Stopped by to have dinner at the lighthouse. Food was fantastic. We had tuna, flounder and chicken and variety of apps - and it was all excellent. We showed up about 730 and was not rushed out at all. Price was very reasonable. Will definitely be back and highly recommend. Cheesecake was really good.
Keith D.
We just had a great breakfast here. Staff is super friendly (shout out to Crissy!) and the owner was generous with his time. Really good bagels, tons o sausage in the biscuits and gravy and already open for the season. Definitely on our "make sure we stop by" list.
Tammie Caruso
My husband and I ordered a chicken sandwich and both were delicious. Took bagels home and had them for breakfast and they were fantastic. Our server was so sweet and pleasant. We certainly will stop there again. Thank you
MIDNIGHT RIDER
Awesome food
Tom W.
The best pork roll and cheese I've found yet in area.Nice owners very friendly service will definitely return!
Valerie R.
Fantastic breakfast! Huge fresh bagel selection. They say they have the best bagels on the island...and they're right!! Quick and friendly service. We can't wait to go back to try more of the bagels or some of the lunch items.
Stephen Gold
Food was great. Service was very slow. But I'll be back
Michelle Savino
I catered breakfast from Lighthouse Deli the morning after my son’s wedding. They couldn’t have been more accommodating and the food was absolutely delicious! The bagels are fresh and rival any NYC bagel. Thank you for making my morning so much easier!
karen terpe
Great breakfast sandwiches! The lunch sandwiches are huge and tasty! The host and staff and very friendly. Great addition to the Island!
Katherine Campbell
Woman at the front desk was rude, every single thing in our 8 person order was incorrect, and it didn’t even taste that good. Also the wait was like 45 minutes for bagels with cream cheese, not even toasted
Lovely staff, great food, comfortable apthmosphere
Sharon Joyce
My husband and I LOVED our breakfast bagel sandwiches. Best we ever had anywhere! Jamie was our lovely server! Just delightful!!!! Made our day!!
Katie R.
First and foremost, the lady at the register (assuming the owner) was wonderful and greeted everyone walking in with a smile. I order a chicken salad hoagie. The bread was fresh and chicken salad was even fresher!!! Highly recommend this deli!
Ken Roche
Great food and nice atmosphere
Steve S.
We had a lunch (sandwiches) here last year that was excellent - we took it to go since our rental is just across the street. YESTERDAY, my son and I wandered in from the beach and wanted to split a sandwich so we stopped in again and ordered an Italian sub with the works (you have to ask for mayo), some cole slaw and a piece of crumb cake. Sandwich was excellent, cole slaw needed a touch of salt, and the crumb cake was outstanding.While in the shop I wandered over to the spot where they keep the bagels and asked if they made them on site and the young lady responded...yes, we make them fresh every day. So TODAY, I walked over and got half a dozen bagels (two everything, one sesame, one blueberry, one French toast and one habanero cheddar). Weave been getting our bagels from a place up the street FOR YEARS and I will never go back because the Lighthouse Deli has the best bagels on the Island. $10 for a half dozen and they are as good as, or better than, our go-to place back home. I must admit, they get a little backed up at lunchtime (might be a loss of help since we're here in mid August), but it's worth it. You can eat-in or take out, the place is really clean and friendly, and the staff are always friendly and helpful. Seriously, best bagels on the island
Stopped by to have dinner at the lighthouse. Food was fantastic. We had tuna, flounder and chicken and variety of apps - and it was all excellent. We showed up about 730 and was not rushed out at all. Price was very reasonable. Will definitely be back and highly recommend. Cheesecake was really good.
We just had a great breakfast here. Staff is super friendly (shout out to Crissy!) and the owner was generous with his time. Really good bagels, tons o sausage in the biscuits and gravy and already open for the season. Definitely on our "make sure we stop by" list.
My husband and I ordered a chicken sandwich and both were delicious. Took bagels home and had them for breakfast and they were fantastic. Our server was so sweet and pleasant. We certainly will stop there again. Thank you
Awesome food
The best pork roll and cheese I've found yet in area.Nice owners very friendly service will definitely return!
Fantastic breakfast! Huge fresh bagel selection. They say they have the best bagels on the island...and they're right!! Quick and friendly service. We can't wait to go back to try more of the bagels or some of the lunch items.
Food was great. Service was very slow. But I'll be back
I catered breakfast from Lighthouse Deli the morning after my son’s wedding. They couldn’t have been more accommodating and the food was absolutely delicious! The bagels are fresh and rival any NYC bagel. Thank you for making my morning so much easier!
Great breakfast sandwiches! The lunch sandwiches are huge and tasty! The host and staff and very friendly. Great addition to the Island!
Woman at the front desk was rude, every single thing in our 8 person order was incorrect, and it didn’t even taste that good. Also the wait was like 45 minutes for bagels with cream cheese, not even toasted
Restaurantji Recommends
Lovely staff, great food, comfortable apthmosphere
My husband and I LOVED our breakfast bagel sandwiches. Best we ever had anywhere! Jamie was our lovely server! Just delightful!!!! Made our day!!
First and foremost, the lady at the register (assuming the owner) was wonderful and greeted everyone walking in with a smile. I order a chicken salad hoagie. The bread was fresh and chicken salad was even fresher!!! Highly recommend this deli!
Great food and nice atmosphere
We had a lunch (sandwiches) here last year that was excellent - we took it to go since our rental is just across the street. YESTERDAY, my son and I wandered in from the beach and wanted to split a sandwich so we stopped in again and ordered an Italian sub with the works (you have to ask for mayo), some cole slaw and a piece of crumb cake. Sandwich was excellent, cole slaw needed a touch of salt, and the crumb cake was outstanding.While in the shop I wandered over to the spot where they keep the bagels and asked if they made them on site and the young lady responded...yes, we make them fresh every day. So TODAY, I walked over and got half a dozen bagels (two everything, one sesame, one blueberry, one French toast and one habanero cheddar). Weave been getting our bagels from a place up the street FOR YEARS and I will never go back because the Lighthouse Deli has the best bagels on the Island. $10 for a half dozen and they are as good as, or better than, our go-to place back home. I must admit, they get a little backed up at lunchtime (might be a loss of help since we're here in mid August), but it's worth it. You can eat-in or take out, the place is really clean and friendly, and the staff are always friendly and helpful. Seriously, best bagels on the island