolate.
Milk chocolate graham crackers
4 graham crackers in one bag.
Milk chocolate coconut clusters
Chocolate covered Oreos
Two cookies in a bag.
Dark chocolate Toffee with Almonds
Toffee coated in dark chocolate topped with almonds.
Milk chocolate Vanilla Marshmallows
6 marshmallows per bag.
Milk chocolate Swedish fish
S'mores bites
Marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker.
Mint Crush Cookie Cluster
One cluster per bag.
Dark Chocolate covered Almond
Dark and Milk chocolate sea salt bites
Dark chocolate Peanut clusters
Dark chocolate Sponge
Sweet molasses honeycomb sponge covered in dark chocolate.
Dark chocolate Swedish fish
Dark chocolate covered Graham crackers
4 graham crackers in one bag.
Jumbo Dark chocolate Peanut butter cup
Milk chocolate Toffee Crunch
Chocolate covered marshmallows
One jumbo marshmallow on a stick covered in milk chocolate with sprinkles (sprinkles vary each time).
Fudge (Specialty)
Vanilla Caramel Seasalt
Peanut Butter
Fine White Chocolate (Specialty)
Red Velvet Truffle
Red Velvet Caramel
Orange Cream
Almond Bark
Breakup
Solid white chocolate.
Specialty Pretzels
Oreo pretzel
Milk chocolate pretzel
Black and White chip pretzel
Peanutbutter chip pretzel
White chocolate pretzel
Coconut pretzel
Dark chocolate pretzel
Allergy, Gluten Free, and Vegan Friendly
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Chocolate chip cookies topped with Himalayan sea salt (6 per box) - dairy-free and vegan.
No Whey! Caramel & Nougat bar
Caramel and nougat in a chocolatey coating - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, vegan, and kosher.
No Whey! Choco No No's
Milk-like chocolatey candies - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, vegan, and kosher.
No Whey! Milkless Crunchy bar
Creamy milkless chocolate with crisped rice - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, and vegan.
No Whey! Milkless Polar Dream White bar
Looks and tastes like a white chocolate bar - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, and vegan.
No Whey! Milkless bar
Looks and tastes like a milk chocolate bar - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, vegan, and kosher.
No Whey! Pea Not Cups
Sunflower-filled milkless cups - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, vegan, and kosher.
No Whey! Peppermint No No's
Milk like peppermint chocolatey candies - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, and vegan.
No Whey! Vegems
Individually wrapped in assorted fruit flavors and colors - dairy-free, tree nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, vegan, and kosher.
Sjaak's 70%25 Extra Dark Chocolate
Vegan.
Sjaak's Celebrate bar
Coconut caramel and almonds coated in milk chocolate - vegan.
Sjaak's Dark Chocolate with Creamy Caramel bar
Vegan.
Sjaak's Dark Chocolate with Raspberry bar
Vegan.
Sjaak's Dream Big bar
Peanut caramel topped with peanut butter and peanuts coated in milk chocolate - vegan.
Licorice
Cherry Licorice
Ripples Licorice
Finnish licorice, chewy texture.
Salt Licorice
Salted black licorice.
Star Licorice
Soft & sweet black licorice.
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Visited here yesterday. It brought me back to my childhood and I cannot wait to return. The owner is wonderful. Allergies? No problem. Options available for everyone. This will be a regular stop for me and my family moving forward. 🩷
February 2025
Nutty Over Sweets is a candy store that I’ve always gone to since I was a little kid and has never failed to satisfy my sweet tooth. The store really does have any candy you could ever want and all of the candy inside the store tastes amazing. I highly recommend anyone to go to the store whether you’re a Sparta local or just visiting for the day.
November 2024
Such a cute candy store. It’s small but it is packed with great candy. Super clean and very friendly service. She even gave my son a couple of chocolate covered Oreos for free which was so nice. Just another gem in Lake
November 2024
You May Also Like
Lake House Cafe - 8 White Deer Plaza
![]()
Cafe, Vegetarian
St. Moritz Grill & Bar - 9 White Deer Plaza
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Vegetarian