Saly G's Restaurant & Tavern
169 Washington Valley Rd, Warren
(732) 667-7400
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
I was really looking forward to celebrating my birthday at Sally G's as I heard such good things about it. The evening started off well with good cocktails, bread, and appetizers. Unfortunately our entrees were tasteless. I thought my Zappa di pesce was in Campbells cream of tomato soup! Very disappointing!!
Very good service. Food was great but a bit pricy. Drinks were good but pricey. Understandably loud on a Friday night at 6:30 but not ideal for a conversational dinner if that's what you are looking for
This is our 2nd time dining at Saly G's. And it did not disappoint. We were celebrating our daughter and son-in-law's birthdays. Appetizers were excellent - Meatballs and tried the special for Honey Figs (burrata was so fresh) and Risotto balls. Main dishes - Angry Parmigiana ( I tried this at our 1st visit - and was impressed how it was presented (on a raised grill type plate) but this time around only served on a regular plate. But the chicken was delicious. The balance of meals was a steak, pork chop (special) and a pasta dish with a pear sauce and breadcrumbs - very extraordinary. The service is always top notch. All of our drinks were delicious. Our order was from wine to different hard drinks. A "must try" place to dine.
Saly Gs is always a win! Great food, great wine and great service. The steaks were amazing!
our first time. excellent entrees. halibut and lobster frau diavalo were well prepared, right sized and tasty. any restaurant with table clothes is worth a try. olives and eggplant pieces for the table was a nice touch. we were unrushed despite the restaurant being busy. a little to noisy for our liking. a music combo was coming on as we were leaving . we weren't aware of this.. would have made later reservations had we known about this. espresso was so so. apple galette was short on apples and tough on pastry crust. . pricey as many restaurants are now. added credit card service charge us a disappointment since accountants have already built that into the prices
Went here for my birthday. A little expensive but it was very good. We really loved the risotto balls. The calamari was fresh. Everyone enjoyed their meals. They also offer options for kids.
Amazing food and service. The angry chicken parm is absolutely delicious. The warm donuts were the best !!! Love it there. Great vibes !!!
While the food was excellent, the service was only mediocre. There were long waits between seeing our waiter to take our order or to get water glasses refilled. We will not return on a busy weekend night.
Service was great and the portions generous. We had the spicy rigatoni which was awesome and the chicken Milanese. Unfortunately, the chicken was dry and tough. A bit disappointing.
The bread with an eggplant spread at the beginning of meal was excellent. Ordered the fried calamari, which was supposed to be tossed with a pepper oil, however, it was just plain, basic fried calamari, crispy, but nothing special. My wife ordered the salad which was perfectly fine and very large. The entrees were both very disappointing. My wife ordered gnocchi, a third of the gnocchi was burned charcoal black where it obviously had been left in a pan too long and was visibly burned. I was surprised they had even sent the obviously burned dish to the table. I ordered the bucatini, it just had no flavor, again, nothing special. The restaurant had been recommended to Us by friends who told us the food was excellent. Maybe there's been a change of Chefs or maybe the chef was on vacation? I don't know, but I don't think we'll return.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food and the ambience was good. The service was excellent. One downside was the bathroom had no soap in it. I mentioned it to the reception desk. When i went back into the bathroom 2 hours later there was still no soap. I question the cleanliness.
Have heard for years what a great place Sally G's is and finally tried this past Friday with a reservation for 4 people. The decor and ambience was great, the food good but was highly dissappointed with the service. Perhaps they were short staffed but we had to flag down our waiter for every single thing, even to order our meal. Was hoping for a better experience.
Very consistent. Good fresh ingredients. Good size portions. Nice menu, something for everyone. Would recommend and return.
This has become one of our most favorite spots. Everything is delicious, but I recommend the Angry Chicken Parm! Owner and staff are always great, and they provide a very relaxing atmosphere.
Lovely evening. Fresh, well prepared food. Well crafted drinks. Would recommend and return.
Loading...