Pizza is absolute garbage. Thick, overly topped. As if extra cheese is de regular. Sauce is bland and cheese is cheap. Dough is just wildly thick. I cannot believe anyone thinks this is good.Service is normally great. But I got 2 slices and a bottle of water. She said I'll give you the combo it's 2 slices and a drink. The 2 slices were $7.25 after tax (which is wild but w.e.) then after I added the water it was 10.75. I asked her after I pay and see the receipt, how much is a bottle of water. She says $2.50. The combo made the water MORE money. Gtfo
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jessica Lathom
I've only been in the Manahawkin location to pick up some slices (bomb af), but I have been over a friends house and had delivery from them. They hand wrote a message in the speech bubble on the front of the box, referring to the conversation they had while my friend was ordering over the phone. I forget exactly what it said, but it was clever and endearing ?The couple times I've been in to pick up slices, the counter staff were very pleasant and accommodating!Parking: Depending on day of the week and time of day, parking can be iffy. Fridays and weekend evenings are obviously busier. Good for them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fusaro Favorites Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Miriam S
The food is decent (usually), but the customer service is by far the worst I’ve ever experienced! If you ever have an issue with your order, don’t expect them to make it right, because they absolutely will NOT! This is the second time I had an issue with an order at Fusaro’s in Manahawkin, and both times, they refused to do anything to rectify the situation. They delivered a burned pizza to me, when I called back to speak with someone, I was put on hold for several minutes, so I hung up! It was already about 7pm and I didn’t want the pizza redelivered that night anyway as it wouldn’t have arrived until 8pm or so! I figured I would call in the morning and just get credit, for the burned pizza, for a future order! I was wrong to assume that if I called the next morning, they would have the decency to still do the right thing. Manager says “we can only offer a refund or redeliver the same day, not the next day. You placed your order around 6pm, and that’s our busiest time. They probably just couldn’t get to the phone right away, you should have waited a couple more minutes or called again, we’re open til 9pm” But you should have never delivered a pizza that was burned in the first place!!!!! And even worse, you refuse to make it right!!!! I’ve ordered many, many times from this place and am appalled at how they treat their customers. It’s not just about a $20 pizza, but a matter of principle!!! Shame on you, Fusaro’s.
Today is National Pizza day and I couldn't think of any other place I would rather have pizza from than Fusaro. It's a local, family owned business that serves not only the best pizza, but other Italian favorites as well. I've been ordering food from the Manahawkin location for years, and I can honestly say I have never been disappointed. It's so easy to order online and delivery and service is always great. Today we ordered: -fried calamari -garlic knots with cheese -pepperoni pizza -white garlic pizza with broccoli If you're ever in town and want delicious and flavorful pizza - plus more- then this is the place to visit. You won't be disappointed.
Vince C.
We've been loyal Fusaro's customers for nearly a decade. Up until recently they've provided quality food, often times prepared to order. However, the last three deliveries were not up to par. More often than not the food was not made as requested and delivered warm, not hot and/or underdone. Heating the food wasn't a big issue, it's just amateurish. The last delivery, though, was awful. Our typical order (pizza, mussels, and wings) was so overdone that the mussels disintegrated and the wings were burnt leaving only the pizza edible. This isn't a story of being disgruntled, just extremely disappointed. I sent private messages via FB Messenger to avoid public embarrassment, but they have gone unaddressed and unanswered. It's clear that Fusaro cares only about the customer's money and not the customer's satisfaction. Fusaro routinely removes negative comments from their posts on social media to give the impression that all is good and no one is dissatisfied. You can do better, Fusaro, much better!
Scott Kohli
Dog food. Cheesesteak ordered no cheese. Burnt ice cold. 1 block away feom restaurant. You should be embarrassed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christina Luell
The food here is incredible, but I really wanted to point out your staff. I felt so welcomed going to pick up my food. I waited for a few minutes (which wasn’t an issue at all) and everyone was just so apologetic and nice. Danielle was so sweet to me and every single customer that walked in behind me. That’s truly the kind of person you want to have working at your business. Thank you ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lydia Creevy
My favorite place to get
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tatiana D.
Great wings & pizza! I am not a Sicilian style pizza lover but my husband loved theirs. We didn't go inside the pizzeria so I can't let you know how the restaurant is but we were able to have our order in a quick time on a Friday night. So service was good.
One of the best pizza places in NJ! Great food, friendly staff, and a cute atmosphere. Always enjoy coming hereParking: Plenty of parking and the lot is easily accessibleKid-friendliness: Super kid friendly. Always have cute kids shows on the dining room TV to keep them entertained
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Michael Colicchio
Sicilian slice was larger and thicker than usual but, surprisingly, light and airy. I recommend it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Slice
Ivy colon
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again, best food coming out of New Jersey is definitely in a strip mall!This place is killing the pizza game with delicious and innovative pies! I personally love the one with mortadella, fresh mozz & olives on the lightest most delicious focaccia like crust!And the vodka slice is out of this world ! The attention to detail is obvious in the ingredients & made with love! I can’t wait to try the rest of the menu.
