This was our 2nd visit ! We are so sorry we don't have the names of the 1st servers who took such beautiful care of us!! Last Sat was Matteo & like our previous servers a SWEETHEART! Everything was delicious & perfect!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mateo Jimenez
Everything was good just some minor things and the wait times can be a bit much but I really time the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Julie Ruth
Eggs Benedict
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ian
If you want to go broke go here, $25 for a mid burger.
Mach5 Speedracer (Mach5speedracer)
Great tasting variety of meals. The bakery is a great stop to bring home some baked goods. We make the Oldwick General Store a stop for lunch when we have a drive with the Fiat Club America car club. Its been our stop for over 20 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samer E
Their falafel needs work
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Andrea Maranca
I just ordered a jersey special with extra meat. Best jersey special I ever had, and I'm an expert! Great job Sam, kudos to you and your team!
Nancy Rush
I can't say enough good things about this place! Amazing chefs, amazing food, and amazing service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Bollmann
Large portions friendly staff and the prices are reasonable. Glad the new(est) owner did what they did and made the investment as the previous was becoming a disappointment. I haven't tried their ice cream window yet maybe next spring
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Kira Theesfeld
YUM!! My whole family agrees that your egg & cheese sandwiches are HANDS DOWN the best we’ve ever had. And the warm cinnamon roll… redonk!
I can’t wait to try all the prepared foods I picked up to bring down she shore for Labor Day Weekend. Thanks for kicking off the holiday for my family with lots of smiles and full bellies!
We love the Oldwick General Store. It’s a quaint country restaurant with wonderful food, good service……a lovely place to gather with family and friends. Tonight we so enjoyed the monthly Chef prepped Gourmet Corn and Tomato dinner outdoors. Seated at long tables with wonderful people who gathered for this beautiful communal dinner. The five course meal was a delicious 5 star event. The fabulous chef, Sam Freund made it a memorable evening. It’s gonna be tempting not to go every month. Linda and Allen Seidman
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Smith
I was looking at the breakfast menu and I saw that an additional egg was $3. I can buy a dozen farm fresh eggs retail for $7. I moved on to the lunch menu.
I had the Greek Freak and it was very good and the portion size was large. I didn’t walk away hungry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mr Les
This quaint general store offers high end home made baked goods including their own bread and a gourmet breakfast that beats everyone in the same category. Price at a minimum for what you get. House made jam, pastrami, innovative omelettes and great clean coffee. Service is always on point. Highly recommend
Juan Carlos De Jesús
Excelent!!! Delicious breakfast! Nice and kind waitress!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samson
We had a good experience overall - good inventive sandwiches with homemade rolls. Fresh potato chips and fries. Old country store ambience in a cute small town. I also like that they offer table service.
Here’s why it’s not 5 stars ….
1) while the rolls are homemade, it appears they’re used for all/most?of the sandwiches - it’s not suitable to use that roll for all the sandwiches, ie, there should be a variety of breads used (ie, rye, ciabatta, etc) - also the rolls, while good, don’t hold up to some of the heartier sandwiches
2) in particular, as concerns the pastrami sandwich, rather than the typical thin-sliced deli pastrami, the pastrami is served in huge chunks on the roll, which makes it nearly impossible to eat as a sandwich, as the huge chunks simply fall out of the roll (this is not rocket science here) - while I’m sure the chef likes his unique take on pastrami, do people actually prefer eating a pastrami sandwich this way?
3) finally, while it was a hot day when we were there, it was way too warm to comfortably have lunch in the dining area - please adequately cool the space so customers will be comfortable
This was our 2nd visit ! We are so sorry we don't have the names of the 1st servers who took such beautiful care of us!! Last Sat was Matteo & like our previous servers a SWEETHEART! Everything was delicious & perfect!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was good just some minor things and the wait times can be a bit much but I really time the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Eggs Benedict
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you want to go broke go here, $25 for a mid burger.
Great tasting variety of meals. The bakery is a great stop to bring home some baked goods. We make the Oldwick General Store a stop for lunch when we have a drive with the Fiat Club America car club. Its been our stop for over 20 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their falafel needs work
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I just ordered a jersey special with extra meat. Best jersey special I ever had, and I'm an expert! Great job Sam, kudos to you and your team!
I can't say enough good things about this place! Amazing chefs, amazing food, and amazing service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Large portions friendly staff and the prices are reasonable. Glad the new(est) owner did what they did and made the investment as the previous was becoming a disappointment. I haven't tried their ice cream window yet maybe next spring
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
YUM!! My whole family agrees that your egg & cheese sandwiches are HANDS DOWN the best we’ve ever had. And the warm cinnamon roll… redonk!
I can’t wait to try all the prepared foods I picked up to bring down she shore for Labor Day Weekend. Thanks for kicking off the holiday for my family with lots of smiles and full bellies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We love the Oldwick General Store. It’s a quaint country restaurant with wonderful food, good service……a lovely place to gather with family and friends.
Tonight we so enjoyed the monthly Chef prepped Gourmet Corn and Tomato dinner outdoors. Seated at long tables with wonderful people who gathered for this beautiful communal dinner. The five course meal was a delicious 5 star event. The fabulous chef, Sam Freund made it a memorable evening. It’s gonna be tempting not to go every month.
Linda and Allen Seidman
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was looking at the breakfast menu and I saw that an additional egg was $3. I can buy a dozen farm fresh eggs retail for $7. I moved on to the lunch menu.
I had the Greek Freak and it was very good and the portion size was large. I didn’t walk away hungry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This quaint general store offers high end home made baked goods including their own bread and a gourmet breakfast that beats everyone in the same category. Price at a minimum for what you get. House made jam, pastrami, innovative omelettes and great clean coffee. Service is always on point. Highly recommend
Excelent!!! Delicious breakfast! Nice and kind waitress!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a good experience overall - good inventive sandwiches with homemade rolls. Fresh potato chips and fries. Old country store ambience in a cute small town. I also like that they offer table service.
Here’s why it’s not 5 stars ….
1) while the rolls are homemade, it appears they’re used for all/most?of the sandwiches - it’s not suitable to use that roll for all the sandwiches, ie, there should be a variety of breads used (ie, rye, ciabatta, etc) - also the rolls, while good, don’t hold up to some of the heartier sandwiches
2) in particular, as concerns the pastrami sandwich, rather than the typical thin-sliced deli pastrami, the pastrami is served in huge chunks on the roll, which makes it nearly impossible to eat as a sandwich, as the huge chunks simply fall out of the roll (this is not rocket science here) - while I’m sure the chef likes his unique take on pastrami, do people actually prefer eating a pastrami sandwich this way?
3) finally, while it was a hot day when we were there, it was way too warm to comfortably have lunch in the dining area - please adequately cool the space so customers will be comfortable
Loading...