I like the ice cream sandwiches here, but my family called saying we wouldn’t be at the shop until 9:50 (it closes at 10) and asked it to please stay open until it’s stated closing time. They sounded annoyed and said sure and then we got there at 9:50 and they were closed. Please make your closing time 9:30 or 9:45 on Google then, and it would be nice if you were more accommodating for your customers.
Andrew Righter
unbelievably GOOD!
Sean Martin
Good Shop, But One Thing Felt Out of Place
Stopped by to pick up an order and overall everything was fine. However, I did feel a bit uncomfortable with one staff member’s shirt — it was an IDF (Israel Defense Forces) shirt. Considering the store is called Peace Pie and has peace signs displayed all around, it just felt a little out of place in that setting.
That said, I still enjoy their products and will continue coming here — just wanted to share my observation.
The NVP Show
My favorite ice cream place to go to when I'm in Ventnor City! The flavor selections are a lot and great. The sandwiches are kept in great condition to enjoy them the most. It's also not far from the beach which is convenient.
Robyn D. Kazatsky
Amazing!!! So delicious last night. I had the peanut butter bar and my son had a caramel apple one. Perfection.
CleverGirl
I adore peace pie. A creative idea with a variety of flavors. I will say the price of per sandwich is a bit steep but enjoyable nonetheless.
Steve Biebel
I wish these were sold on the beach, good thing they are only two blocks from the boardwalk. Peace pies will change your life. Coffee toffee and Jersey Devil for the win! There is no greater reward than a peace pie after a bike ride over three bridges.
Theresa Rose-Jertson
Pricy but worth it very good ice cream combos with pie filling on an ice cream sandwich cookie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Blumberg
These are our absolute favorite ice cream sandwiches!!! Think gourmet ice cream between two gourmet cookies. Yum!!!!
These are great sandwiches. Ice cream combos are excellent . Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich
Haley Kleespies
Love this place, but their hours say that they’re open until 9pm in multiple places and they weren’t open when we got there at 8:15.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Cobbler
Brad Bernstein
Simply the best. I even go here when I have dinner at Stella right next store and I love that place. Can’t pass up a peace pie.
Mike
Nope, not worth $8 for a sandwich that is smaller than what you normally find, which they conveniently hide from the menu. Ice cream is pretty blah. And cookie dough doesn’t even have cookie dough in the ice cream? Lame-oh!
rpitetti1
Excellent product!! Great variety of flavors Yumm!!!
I like the ice cream sandwiches here, but my family called saying we wouldn’t be at the shop until 9:50 (it closes at 10) and asked it to please stay open until it’s stated closing time. They sounded annoyed and said sure and then we got there at 9:50 and they were closed. Please make your closing time 9:30 or 9:45 on Google then, and it would be nice if you were more accommodating for your customers.
unbelievably GOOD!
Good Shop, But One Thing Felt Out of Place
Stopped by to pick up an order and overall everything was fine. However, I did feel a bit uncomfortable with one staff member’s shirt — it was an IDF (Israel Defense Forces) shirt. Considering the store is called Peace Pie and has peace signs displayed all around, it just felt a little out of place in that setting.
That said, I still enjoy their products and will continue coming here — just wanted to share my observation.
My favorite ice cream place to go to when I'm in Ventnor City! The flavor selections are a lot and great. The sandwiches are kept in great condition to enjoy them the most. It's also not far from the beach which is convenient.
Amazing!!! So delicious last night. I had the peanut butter bar and my son had a caramel apple one. Perfection.
I adore peace pie. A creative idea with a variety of flavors. I will say the price of per sandwich is a bit steep but enjoyable nonetheless.
I wish these were sold on the beach, good thing they are only two blocks from the boardwalk. Peace pies will change your life. Coffee toffee and Jersey Devil for the win! There is no greater reward than a peace pie after a bike ride over three bridges.
Pricy but worth it very good ice cream combos with pie filling on an ice cream sandwich cookie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These are our absolute favorite ice cream sandwiches!!! Think gourmet ice cream between two gourmet cookies. Yum!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Bun, Strawberry Shortcake, Ice Cream Sandwich, Key Lime Pie, Peanut Butter Cup
Best part of going to the beach
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
These are great sandwiches. Ice cream combos are excellent . Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich
Love this place, but their hours say that they’re open until 9pm in multiple places and they weren’t open when we got there at 8:15.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Cobbler
Simply the best. I even go here when I have dinner at Stella right next store and I love that place. Can’t pass up a peace pie.
Nope, not worth $8 for a sandwich that is smaller than what you normally find, which they conveniently hide from the menu. Ice cream is pretty blah. And cookie dough doesn’t even have cookie dough in the ice cream? Lame-oh!
Excellent product!! Great variety of flavors Yumm!!!
Loading...