We ordered delivery via Grub Hub. This was our first order from Panatieri's. We thoroughly enjoyed the food, but I am holding off one star since we haven't tried the pizza yet. The food arrived quickly and was packaged very nicely! We ordered antipasto di casa, no olives. It was delicious and fresh! They give you a choice of dressing, but oil & vinegar is traditional to me. The garlic bread with cheese was delicious and garlicky, and I liked how they cut it into pieces rather than a loaf. The bread was soft and not too dry. I got the meatballs, which were quite dense but had a good flavor. You get two, but they are a good size and come with sauce. Panatieri's sauce is delicious, btw. Last but not least, my husband got the lasagna. It has meat in it, but not too much. Cheesy enough and moist. There is a good amount of sauce on it. My husband loved it. Update: we ended up getting a pizza a few days later. We felt the sauce was too sweet but the toppings were generous and tasty. The crust was thin and sturdy. They put an extra blob of sauce in the middle of the pie so your first bite is mostly sauce. Loved the food, pizza was just okay.
Libase' Salon & Spa
Delious Pizzas ? ♥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan, Slice of Pizza
Apryl Rosenthal
The food is wonderful. A wide variety of pizza. Wings. The chicken slides were incredible. They offer you a discount if you pay cash but you have to beg for a receipt.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bill Simonson
The pizza is awesome!!I have been going there forseveral years and have alwaysbeen very happy and very full.Thank you....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
rimla khawaja
This is a great place to grab a quick slice. Their Sicilian pizza is as close to “authentic” as I could find in NJ. Sicilian slices are all about perfecting the crust. They did a great job.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
C Dubz
Great food ,and possibly the best garlic knots I've had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza, Garlic Knots
Jose Fermin
Came here for wings and they were over cooked or left out for to long and sauce thrown on top and reheated .When I go back to return and ask for something different ,the gentlemen cooking pizza says I can’t buy anything else . Simply hungry trying to buy something worth it and couldn’t even serve me as a customer the right way. He claims his wings never been return for 7 years of him working there . “Merry Christmas to you “he yells as I walk out the store without being able to purchase something different because I didn’t like the wings. Thank you for the worst service .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gregory Pastir
I stop down here for lunch every now and then during work and I always get two slices of Chicago pepperoni sausage deep dish. It is the absolute best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danny G (MDw)
Big selection of pizza by the slice! Decent. Even better, you can still (Sept 2023) get a Veal Parm or Eggplant Parm hero Under $10, that makes it great!
Kirsten K.
The pizza here is exceptional! I love the huge variety of slices and how creative the toppings are. Yes I am team pineapple on pizza, and they have that here! My current favorite topping is the salad pizza which has red roasted peppers, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, and basil. The flavor is amazing! I come at lunch and get a couple different slices and eat on the iron tables outside on the sidewalk. The staff has always been polite and efficient. I recommend paying in cash because there's a discount. I have not been to the restaurant part yet but I plan to try it. There's a big free parking lot. This restaurant is located in the corner of a large strip mall right at a main intersection in Warren.
Could be better quality control ... 2 burnt garlic rolls out of 6... not
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jose R. Jimenez III
Not cool, we need nicer people in the restaurant industry. He’s not apart of that.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
Lynn Schick
I love the food. Pizza is great as well as the dinners. I usually do take out and have eaten outside so have no comments on the atmosphere!Parking: Typical strip mall parking. It is plentiful.Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking and wheelchair accessible entrance.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
Mike Heffron
This place is fine, pretty standard fast service counter place. Came with my family and they were friendly and helpful. You can actually get stuff from their dinner menu, but when we were there the dining area was closed, and it looks like it doesn't get used. I would probably come back again for take away, rather than to sit.Kid-friendliness: They were accommodating of my 3 year old.Parking: This is in a shopping center so lots of parking in the lot.
ROBiN UMANA
Highly disappointed in not only the food but your service. My company ordered over $230.00 in food threw SLICE today 4/19/23 for lunch- our food came in and most sauces were missing- cheese steaks over salted, shrimp & chicken Cesar salads were MISSING chicken - raw shrimp the list goes on. I made the MISTAKE of calling the restaurant in WARREN directly to only get attitude from a gentleman named ESTEBAN who told me it WASN'T their fault that I needs to go through SLICE and they would issue me a refund. I would also like to mention that ESTEBAN couldn't BE BOTHERED by how unhappy we were and was annoyed I had even reached out.. if this is who you have assigned to be the manager there god bless this business because this young man couldn't CARE LESS. I went through SLICE who was ANOTHER joke and refunded $7.98 for the "chicken" and asked me to reach back out to the location about the problem, however I won't be calling Estaban about this since he obviously couldn't be bothered in the 1st place.
