Cheesesteaks & Shakes

308 Bloomfield Ave, Verona
(973) 860-7120

Recent Reviews

BKLYN Frank

We just found this great cheesesteak place last summer and now they've closed for good ... so sad ?

Sonia S.

This place violates health codes. I ordered the classic Cheesesteak sandwich. I waited a while then someone who was eating at a table inside suddenly said " this isn't my sandwich, I didn't order this ". The woman behind the counter then realizes it's the one I ordered, and proceeds to put that very same sand in a bag and give it to me. Um, what? Thats unhygienic and anyone who's taken a food handlers license test knows this. Then to add insult to injury, she then looks at my stomach and asks me " when's the baby due? " I'm not pregnant, and that's extremely rude. Will never give my money to this place again and can't fathom how they're in business. Avoid, avoid.

Frank Nicotero

Great Cheesesteak, loved the fries, great fried cauliflower and wings. Topped it off with a coffee shake very friendly service everything was excellent

C K

Wow! Great food good music and Annette was awesome!!! She was smiling the entire time gave us some awesome suggestions and hooked it up! Definitely be back to try more of the menu…. But thumbs up on the cheese steaks, burgers, chicken fingers and ice cream!

Al And Dee R.

I usually never leave negative reviews but this has to be the worst chicken "sandwich" because as you can see it is not a chicken cheesesteak. Let's start with the chicken: the chicken was cubed as opposed to actual chicken steak strips, then it was the most unseasoned chicken I have ever had. Even with the whiz cheese, ketchup and bbq sauce I could not cover how tasteless and bland this chicken was. The whiz cheese did not taste like authentic whiz cheese. It tasted like the pretzel dipping cheese. Then the French fries: please note the crown fried chicken container pictured. The fries were decent and had some salt on them but not as crispy as fries typically come. Overall, this was an unpleasant eating experience and I do not recommend this place to anyone. Honestly I'm still hungry and now sad.

Tom O.

We've passed this place a bunch of times, and it is definitely an inviting looking place. We ordered 3 cheesesteaks, which came on half subs + 3 drinks (nonalcoholic) came to about $65. Not so much the cost, but the quality was not there. These cheesesteaks were just OK... Not terrible but not great.

Lokai K.

This place is pretty good the staff is really nice and helpful. The Famous cheesesteak is really delicious the right amount of greasiness. I had the chicken cheesesteak and was thrown off with the grilled chicken cut up. Compared to other places that sell chicken cheesesteaks it just doesn't compare. The milkshakes and the root beer floats are pretty good so you should definitely try those. I will be back to try different things on the menu.

Ernest

Decent cheesesteaks. There are not many spots that do it right on north Jersey, but this place definitely fills a void. I liked the style of the restaurant as well. I wish I would have gotten the milk shake because it looked good, but I wasn't feeling sweets that day. Regarding the cheese steak it's self, the greesiness was right on point and the cheese wiz was good! My gripes: the bread needed to be slightly more absorbent and the fries were not really particularly tasty (for $4 I expected more I guess). Overall, I give this place a 2.6 out of 5.

BossLyfeInc LyfeInc

All I can say is 5 stars!!! My 9 yr old son googled this place and we took the 35 minute drive that was well worth the trip. The cheesesteak was amazing!!! Quality, fresh ingredients !!! The root beer float took me back to my childhood! Also great customer service from the moment we walked in until the moment we left. We are definitely going to be frequent customers.

Brandon Cole

First time here. The phily cheesesteak was the best I ever had. The owner/cook Louie is great. He took the time to explain the quality of the meat and how it's prepared. He's also very funny and is always singing to the Sinatra music playing. Great food, great service and very Clean. I wish there were more than 5 stars to give him.

Christopher C.

We just landed in NJ and needed nutrition after a long red eye flight. Our Airbnb was located nearby and we wanted a quick meal before heading into NYC for the evening. This place hit the spot! We ordered at the location and got legit NJ small business vibes. From the ambiance that takes you back in time, to the owner being chef to customers, it had a great homey feel. The food was amazing and we left satisfied. Great value, portions are hearty, and we love supporting small businesses

Trent C.

this place was awful, the cheesesteak was terrible; not to mention they don't listen to directions very well. I told the girl no onions 5 times. b/c I could tell she wasn't absorbing what I was telling her and to no surprise my cheese had onions in it. its one thing to have mediocre food; but dense staff and mediocre food is a recipe for non recurring business,

Taylor Hart

OK service was wonderful, please have a good vibe. I ended up spending $20 on a cheesesteak when I told myself I wasn’t going to spend $20 on pasta earlier, which brought me here. I took like four bites thought I would have to drive home and add more cheese. and drove on my way home. I don’t know what was in it but I threw up on the way home also. In the bag with the cheese steak.

J M.R.

I can't ?. I usually get cheesesteaks in Philly (as a must do when in town), but this place had me coming back 3days in a row....I had to slow it down my pockets were crying.....I was driving 40 minutes from home ordering multiple sandwiches ?, paying tolls. Haven't reviewed because this place was going to be my little secret,but the cravings are kicking in.BTW staff was pleasant nice, friendly and sweet.

Mark B.

I went to the place at 8:45pm and they gave me a bunch attitude because they wanted to close early. The one guy said cursed and the lady said she closed the register already. Friday night and closing early????? Terrible service and will Not go back

Load More