Super solid experience. Pizza definitely uses a unique recipe for the dough.Excellent wraps and sandwiches as well. The place may have an outdated feel appearance wise. But the food is where the budget is.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pie
Bruce Teke
The worst pizza I think I ever ate. It's a 1.1 for me. Pizza was super dry, very soft, dough was raw. The.cheese was oily as well. You guys should be ashamed of yourselves charging 20 bucks for a pie.
stephanie michele
ordered a pizza crust was like bread, not well tasting at all. Cheese and sauce was good but crust ruined
Food: 1
Luz Barlikas
First time and definitely not the last!!! We ordered cheese pizza antipasto and OMG SUCK YOUR FINGERS DISO FRIES! Miss Betty is a beautiful person talkative and great Chef.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JaN C
The sandwiches are delicious, the service excellent ? always a great lunch or dinner option, whether to go or eat in I love them
Brandon reese
Amazing food! Betty is a beautiful person and truly felt at home while I waited for the best food around!
Michelle Al
Very nice local , long time restaurant (business)for lunch or dinner ( eat in , take out or delivery )
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathrin Walker
This lady knows her food. Glad she keeps afloat with so many pizza business around. One of the best dough i know around here and the perfect cheese choices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Cavatelli with Broccoli, Ziti Pizza, Garlic Knots, Cheese Tortellini, White Pizza, Pizza Pie
cheri crolle
First time we have tried Gepetto's antipasto and pizza in Wanaque. All I can say is great. The antipasto was fresh with a real homemade Tasting Italian dressing. Just the perfect combination of ingredients. Pizza with an old fashion pizzeria flavor. We will be back!
Martin Peterson
Good food at a decent price. A real home town gem. The owner is sweet and makes you feel like you're a guest in her home.Kid-friendliness: Coloring books available.
Gepetto's is located on Ringwood Avenue in Wanaque NJ. It's most adorable, rustic cozy atmosphere gives off the vibe of family and positivity. I ordered the vegetable pizza and it was huge and perfectly Delicious....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris T
Very, very good pizza. Way better than your average Italian pizzeria. I just came to the neighborhood and this is the best one of the few I tried so far. I ordered an artichoke, roasted red pepper and black olives pizza and it was cooked perfectly. Dough was golden cripsy on the edges (most pizzerias are either undercooked or burnt) and ingredients were on point. Not greasy and oily and not too dry. Buffalo Wings were crispy and delicious. there's attention to detail in the food they make. Will order again.
E Jr Ayala
I don’t know how I haven’t tried Geppettos sooner. My normal spot was closed today so I decided to give them a try. I live literally 6 or 7 houses away from the location. I went online and found a family combo of 2 large pies an order of garlic knots and a 2 liter soda. It was like 35$ and to be honest the pizza was magnificent. The only real reason I haven’t tried them sooner, and I’ll admit I feel kind ve foolish now, is because people always say they aren’t that great. I disagree respectfully. They are REALLY good. The pizza is great the price is great and the garlic knots while not the best I’ve had were still decent. I will certainly be coming to them weekly for the same family combo on pizza night. They won me over on the first try. If it stays consistent then I won’t ever switch from them but I’ll be back after the 3rd buy to let you know if it was consistent or not. Thanks Geppettos.
mikevenom1
Pizza was great! Betty is really nice! Highly recommend Geppetto's!
Super solid experience. Pizza definitely uses a unique recipe for the dough.Excellent wraps and sandwiches as well. The place may have an outdated feel appearance wise. But the food is where the budget is.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pie
The worst pizza I think I ever ate. It's a 1.1 for me. Pizza was super dry, very soft, dough was raw. The.cheese was oily as well. You guys should be ashamed of yourselves charging 20 bucks for a pie.
ordered a pizza crust was like bread, not well tasting at all. Cheese and sauce was good but crust ruined
Food: 1
First time and definitely not the last!!! We ordered cheese pizza antipasto and OMG SUCK YOUR FINGERS DISO FRIES! Miss Betty is a beautiful person talkative and great Chef.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The sandwiches are delicious, the service excellent ? always a great lunch or dinner option, whether to go or eat in I love them
Amazing food! Betty is a beautiful person and truly felt at home while I waited for the best food around!
Very nice local , long time restaurant (business)for lunch or dinner ( eat in , take out or delivery )
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This lady knows her food. Glad she keeps afloat with so many pizza business around. One of the best dough i know around here and the perfect cheese choices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Cavatelli with Broccoli, Ziti Pizza, Garlic Knots, Cheese Tortellini, White Pizza, Pizza Pie
First time we have tried Gepetto's antipasto and pizza in Wanaque. All I can say is great. The antipasto was fresh with a real homemade Tasting Italian dressing. Just the perfect combination of ingredients. Pizza with an old fashion pizzeria flavor. We will be back!
Good food at a decent price. A real home town gem. The owner is sweet and makes you feel like you're a guest in her home.Kid-friendliness: Coloring books available.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Gepetto's is located on Ringwood Avenue in Wanaque NJ. It's most adorable, rustic cozy atmosphere gives off the vibe of family and positivity. I ordered the vegetable pizza and it was huge and perfectly Delicious....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very, very good pizza. Way better than your average Italian pizzeria. I just came to the neighborhood and this is the best one of the few I tried so far. I ordered an artichoke, roasted red pepper and black olives pizza and it was cooked perfectly. Dough was golden cripsy on the edges (most pizzerias are either undercooked or burnt) and ingredients were on point. Not greasy and oily and not too dry. Buffalo Wings were crispy and delicious. there's attention to detail in the food they make. Will order again.
I don’t know how I haven’t tried Geppettos sooner. My normal spot was closed today so I decided to give them a try. I live literally 6 or 7 houses away from the location. I went online and found a family combo of 2 large pies an order of garlic knots and a 2 liter soda. It was like 35$ and to be honest the pizza was magnificent. The only real reason I haven’t tried them sooner, and I’ll admit I feel kind ve foolish now, is because people always say they aren’t that great. I disagree respectfully. They are REALLY good. The pizza is great the price is great and the garlic knots while not the best I’ve had were still decent. I will certainly be coming to them weekly for the same family combo on pizza night. They won me over on the first try. If it stays consistent then I won’t ever switch from them but I’ll be back after the 3rd buy to let you know if it was consistent or not. Thanks Geppettos.
Pizza was great! Betty is really nice! Highly recommend Geppetto's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parmigiana Hero, Homemade Lasagna, Pizza Pie, Cheesesteak Hero
Best pizza around. Been going there for over 30 yrs.