Holland American Bakery

246 NJ-23, Sussex
(973) 875-5258

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Frank Lettieri

Great family bakery

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Allison Szczepanski

We had the most beautiful sheet cake for my baby shower! The cake itself was moist yet light and everyone loved the raspberry filling.
Was just so so happy how beautiful the cake turned out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Summer Dahlquist-Tookey

Literally the most delicious baked goods. Super cute shop and unbelievably friendly staff. Happy we stopped by.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanita Virosa

Lovely old time bakery. With Dutch gifts as well. Its been open since the 50s. Took a variety of the cookies home. Staff was pleasant.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pastries, Cookie Platter 2 5 lbs, Krakelingen Cookies

Marilyn

Beautiful store! Delicious goodies. Loved everything purchased.😋

Snake

Delicious baked goods. A little chaotic knowing when it's your turn to order and a little tight in the space when it gets busy. Still worth the trip and visit.

Check out their ceramics, real pretty high quality at great prices

Carol Grazevich

Wish they were closer! Use to go there when I was a kid we drove from Warwick pine island area to go there!

John Clarke

Want a place to gain weight from just looking? Go no further!!! My wife is out to destroy my diet, and she picked the perfect place to stop. Lots of delicious pastries pies cakes. The cronuts are addictive and you can't eat just one. They have them in glazed, cinnamon sugar, and maple. You can't beat the old-fashioned donuts either. My wife really wanted to try their crumb cake as she heard from a friend how great it is.. Luckily, there was one small piece left. I wish I could tell you how good it was, but it was devoured without sharing

John Swinson

Excellent baked goods, beautiful selection of ceramics, great service.

H G

Amazing bakery with traditional Dutch treats. Nothing else to say. If you know, you know. If you don't know, go and you won't be disappointed.
Also, great weekly fish fry and breakfast sandwiches, but 99.99% we're there for the bakery.

Brittany Wilson

The boterkoek is to die for! I bought a loaf of Dutch rye bread and 3 boxes of De Ruijter sprinkles for the bread! I ordered $80 worth of baked goods and chocolates & bread and spices and my family and I will DEFINITELY be coming back! We travelled 5 & 1/2 hours to come here and we will be coming back before the Summer to stock back up 🩷 This is officially my favourite Dutch bakery since the one in my home country closed down years ago when I was a little girl 🥺🩷

Brittany Keller

The boterkoek is to die for! I bought a loaf of Dutch rye bread and 3 boxes of De Ruijter sprinkles for the bread! I ordered $80 worth of baked goods and chocolates & bread and spices and my family and I will DEFINITELY be coming back! We travelled 5 & 1/2 hours to come here and we will be coming back before the Summer to stock back up 🩷 This is officially my favourite Dutch bakery since the one in my home country closed down years ago when I was a little girl 🥺🩷

P Wtns

Good bread, nice cookie's great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Keene

Absolutely love the food and the staff. They are very attentive and call for more help if it gets busy! Wonderful people

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jay Brekls

First time and everything was delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...