Good pizza, but the owner doesn’t know manners or simple kindness. Gets overwhelmed & takes it out on his own customers who ARE UNDERSTANDING of the rush
C. WARREN
I miss the Luigi’s pizza on Doris Avenue. This new Luigi’s on Sunset is nothing like it. I was happy when Luigi’s returned to the area and bought pies on different occasions and was unhappy. They were tasteless, the sauce tasted as if it was diluted. The original Luigi’s has been the best in the area for years. Now back at the The Original Attilio's Pizza in Tinton Falls.
Diane Van Note
I love Luigi’s so much my mom and I ride all the way from Toms River to get pizza from here but today was very disappointed in them the pizza was all burned couldn’t even eat it too hard I mean for $20.25 I should be able to enjoy it I don’t think we will be down there no time soon after this experience give them sometime to get their act together and maybe we will return
Smiley Harris
Grew up eatting Luigi's pizza! Has not changed in over 40 years. I moved out if state years ago but EVERY time U come back to visit my parents I must grab a pie to take back with me. The ingredients are always fresh and their dishes full of flavor. You will not be disappointed!!
Bobby Willard
They kept the name, they kept the shape of the pizza...but this isn't the same pizza that was on Doris Ave for decades. Not terrible...but not worth the 30 bucks for a 2 topping large.
Jacob Kostakis
The owner of this establishment Kelly Barrone who lives at 94 Locust Avenue Neptune City NJ, 07753 - doesn’t pay his employees and he bounces checksHis address is 94 Locust Avenue and he drives a new Lincoln Navigator -If he owes you money pay him a visit :) that’s his address or if you wanna sue him send the judgement papers there that’s all the info you needSmall claims court superior court in freehold NJ is where you go for the papers to file a suit against this man for unpaid wages
Gary Hibberd
The medium sounded barely bigger than a personal pizza, so we ordered the next size up, which was not large, but XL. Added sausage on half. Bill came to almost $25! Pizza was okay, but not that great, and it was so thin that there was not much to it. For $25! I don't know how they will be able to stay in business with those prices. Such a poor value.
Douglas Haddad
Brings me straight back to my youth. Fresh pie is the way to go for me. ? Yum!
Michael Avedikian
Pizza was delicious! Nothing more you can ask for. Thin crust, delicious sauce and not overly cheesy or oily. Perfect proportions of everything. My family and I ate the entire X- Large pizza wishing we got more. This is that classic Luigi’s famous taste. Nothing but good things to say.
ASH27 Slick
This pizza is average and a little pricey and definitely not as good as it was years ago. Maybe they changed food vendors, ingredients or both. It just doesn't taste the same. Also- injecting politics and having offensive shirts and other items plastered in the front of the store so every person can see it is a great way to lose customers and go out of business. Extremely unprofessional establishment. I live locally and I won't be back.
Every time I order a pizza here they “accidentally” make a square pie and charge me for it, even though it’s not what I ask for and a square pie costs a lot more. I let it go on three separate occasions but now when you go in you are bombarded with political merch. Whole place is a bad shady vibe
Charlie McCarrick
They were mystified by vegan pizza but they gave us one anyways so 10/10 haha. They were very friendly
Angie Kulesz
We're going to stick to pizza because it's always been fantastic. The entrees and subs. Go somewhere else. I thought I had COVID because it had no taste or flavor. The cheese on the sub was waxy. The menu on delivery services do not match and when I called to make correction they said they handled and did not. We threw $50 into the trash.
jennifer daly
I ordered take out, oily beyond belief, penne carbonara and garlic bread with cheese. The food was inedible.
Lisa West
Ordered 2 medium pizzas both we’re burnt and I ordered a calzone since when do calzones have sesame seeds on them never and they made it like a Stromboli very disappointed
Good pizza, but the owner doesn’t know manners or simple kindness. Gets overwhelmed & takes it out on his own customers who ARE UNDERSTANDING of the rush
I miss the Luigi’s pizza on Doris Avenue. This new Luigi’s on Sunset is nothing like it. I was happy when Luigi’s returned to the area and bought pies on different occasions and was unhappy. They were tasteless, the sauce tasted as if it was diluted. The original Luigi’s has been the best in the area for years. Now back at the The Original Attilio's Pizza in Tinton Falls.
I love Luigi’s so much my mom and I ride all the way from Toms River to get pizza from here but today was very disappointed in them the pizza was all burned couldn’t even eat it too hard I mean for $20.25 I should be able to enjoy it I don’t think we will be down there no time soon after this experience give them sometime to get their act together and maybe we will return
Grew up eatting Luigi's pizza! Has not changed in over 40 years. I moved out if state years ago but EVERY time U come back to visit my parents I must grab a pie to take back with me. The ingredients are always fresh and their dishes full of flavor. You will not be disappointed!!
They kept the name, they kept the shape of the pizza...but this isn't the same pizza that was on Doris Ave for decades. Not terrible...but not worth the 30 bucks for a 2 topping large.
The owner of this establishment Kelly Barrone who lives at 94 Locust Avenue Neptune City NJ, 07753 - doesn’t pay his employees and he bounces checksHis address is 94 Locust Avenue and he drives a new Lincoln Navigator -If he owes you money pay him a visit :) that’s his address or if you wanna sue him send the judgement papers there that’s all the info you needSmall claims court superior court in freehold NJ is where you go for the papers to file a suit against this man for unpaid wages
The medium sounded barely bigger than a personal pizza, so we ordered the next size up, which was not large, but XL. Added sausage on half. Bill came to almost $25! Pizza was okay, but not that great, and it was so thin that there was not much to it. For $25! I don't know how they will be able to stay in business with those prices. Such a poor value.
Brings me straight back to my youth. Fresh pie is the way to go for me. ? Yum!
Pizza was delicious! Nothing more you can ask for. Thin crust, delicious sauce and not overly cheesy or oily. Perfect proportions of everything. My family and I ate the entire X- Large pizza wishing we got more. This is that classic Luigi’s famous taste. Nothing but good things to say.
This pizza is average and a little pricey and definitely not as good as it was years ago. Maybe they changed food vendors, ingredients or both. It just doesn't taste the same. Also- injecting politics and having offensive shirts and other items plastered in the front of the store so every person can see it is a great way to lose customers and go out of business. Extremely unprofessional establishment. I live locally and I won't be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Every time I order a pizza here they “accidentally” make a square pie and charge me for it, even though it’s not what I ask for and a square pie costs a lot more. I let it go on three separate occasions but now when you go in you are bombarded with political merch. Whole place is a bad shady vibe
They were mystified by vegan pizza but they gave us one anyways so 10/10 haha. They were very friendly
We're going to stick to pizza because it's always been fantastic. The entrees and subs. Go somewhere else. I thought I had COVID because it had no taste or flavor. The cheese on the sub was waxy. The menu on delivery services do not match and when I called to make correction they said they handled and did not. We threw $50 into the trash.
I ordered take out, oily beyond belief, penne carbonara and garlic bread with cheese. The food was inedible.
Ordered 2 medium pizzas both we’re burnt and I ordered a calzone since when do calzones have sesame seeds on them never and they made it like a Stromboli very disappointed
Loading...