Cake That! was extremely accommodating and provided excellent customer service. On top of that, the cake they created for our son's 2nd birthday party was amazing. It came out great and was a hit! Thank you so much Cake That!
Lindsay Sorg
Cake That! was extremely accommodating and provided excellent customer service. On top of that, the cake they created for our son's 2nd birthday party was amazing. It came out great and was a hit! Thank you so much Cake That!
Devon Kerstetter
The BEST carrot cake cupcake ever
Dranixo
Such a wonderful experience looking for our wedding cake, this place is the best businesse to deal with. Absolute fantastic owners and a wonderful staff. Their cream cheese icing is something that should be held on the highest pedestal. If you are looking for great cakes and great baked goods you found the right place.
Tara Mcqueen
Amazing customer service! I had to order cupcakes for an employee and the gal I worked with was so nice, accommodated every request and even went above and beyond to call me back to let me know of an update when she didn't need to. I highly recommend this company!
Lynn Charles
Fabulous! Helpful and friendly staff + the food is fantastic!
Alyssa M.
I worked with Jess and Jenna to create a custom cake for my son's 3rd birthday. They were both very helpful and easy to work with. They did a great job replicating the design I had in mind, and it was delicious too. I will definitely order from them again.
Frank Wulff
Very very friendly and courteous front end staff. Not much of a selection, perhaps it was the off season? Very fresh baked goods that we purchased. Rated 3 stars only because no real selection
Jill F.
We had a delicious Oreo cookie cake and an assortment of yummy cupcakes, will definitely be back again!!
David Julian
What a fabulous find. Actually stumbled across this gem after visiting their neighbor. As someone who needs to be Gluten Free for medical reasons, to CAKE THAT! offered a variety of Gluten Free vegan treats. It was refreshing to see the number available as many places offer only one option, if that. There were some free samples to boot. Oh, and the best part, REASONABLE PRICING.I think I found my new favorite local bakery.
I would like to leave a review on the Gluten Free/Vegan Cookies I recently ordered for my daughter and I who have Celiac disease.
Lisa Richichi
Finally! A dream come true! Half of the bakery is for the health conciseness with a plethora of gluten and dairy free options and loads of keto options. The other half is typical fancy decadent bakery cupcakes and cookies sandwiches. I'm so happy someone finally did the right thing and catered to all different tastes in the baker's world. This business will be around long after I'm dead and hopefully will spread to other towns like wild fire. Everything tastes amazing just buy it all lol
Kimberly ODonnell
I very rarely post reviews on businesses. But Cake That is amazing! We had to postpone our wedding due to COVID and did a small ceremony but we still wanted a cake. The staff understood our struggle. We had our ceremony last night and i already ate a slice for lunch today. I want to drown in their vanilla icing. They were just so nice and understanding.
Julie Whelan Capell
Gluten free heaven! I couldn't believe it when I walked in and they had three kinds of gluten free cupcakes available (pumpkin, vanilla and chocolate). All were good but the chocolate was amazing! I also tried a red velvet macaron; it was the best macaron I have had in a very long time. They have a different cupcake special flavor every day--you can check out their calendar online. About once a week the flavor is gluten free. And they are always trying new gluten free items. The day I was there, they were testing out gluten free pumpkin-flavored pop tarts! I bought one but haven't tried it yet. This will definitely become a frequent stop for me when I am in Manahawkin.
Basia Puzak
Large selection of cupcakes, different flavors and great tasting. Courteous and friendly service. Recommend visiting. We go there often.
Cake That! was extremely accommodating and provided excellent customer service. On top of that, the cake they created for our son's 2nd birthday party was amazing. It came out great and was a hit! Thank you so much Cake That!
Cake That! was extremely accommodating and provided excellent customer service. On top of that, the cake they created for our son's 2nd birthday party was amazing. It came out great and was a hit! Thank you so much Cake That!
The BEST carrot cake cupcake ever
Such a wonderful experience looking for our wedding cake, this place is the best businesse to deal with. Absolute fantastic owners and a wonderful staff. Their cream cheese icing is something that should be held on the highest pedestal. If you are looking for great cakes and great baked goods you found the right place.
Amazing customer service! I had to order cupcakes for an employee and the gal I worked with was so nice, accommodated every request and even went above and beyond to call me back to let me know of an update when she didn't need to. I highly recommend this company!
Fabulous! Helpful and friendly staff + the food is fantastic!
I worked with Jess and Jenna to create a custom cake for my son's 3rd birthday. They were both very helpful and easy to work with. They did a great job replicating the design I had in mind, and it was delicious too. I will definitely order from them again.
Very very friendly and courteous front end staff. Not much of a selection, perhaps it was the off season? Very fresh baked goods that we purchased. Rated 3 stars only because no real selection
We had a delicious Oreo cookie cake and an assortment of yummy cupcakes, will definitely be back again!!
What a fabulous find. Actually stumbled across this gem after visiting their neighbor. As someone who needs to be Gluten Free for medical reasons, to CAKE THAT! offered a variety of Gluten Free vegan treats. It was refreshing to see the number available as many places offer only one option, if that. There were some free samples to boot. Oh, and the best part, REASONABLE PRICING.I think I found my new favorite local bakery.
Restaurantji Recommends
I would like to leave a review on the Gluten Free/Vegan Cookies I recently ordered for my daughter and I who have Celiac disease.
Finally! A dream come true! Half of the bakery is for the health conciseness with a plethora of gluten and dairy free options and loads of keto options. The other half is typical fancy decadent bakery cupcakes and cookies sandwiches. I'm so happy someone finally did the right thing and catered to all different tastes in the baker's world. This business will be around long after I'm dead and hopefully will spread to other towns like wild fire. Everything tastes amazing just buy it all lol
I very rarely post reviews on businesses. But Cake That is amazing! We had to postpone our wedding due to COVID and did a small ceremony but we still wanted a cake. The staff understood our struggle. We had our ceremony last night and i already ate a slice for lunch today. I want to drown in their vanilla icing. They were just so nice and understanding.
Gluten free heaven! I couldn't believe it when I walked in and they had three kinds of gluten free cupcakes available (pumpkin, vanilla and chocolate). All were good but the chocolate was amazing! I also tried a red velvet macaron; it was the best macaron I have had in a very long time. They have a different cupcake special flavor every day--you can check out their calendar online. About once a week the flavor is gluten free. And they are always trying new gluten free items. The day I was there, they were testing out gluten free pumpkin-flavored pop tarts! I bought one but haven't tried it yet. This will definitely become a frequent stop for me when I am in Manahawkin.
Large selection of cupcakes, different flavors and great tasting. Courteous and friendly service. Recommend visiting. We go there often.