Clove Brook Market | Bakery, Deli, & Catering

I’ve had multiple crumb cakes from here before. Unfortunately, they are starting to become more crumb and less cake. I’m talking like 1 centimeter of cake at the bottom. It still tastes good, but if I wanted an 8x8 pan of streusel topping, I’d just ask for that. Hoping this review can help save the cake to crumb ratio!

Probably one of the best deli's I've been to food was amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered catering and wow! Everyone raved about the food and you definitely get a lot for your money. Highly impressed!

Some of the best deserts in Sussex County.

All I can say is, Clove Brook made our wedding day all the more perfect! I met with Kim last September when looking for vendors. Pretty much anyone I talked to in Sussex recommended them. I immediately knew why, as I trusted Kim right away.

Leading up to our wedding day, Kim and Rich actively supported us in our decision making. They visited our venue site, and we came up with a plan to make sure the day would go smoothly.

And the day went incredibly smoothly! The cocktail hour had both hand outs and a table for people to take food from. Clove Brooks’s staff were incredibly attentive to our guests. Kim said their staff loves working weddings, and it was cool to see how much they all enjoyed it!

The dinner was phenomenal! We had a buffet of eggplant rollatini, brisket, penne vodka pasta, roasted potatoes, and salad. Everyone raved about the food (especially the brisket). The line went fast and smooth, and everyone had their fill.

For dessert, Clove Brook had a pie bar set up for us… wow! They had so many choices of pies to choose from. Again, yet another thing people raved about! We also had Clove Brook take care of our cake which was perfect.

We trusted Kim and Rich with our day, and we wouldn’t have it any other way. Whether is a Taylor ham egg and cheese, or a big wedding, love is put into the food and service. Go with Clove Brook!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Omgoodness hard to decide. Everything was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Disappointed by Poor Customer Service
My husband and I have been loyal customers of Clovebrook Bakery, often making a 30-minute drive specifically for their incredible scones. Unfortunately, today’s visit was disappointing due to the treatment we received from a staff member named Mia.

From the start, Mia seemed visibly irritated by our presence. We simply asked for a box instead of a bag so our scones wouldn’t get crushed on the drive home. This request appeared to bother her, and we were made to feel like an inconvenience. We then had to request a larger box ourselves, as she made no effort to ask how many items we were purchasing — something that’s always been standard from other staff members in the past.

Without a word, she handed the box to the cashier and walked away. There was no acknowledgment or attempt at basic courtesy. My husband and I were both taken aback by how dismissive and cold the interaction was — especially considering we just drove an hour round-trip for a few scones.

I later went back in to ask for the employee’s name, as I felt the treatment we received was unacceptable. Surprisingly, no one at the counter would identify her — even after I clearly described her and her behavior. It wasn’t until I pointed her out (as she peeked from the back while on her phone) that someone reluctantly told me her name was Mia.

Additionally, I was concerned to see Mia handling baked goods without gloves. Her mood was clearly affecting her work — her fingers kept slipping, and it was unclear whether or not she touched the food directly. None of the staff handling items from the display seemed to be wearing gloves today, which is concerning from a food safety perspective.

We love this bakery and the products they make, but customer service matters — and today’s experience left a bad taste in our mouths. If Mia is struggling with her role, perhaps she would be better suited to working in the back, where she doesn’t have to engage directly with customers. Courtesy, cleanliness, and professionalism are the minimums one should expect when supporting a local business.

We hope Clovebrook takes this feedback seriously and continues to uphold the great standards we’ve come to expect — both in their food and their service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Great food, wonderful service, and beautiful displays.

Homemade cookies, breads, pies, pastries, full beverage cases, sandwiches made to order, and even prepared meals.

They offer breakfast, lunch, and dinner. You wouldn't go wrong here any time of day.

The staff is wonderful, and the menu is too. You'll find a line of regulars here all day, six days a week.

A local staple

Outstanding

Great experience!! Yummy food and friendly staff!!

Clovebrook and the staff were so amazing! They catered our wedding April 19,2025 and I couldn't have been happier with the service as well as the delicious food. Everyone at the wedding said the food was delicious. I had the pleasure of working with Kim to plan and talk to personally about what I wanted and the amount of ppl. Kim guided me through the whole process of knowing amount of food needed as well as cake options. I will be using them in the future for any and all events I need. You will be so pleased with Clovebrook and there Staff.

Amazing hidden gem.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had Clove Brook carrot cake as our wedding cake in 2015, a small two tier, and large amounts of sheet cake. Now, almost 10 years later, friends and family still talk about how our wedding cake was “the best they y ever had” and in a “league of its own”! It was very good cake, and clearly we were not the only ones to feel that way. Thank you Clove Brook market for helping make our wedding so memorable!

Food: 5

This place is a hidden gem from the winter smash pie to the summer smash pie and everything in between. Had a lemon cranberry scone it was the best I have ever had .

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie

Good food good price little busy but fast service 👌

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5