Amster’s Prospect Tavern

18 W Prospect St, Waldwick
(201) 652-9819

Recent Reviews

Tony Dadika

LOL. It was a little funny when I asked why that Sam Adam's was $8 and was told domestic beer was $5. I always thought Boston was in the United States.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Dave Ciccolella

Great food, live music, trivia, and more. Always have a good time here. Great patio too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zigi Putnins

Great neighborhood bar. Good food. Friendly crowd. Outdoor court in the back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M J

Skip!!! Very disappointed with the quality of food, portion size and very expensive for a dive bar. Was excited to try this place again after hearing they had made some upgrades. Was confused when entering seeing the bar was exactly the same dive bar it was a few years ago when I was there last. Way overpriced for it still being a dive bar with a dining room tucked in the back and misses the mark in terms of trying to “upscale”. The food was not good and portions were minimal for the price of $15-$18 and dipping sauces were left off. I would equate it to airport food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Valerie Paranicas

Use to be a place of great food and excellent value. In the last few months the portions have become minuscule with missing items like the two onion rings with your burger. Even the pickle is almost invisible .You get charged for a cheese burger even if you order a plain burger. A glass of wine is a tiny measured amount not even close to the generous portion of just a few months ago. Prices have had a large percentage increase. The food is not even close to “Norm’s” - the previous owners standard.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Valerie P.

Was a great place with good food and value. Recent changes in the last few months with minuscule portions, missing items like onion rings with the Burger. Charged for a cheese burger even if you order a plain burger. Big percentage increases in everything.Measured tiny amount of wine. Not a good value anymore. You can dine in a much finer restaurant for these prices - it's just a local Watering Hole from before prohibition.

Jonathan Isernhagen

We loved the old place but also the new management. Very good Moscow mules and the appetizers were delicious, though they had run out of the cauliflower. The waitress was charming and attentive and there was a great piano player who played Sinatra-style greats and Billy Joel's "Piano Man" unobtrusively while we ate. The outdoor courtyard is perfect this time of year.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbara O'Donnell

Great casual place. Half-priced drinks at happy hour. Food is freshly made! Friendly staff

Meagan A.

Best tavern around! Great service and food is always consistent. Love the live music on Wednesday nights and the outdoor patio once the weather gets nice

Allison L.

Sparkling clean, under the new owners. 1/2 price appetizers and 1/2 price drinks during happy hour (4-6). Reasonable prices and interesting specials that we look forward to trying soon. Trivia on Thursdays and live music on other days. What a refreshing change from another local place that is also under new ownership. We will make Amster's our new hangout! Shout out to bartender Brian, great service, and keeps the bar fun.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Joanne G.

Burgers and cheesesteaks were fine. Everything else about the place... meh. New owners seem to be missing the mark. Sadly probably won't be back.

Donna Dranikowski

Great little family owned place. Food, service and drinks are all on point!!!

Willie Walker

Mussels in white wine were Extremely delicious. Brian the tender was great. New ownership is heading in the right direction. Check it out.

Barbara Costello

Bar type menuFood was goodCasual atmosphereNice place to

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

L S.

Great food and service. Don't let the front appearance keep you away- it's a hidden g.

Load More