Rays New York Pizza

545 Mill Creek Rd, Manahawkin
(609) 597-5050

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Meag Lazzara

We placed an order for food to be sent to the family of our friend and coworker that passed away and Vickie was absolutely wonderful! Thank you Vickie for going above and beyond for us. The food was delicious and everyone loved it. You were so kind and went out of your way to make a special note, thank you again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Antoinette R

Best pizza in NJ!

Food: 5

Kayla Khaled

Not the usual looking pizza place but the pizza is excellent. This was a great find!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittany Petrella

Amazing gluten free delivery! Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

PM

Love it here! Garlic knots are the best.

Kathy DiLorenzo

Great cheesesteaks… but no potatoes please lol. Super nice staff

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Stephen Benner (Steve)

While it’s not the same as the slices I’d get back home in Manhattan, their pizza is one of the best in the area. Some days it can be a little too greasy so just let them know on the phone, they’re friendly folks.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

iwozim

Worst pizza ever !

Food: 1

Kim Henderson

Food was ice cold and hard as a rock, very disappointed as they are always good. 2 sandwiches and kids meal was$72.00

Rikki O'Hagan

I used to get the Texas Chicken Pizza all the time, and it’s delicious! The spicy chicken, ranch dressing, and gooey cheese are a fantastic combo, and the crust is perfectly crispy.

However, I’m frustrated with the pricing. The menu prices online don’t match what I’m charged, and there are added fees for credit cards and delivery. Plus, they don’t offer a loyalty program like other local pizza places, which is disappointing.

While I love the pizza, the high prices and lack of rewards make me think twice about returning. If they could improve pricing transparency and introduce a loyalty program, I’d be back for sure.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Emma Weber

disappointing:( i ordered pizza through doordash because i’m babysitting and the pizza was flavorless, sauce tasted fake and the crust was dry and not appetizing. garlic knots are just coated in loads of oil with no taste.

Food: 2

James Sheehan

Great pizza.

Food: 5

Christina Brockman

Ordered pizza via Door Dash and it was horrible. Nothing fancy, half plain, half meatball. The sauce had an off taste, the crust was inedible (hard, crunchy, overcooked), it was like eating cardboard. The owners are nice to deal with and helpful but c'mon, a simple pizza was that bad. We go back to them periodically forgetting how lousy the pizza was from the prior year, do not get a pizza pie from here, you will be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Cassidy Matteo

Stopped in for a quick buffalo slice 10/10 will definitely order again from here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jackie Steinbronn

DON'T pass by this place without stopping for over two years like me. We've been missing out. It's located across the street from Acme.
1- We were greeted by a very personable lady who always had a genuine smile on her face the whole time. She made great recommendations and brought our food, extra plates, forks and napkins to our table. We had good conversations too.
2-The pizza was delicious, crispy and the cheese didn't fall off. Also, you must try their fries! It has that crispy coating on it and goes really well with cheese dip.
3-When we were done eating, a young man came over and helped us clean up and offered to-go boxes and tops for our cheese dip.
4-I have to confess, the service here was better than some 5 star restaurants I've been too! Everyone working was very friendly and had good conversations too. You kind of felt part of a family in there.
5-We will be coming back! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...