Gargiulo's Tinton Falls

Food and service and ambience are fantastic. Have gone back twice and will continue. Highly recommend

Always like going back home and being with family! So much warmth and love along with great food and service

We have dined here many times before, but this evening was very disappointing. The service was abysmal. The waitress took our order and disappeared. Never checked if we needed drinks etc. When our caesar salad arrived it was drowning in dressing. We could not find anyone to address this. We finally got a hold of the manager, Victor, to get a refill on a soda because our waitress was nowhere to be found, and when he Brought it, and asked how is everything, I told him about the salad. He said that I should have said something, but again, our waitress , no one, was anywhere to be found. We left with no apology. We we will not return

The server brought my husband the wrong entree. Then when the sole arrived it had the wrong side vegetable. It was very good, though. My roasted eggplant was bland and tasteless. The server knew it was our 35th anniversary celebration but did not even bother to bring us a candle or anything to acknowledge.

We were pleasantly surprised at how good the food and service was. Joe, the bartender was attentive and made perfect cocktails.

So many restaurants at the shore are closed on a Monday so this was such a pleasant surprise thanks to my search on open table that they were open and had availability. We were the only ones in the restaurant and I don't understand how that could be possible because the place is adorable. The waiter Joe was just so lovely and friendly and helpful. We were celebrating my friend's birthday. We shared an amazing fennel salad the Cacio de Pepe and my friend who is Italian said it was the best tiramisu he's ever had. I can't wait to go back.

EXCELLENT AS ALWAYS FOOD AND SERVICE WERE EXCELLENT GRAHAM CRACKER GELATO FOR DESSERT IS PHENOMENAL

From valet parking to exiting the restaurant the evening was excellent! The staff was friendly and accommodating, the wine was very good, and the food was delicious. The Maitre D was awesome and checked on us a few times. I would recommend this location and look forward to going back! Patricia

Altogether charming! Small place at intersection of secondary roads. Unexpected valet parking, fire pit, friendly bar, DR neither too big or small, great menu outdone by the food and excellent service. Bill is presented w Italian lottery to see if it's ‘on the house!' Only wish restaurant was open later for dinner.

The service was amazing. Everyone was so friendly. There was a fault with the bottle of wine we ordered, the manager (or owner?) came up to apologize and chat with us. He opened a new bottle in front of us and tasted it, and that bottle was excellent! This issue was handled so well. The rice balls were crispy and light, excellent. We also absolutely loved the graham cracker gelato. Both are mains were very solid. Great experience, we will be back

Services was really bad waiter never came to our table to take our order after giving us our appetizers.. The hostess took our order then another person came over to see if everything ok got our drinks..Very disappointed the way we where treated..1star for the waiter

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

FABULOUS 👌 Our first time experience and it was LOVELY!! We felt like family, everyone, owners, our Waiter Dave, singer Gina, all fantastic! Food excellent! Thank you, we will be back!! Mare & Lyn

This was the first time my family and I had visited this place. We loved it from the beautiful outdoor seating and view, to the delicious food and great service from Dave. I had the Cacio e Pepe with a Rosé wine. It was amazing. The baked calamari was tremendous as well as the clams. The flourless chocolate cake was 11/10. I can't wait to go back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Worst parking situation. Outdoor dining had 4 tables overlooking the valet. The corn/shrimp fritter was small . You only get 2 for $18.00. My pasta bolognese was very good. Perfect pasta and sauce was incredible. Can do without the skimpy amount of meat $26.00. The shrimp scampi left a lot to be desired. They were large but tasted like they were frozen, thawed out and then added breadcrumbs . Sauce watery $36.00

Escarole & bean soup as our appetizer was delicious! Spouse had the pork chop and & I had the fra diavlo risotto special with shrimp and sausage amazing!