Old Stone

13 Mill St, Sussex
(973) 702-2379

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Suzy Q Bernstein

Oh my we just left the old stone and all my husband and I can say is AMAZING!!! They have the BEST pancakes!! They’re huge, fluffy, airy, so light and delicious!! One of the best cups of coffees we had and the service was superb!! We have a new breakfast place and we can’t wait to come back!!! Give them a try you won’t be disappointed!!!!

Ashley Vander Berg

The very best food in the area, a beautifully welcoming atmosphere and the sweetest, most attentive and hardworking owner! Our family’s favorite local restaurant for breakfast and lunch☕️🍳🥞

Jason Wasserott

The Old Stone was worth the visit. The Ruben sandwich was phenomenal The best I ever had. The coffee was really good too.

Naomi Wiesen

Cute family owned and run cafe. The place is spotless, the service is super friendly and our breakfast sandwiches were great.

Stacie Andre Raff

It is a very cute place, The food was plentiful and delicious. Service was exceptional.

Dave Reines

We've gone there a few times for breakfast. I had different offerings each time and the meal was delicious.

Jeannine Pagano Williams

well i was all ready to leave a 5 star review.. till the bill came.. food.. service.. everything was just great.. very cute place.. but where I ran into a issue was I asked if I could substitute hash browns for home fries. the eggs came with 2 eggs hash browns and toast.. for a great price I think 7.99.. I was told yes no problem.. so when I got bill there was a 4.50 charge for the hash browns.. I assumed a error was made so we asked.. she said no that you get charged for the substitute.. now had she told me that when I ordered I would have just had the home fries.. but I did not get the home fries with my meal.. so they charged the hash browns as a side. but did not give the home fries that was included.. so although it sounds silly.. i felt they should have been much clearer.. I feel bad even bringing this up but spending 40.00 on 2 breakfast is a bit much...so yes the 4.50 was almost the tip.. which I did leave 6.00.. so yes it was 40 bucks for breakfast.. but still a very cute place.. good food.. friendly..but I was a bit taken back

Russell A

Good breakfast stop, charming atmosphere with delicious bakery items.
Expensive coffee

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Alba Martinez

Best soup and salads !! It’s was a nice lunch experience.

John Grant

Here in Sussex Borough, NJ for a wedding this afternoon and needed a breakfast spot. Did a Google search and almost decided on other more popular local places but was attracted to high review’s especially indicating freshly prepared food. I had an AMAZING breakfast sandwich called “The Stoner” consisting of fried eggs, meat and melted cheese between three slices of French Toast!! Not only scrumptious but a generous portion. EVERYTHING was great about this place!! A must go if you’re in the neighborhood.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen Wildt

What a great find!! On our ride to High Point.. stopped for breakfast!! French toast & omelette were delicious & all from scratch! The service was great & friendly! Really enjoyed it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T. L.

I've never actually been able to get food here because they've been closed anytime I'm in town. So I finally just called early to get the hours and based on the rudeness of whoever answered the phone, I don't really care what the hours are now.

Service: 1

Kara Citarella

I think my favorite part of this place was its history and the decor. It was super charming and full of antiques. The building is from the 19th century, I believe. The French toast wasn’t great, although it was apparently supposed to be really good. I wish there was more room to sit. They didn’t have as many of the teas as advertised. Sometimes, the service was good and sometimes, not as great. Would still go back and try the bakery items. They looked really good. The people who waited on us looked overwhelmed, but seemed to be trying their best.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Nicholas Sciancalepore

I always have such amazing food and service here. DO NOT EXPECT TO LEAVE HUNGRY. Everything is freshly made and the portions are huge. Had one of the best sandwiches I've ever had here. Pictured below: turkey and provolone toasted with Russian dressing and lettuce, tomato and onion. Ssssoooo good. Also get one of their breakfast sandwiches they pack on the meat. Every time I leave full and happy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M. Vitiello

First time here. Owners friendly, good unique and different take on traditional French Toast and Home Fries. Just wished my home fries were cooked longer and seasoned up more. Waitress was one of the owners which I thought was nice but also can be a lot for her at times I imagine. Coffee was decent and accessible, and I see why people come for it. Bakery cases were being filled as my wife and I sat there eating. Everything looked delicious. We took home a vanilla sprinkled donut for our daughter who said it was real good, and wanted to know where we got it from. Guess we will be returning with her. This place has a real nice homey, antique, all American Vibe. Reminded me of Cracker Barrel a bit. The outside is deceiving to what it looks like on the inside.

Parking: Plenty of strip mall parking although it directly places you backing out into highway traffic. That’s the only down side. If room, I would either back into spot prior to parking or turn around in available spots if any to get out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: 2 Eggs, French Toast

Loading...