Counter staff very helpful and friendly best service in town!Kid-friendliness: Friendly, fun atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Sauce, Cheesesteak
Ted Delfranco
Gotta give these guys a shout out! I order big deliveries all the time and they are awesome. Food is always great, and their drivers are on time. Best cheesesteak Stromboli around!!! Thanks for always taking my (last minute) big lunch deliveries!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza Slice, Mixed Salad, Chicken Fingers with French Fries, Margarita Pizza, Cheesesteak
Pizza is absolute garbage. Thick, overly topped. As if extra cheese is de regular. Sauce is bland and cheese is cheap. Dough is just wildly thick. I cannot believe anyone thinks this is good.Service is normally great. But I got 2 slices and a bottle of water. She said I'll give you the combo it's 2 slices and a drink. The 2 slices were $7.25 after tax (which is wild but w.e.) then after I added the water it was 10.75. I asked her after I pay and see the receipt, how much is a bottle of water. She says $2.50. The combo made the water MORE money. Gtfo
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
I've only been in the Manahawkin location to pick up some slices (bomb af), but I have been over a friends house and had delivery from them. They hand wrote a message in the speech bubble on the front of the box, referring to the conversation they had while my friend was ordering over the phone. I forget exactly what it said, but it was clever and endearing ?The couple times I've been in to pick up slices, the counter staff were very pleasant and accommodating!Parking: Depending on day of the week and time of day, parking can be iffy. Fridays and weekend evenings are obviously busier. Good for them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fusaro Favorites Pizza, Slice of Pizza
The food is decent (usually), but the customer service is by far the worst I’ve ever experienced! If you ever have an issue with your order, don’t expect them to make it right, because they absolutely will NOT! This is the second time I had an issue with an order at Fusaro’s in Manahawkin, and both times, they refused to do anything to rectify the situation. They delivered a burned pizza to me, when I called back to speak with someone, I was put on hold for several minutes, so I hung up! It was already about 7pm and I didn’t want the pizza redelivered that night anyway as it wouldn’t have arrived until 8pm or so! I figured I would call in the morning and just get credit, for the burned pizza, for a future order! I was wrong to assume that if I called the next morning, they would have the decency to still do the right thing. Manager says “we can only offer a refund or redeliver the same day, not the next day. You placed your order around 6pm, and that’s our busiest time. They probably just couldn’t get to the phone right away, you should have waited a couple more minutes or called again, we’re open til 9pm” But you should have never delivered a pizza that was burned in the first place!!!!! And even worse, you refuse to make it right!!!! I’ve ordered many, many times from this place and am appalled at how they treat their customers. It’s not just about a $20 pizza, but a matter of principle!!! Shame on you, Fusaro’s.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Friendly staff and good
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parm Sub, Sauce, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Parmigiana, Slice of Pizza
Today is National Pizza day and I couldn't think of any other place I would rather have pizza from than Fusaro. It's a local, family owned business that serves not only the best pizza, but other Italian favorites as well. I've been ordering food from the Manahawkin location for years, and I can honestly say I have never been disappointed. It's so easy to order online and delivery and service is always great. Today we ordered: -fried calamari -garlic knots with cheese -pepperoni pizza -white garlic pizza with broccoli If you're ever in town and want delicious and flavorful pizza - plus more- then this is the place to visit. You won't be disappointed.
We've been loyal Fusaro's customers for nearly a decade. Up until recently they've provided quality food, often times prepared to order. However, the last three deliveries were not up to par. More often than not the food was not made as requested and delivered warm, not hot and/or underdone. Heating the food wasn't a big issue, it's just amateurish. The last delivery, though, was awful. Our typical order (pizza, mussels, and wings) was so overdone that the mussels disintegrated and the wings were burnt leaving only the pizza edible. This isn't a story of being disgruntled, just extremely disappointed. I sent private messages via FB Messenger to avoid public embarrassment, but they have gone unaddressed and unanswered. It's clear that Fusaro cares only about the customer's money and not the customer's satisfaction. Fusaro routinely removes negative comments from their posts on social media to give the impression that all is good and no one is dissatisfied. You can do better, Fusaro, much better!
Dog food. Cheesesteak ordered no cheese. Burnt ice cold. 1 block away feom restaurant. You should be embarrassed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food here is incredible, but I really wanted to point out your staff. I felt so welcomed going to pick up my food. I waited for a few minutes (which wasn’t an issue at all) and everyone was just so apologetic and nice. Danielle was so sweet to me and every single customer that walked in behind me. That’s truly the kind of person you want to have working at your business. Thank you ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite place to get
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great wings & pizza! I am not a Sicilian style pizza lover but my husband loved theirs. We didn't go inside the pizzeria so I can't let you know how the restaurant is but we were able to have our order in a quick time on a Friday night. So service was good.
Restaurantji Recommends
One of the best pizza places in NJ! Great food, friendly staff, and a cute atmosphere. Always enjoy coming hereParking: Plenty of parking and the lot is easily accessibleKid-friendliness: Super kid friendly. Always have cute kids shows on the dining room TV to keep them entertained
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Sicilian slice was larger and thicker than usual but, surprisingly, light and airy. I recommend it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Slice
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again, best food coming out of New Jersey is definitely in a strip mall!This place is killing the pizza game with delicious and innovative pies! I personally love the one with mortadella, fresh mozz & olives on the lightest most delicious focaccia like crust!And the vodka slice is out of this world ! The attention to detail is obvious in the ingredients & made with love! I can’t wait to try the rest of the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza Slice, Sauce, Garlic Knots, Penne Vodka, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Counter staff very helpful and friendly best service in town!Kid-friendliness: Friendly, fun atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Sauce, Cheesesteak
Gotta give these guys a shout out! I order big deliveries all the time and they are awesome. Food is always great, and their drivers are on time. Best cheesesteak Stromboli around!!! Thanks for always taking my (last minute) big lunch deliveries!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza Slice, Mixed Salad, Chicken Fingers with French Fries, Margarita Pizza, Cheesesteak