We ordered delivery via Grub Hub. This was our first order from Panatieri's. We thoroughly enjoyed the food, but I am holding off one star since we haven't tried the pizza yet. The food arrived quickly and was packaged very nicely! We ordered antipasto di casa, no olives. It was delicious and fresh! They give you a choice of dressing, but oil & vinegar is traditional to me. The garlic bread with cheese was delicious and garlicky, and I liked how they cut it into pieces rather than a loaf. The bread was soft and not too dry. I got the meatballs, which were quite dense but had a good flavor. You get two, but they are a good size and come with sauce. Panatieri's sauce is delicious, btw. Last but not least, my husband got the lasagna. It has meat in it, but not too much. Cheesy enough and moist. There is a good amount of sauce on it. My husband loved it. Update: we ended up getting a pizza a few days later. We felt the sauce was too sweet but the toppings were generous and tasty. The crust was thin and sturdy. They put an extra blob of sauce in the middle of the pie so your first bite is mostly sauce. Loved the food, pizza was just okay.
Delious Pizzas ? ♥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan, Slice of Pizza
The food is wonderful. A wide variety of pizza. Wings. The chicken slides were incredible. They offer you a discount if you pay cash but you have to beg for a receipt.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The pizza is awesome!!I have been going there forseveral years and have alwaysbeen very happy and very full.Thank you....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a great place to grab a quick slice. Their Sicilian pizza is as close to “authentic” as I could find in NJ. Sicilian slices are all about perfecting the crust. They did a great job.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great food ,and possibly the best garlic knots I've had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza, Garlic Knots
Came here for wings and they were over cooked or left out for to long and sauce thrown on top and reheated .When I go back to return and ask for something different ,the gentlemen cooking pizza says I can’t buy anything else . Simply hungry trying to buy something worth it and couldn’t even serve me as a customer the right way. He claims his wings never been return for 7 years of him working there . “Merry Christmas to you “he yells as I walk out the store without being able to purchase something different because I didn’t like the wings. Thank you for the worst service .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I stop down here for lunch every now and then during work and I always get two slices of Chicago pepperoni sausage deep dish. It is the absolute best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Big selection of pizza by the slice! Decent. Even better, you can still (Sept 2023) get a Veal Parm or Eggplant Parm hero Under $10, that makes it great!
The pizza here is exceptional! I love the huge variety of slices and how creative the toppings are. Yes I am team pineapple on pizza, and they have that here! My current favorite topping is the salad pizza which has red roasted peppers, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, and basil. The flavor is amazing! I come at lunch and get a couple different slices and eat on the iron tables outside on the sidewalk. The staff has always been polite and efficient. I recommend paying in cash because there's a discount. I have not been to the restaurant part yet but I plan to try it. There's a big free parking lot. This restaurant is located in the corner of a large strip mall right at a main intersection in Warren.
Restaurantji Recommends
Could be better quality control ... 2 burnt garlic rolls out of 6... not
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Not cool, we need nicer people in the restaurant industry. He’s not apart of that.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
I love the food. Pizza is great as well as the dinners. I usually do take out and have eaten outside so have no comments on the atmosphere!Parking: Typical strip mall parking. It is plentiful.Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking and wheelchair accessible entrance.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
This place is fine, pretty standard fast service counter place. Came with my family and they were friendly and helpful. You can actually get stuff from their dinner menu, but when we were there the dining area was closed, and it looks like it doesn't get used. I would probably come back again for take away, rather than to sit.Kid-friendliness: They were accommodating of my 3 year old.Parking: This is in a shopping center so lots of parking in the lot.
Highly disappointed in not only the food but your service. My company ordered over $230.00 in food threw SLICE today 4/19/23 for lunch- our food came in and most sauces were missing- cheese steaks over salted, shrimp & chicken Cesar salads were MISSING chicken - raw shrimp the list goes on. I made the MISTAKE of calling the restaurant in WARREN directly to only get attitude from a gentleman named ESTEBAN who told me it WASN'T their fault that I needs to go through SLICE and they would issue me a refund. I would also like to mention that ESTEBAN couldn't BE BOTHERED by how unhappy we were and was annoyed I had even reached out.. if this is who you have assigned to be the manager there god bless this business because this young man couldn't CARE LESS. I went through SLICE who was ANOTHER joke and refunded $7.98 for the "chicken" and asked me to reach back out to the location about the problem, however I won't be calling Estaban about this since he obviously couldn't be bothered in the 1st place.