Cyndi made our whole wedding cake process so easy! She was super responsive the whole time and we did not have to worry about anything. The cake tasted amazing and turned out even better than we could have hoped for! Highly recommend getting your cake from a Piece of Cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Holly Corkill
We used A Piece of Cake for our wedding and they were incredible! The cake was amazing and cookies were incredible! We would recommend anyone to go here for any baked goods needs! They were so easy to work with it. We were out of town and she still made it so easy to work with her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Show
Their apple pie ice cream tastes exactly like apple pie ala mode with less crust but all the flavor you would want!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Erika Poderis
Beautiful cake and cupcakes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristen Killian
This is absolutely perfect! I couldn't have asked for anything more!!! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tracey Huskey
Was looking for a bakery because I want a good cupcake so I decided to try a piece of cake I got two different kinds one cotton candy one Pina cola the cotton candy the cake is very very dry the icing which is a whole.lot for a small cupcake doesn't even taste like cotton candy at Ann and the blue filling inside is the same way the icing tasted like mint or something but nothing like cotton candy the Pina cola is the same way the cake is very very dry and way to much icing on a small cupcake no Pina cola flavor everything looks so good but when you taste it it's very dry and nothing like what they are saying it is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Ashley Sullivan
Ordered cupcakes for a baby sprinkle! The staff was so accommodating and helpful, and the cupcakes were absolutely DELISH!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew
They completely messed up the flavoring. I asked for vanilla and then they tried to say that vanilla was inside. It was more like a butter, scotch or butter cream that was inside. It definitely wasn’t vanilla! They were also very rude when I asked for some type of credit back because they ruin the whole cake that I couldn’t even eat for $133. Won’t be back very rude.
Elizabeth Howe
whatever i tried was good, however looked into here for my birthday stuff.. found out they freeze stuff & then put it in the case.. not fresh baked daily…
Lynda Wayne
During cutting the cake we noticed all of the flowers were held together with non edible wires. Please make sure your customers know this. We almost had a child and an elderly woman swallow the wire as it was hiding under icing. We were not made aware during pick up.The cake delicious but customers should be made aware.Edit- we called to let them know and they were incredibly non-responsive and rude. For $80 I guess that doesn’t purchase customer service or kindness. Won’t be back.
Delicious cake, the sweetest family, and the cupcakes are to die for! I love this small business. This family is absolutely the best, and most thoughtful people we've met in Cape May. They go above and beyond the request!! This cake my son chose was their lemon cake with raspberry filling -- and it was DELICIOUS! You could totally taste the lemon in the cake! And their cupcakes?! Ahmayzing. So many flavors and so fresh and delicious. Cannot recommend this business enough!
Cammi McCune
Cyndi did an entire dessert display and wedding cake for our wedding. When I tell you every single guest said it was the best wedding cake and the best dessert display they have ever had.. I mean every single guest. We were so happy with the service and not to mention Cyndi was an absolute sweetheart. Would recommend 1000x over to anyone getting married at the jersey shore. I already have friends asking where she is located so that they can get their next birthday cake here. Couldn’t be happier!
Alexa Pagano
A Piece of Cake was fantastic to work with. We got married at the Grand Hotel in Cape May on August 26. Cyndi made my vision of an elegant-beach themed wedding cake come to life. Everyone complimented on how delicious our desserts and cake were; and how BEAUTIFUL our wedding cake was. Definitely recommend her to anyone getting married!
Mia Chiarella
My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and so delicious ! Thank you !
Kristen Leigh
My Fiancé found this amazing bakery online, we are from Lancaster PA but will be getting married in Cape May and did not want to try and travel with a wedding cake and 2 golden retrievers 3hrs... the shop is clean, cute, and very inviting. we tried 2 cupcakes (which were AH-MAZING) but I knew I would be happy with their work after talking to the owner and her 2 sweet daughters. I can not wait to see her take on our cake. now to schedule our official tasting so we can try to pick flavors lol
Cyndi made our whole wedding cake process so easy! She was super responsive the whole time and we did not have to worry about anything. The cake tasted amazing and turned out even better than we could have hoped for! Highly recommend getting your cake from a Piece of Cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
We used A Piece of Cake for our wedding and they were incredible! The cake was amazing and cookies were incredible! We would recommend anyone to go here for any baked goods needs! They were so easy to work with it. We were out of town and she still made it so easy to work with her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their apple pie ice cream tastes exactly like apple pie ala mode with less crust but all the flavor you would want!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Beautiful cake and cupcakes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is absolutely perfect! I couldn't have asked for anything more!!! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was looking for a bakery because I want a good cupcake so I decided to try a piece of cake I got two different kinds one cotton candy one Pina cola the cotton candy the cake is very very dry the icing which is a whole.lot for a small cupcake doesn't even taste like cotton candy at Ann and the blue filling inside is the same way the icing tasted like mint or something but nothing like cotton candy the Pina cola is the same way the cake is very very dry and way to much icing on a small cupcake no Pina cola flavor everything looks so good but when you taste it it's very dry and nothing like what they are saying it is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Ordered cupcakes for a baby sprinkle! The staff was so accommodating and helpful, and the cupcakes were absolutely DELISH!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They completely messed up the flavoring. I asked for vanilla and then they tried to say that vanilla was inside. It was more like a butter, scotch or butter cream that was inside. It definitely wasn’t vanilla! They were also very rude when I asked for some type of credit back because they ruin the whole cake that I couldn’t even eat for $133. Won’t be back very rude.
whatever i tried was good, however looked into here for my birthday stuff.. found out they freeze stuff & then put it in the case.. not fresh baked daily…
During cutting the cake we noticed all of the flowers were held together with non edible wires. Please make sure your customers know this. We almost had a child and an elderly woman swallow the wire as it was hiding under icing. We were not made aware during pick up.The cake delicious but customers should be made aware.Edit- we called to let them know and they were incredibly non-responsive and rude. For $80 I guess that doesn’t purchase customer service or kindness. Won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious cake, the sweetest family, and the cupcakes are to die for! I love this small business. This family is absolutely the best, and most thoughtful people we've met in Cape May. They go above and beyond the request!! This cake my son chose was their lemon cake with raspberry filling -- and it was DELICIOUS! You could totally taste the lemon in the cake! And their cupcakes?! Ahmayzing. So many flavors and so fresh and delicious. Cannot recommend this business enough!
Cyndi did an entire dessert display and wedding cake for our wedding. When I tell you every single guest said it was the best wedding cake and the best dessert display they have ever had.. I mean every single guest. We were so happy with the service and not to mention Cyndi was an absolute sweetheart. Would recommend 1000x over to anyone getting married at the jersey shore. I already have friends asking where she is located so that they can get their next birthday cake here. Couldn’t be happier!
A Piece of Cake was fantastic to work with. We got married at the Grand Hotel in Cape May on August 26. Cyndi made my vision of an elegant-beach themed wedding cake come to life. Everyone complimented on how delicious our desserts and cake were; and how BEAUTIFUL our wedding cake was. Definitely recommend her to anyone getting married!
My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and so delicious ! Thank you !
My Fiancé found this amazing bakery online, we are from Lancaster PA but will be getting married in Cape May and did not want to try and travel with a wedding cake and 2 golden retrievers 3hrs... the shop is clean, cute, and very inviting. we tried 2 cupcakes (which were AH-MAZING) but I knew I would be happy with their work after talking to the owner and her 2 sweet daughters. I can not wait to see her take on our cake. now to schedule our official tasting so we can try to pick flavors lol
Loading...