Old Stone

Name: Old Stone
Address: 13 Mill St, Sussex, New Jersey, 07461, US
Telephone: (973) 702-2379
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

$ • Burgers, Sandwich Shops, American

Hours:
13 Mill St, Sussex
(973) 702-2379

Menu Order Online

About Old Stone

Old Stone is a charming restaurant with a warm and welcoming atmosphere, reminiscent of Cracker Barrel. The owners are friendly and attentive, often taking on multiple roles, including waiting tables. The menu offers a unique take on traditional dishes, such as French Toast and Home Fries, which are cooked to perfection. The coffee is decent and accessible, and the bakery cases are always being filled with delicious treats, including vanilla sprinkled donuts and blueberry turnovers. The restaurant's interior features historical accents and antiques, making it feel cozy and all-American. The tables are arranged to provide ample space, and the window seats offer a nice view. Parking is plentiful, with a strip mall lot that’s easily accessible.

Recent reviews highlight the restaurant’s good food, friendly service, and cute, cozy vibe. One customer praised the “AMAZING breakfast sandwich called ‘The Stoner,’” which features fried eggs, meat, and melted cheese between three slices of French Toast, describing it as scrumptious with a generous portion. Another guest appreciated the scratch-made French toast and omelette, mentioning they enjoyed their breakfast during a trip to High Point. However, there was a concern about a $4.50 charge for substituting hash browns for home fries, which was not clearly explained and caused some disappointment, especially considering the total spent.

Overall, Old Stone remains a great spot for a delicious meal and a warm atmosphere. Guests often mention the friendly service, cozy setting, and tasty, homemade dishes, making it a popular choice for breakfast and casual dining.