Cake Fiction
11 E Mill Rd, Long Valley
(862) 205-9035
Customers' Favorites
Wedding Cake
Custom Cake
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We used Cake Fiction for our wedding cake this past weekend. Paula and her husband are the sweetest people and so talented. When we did our cake tasting, all the flavors were so good and we were struggling to decide. Luckily, we were able to have different flavors for the different tiers so we could enjoy more than one. I would definitely recommend using them, and it’s all made from scratch. 💜
Paula is a wonderful artist & business owner. She was communicative and very prompt with quotes and timeliness. Her prices are fair and her quality of work is unmatched. The cake came out fantastic
Loved working with Paula! She and her husband are the best. Cake making is a passion project for them and it’s evident in the quality, execution and care they take in creating your wedding cake. The cake tasting at their beautiful farm home in NJ was my favorite wedding planning activity. They were so warm and welcoming and excited to have us. The cakes are all 10/10 delicious. I wish they made cakes for all occasions.
You May Also Like
Chesapeake Tavern - 1 W Mill Rd
![]()
Seafood, Bar, Seafood Markets, American
Long Valley Bagel - 6 W Mill Rd
![]()
Bagels, Pet Friendly
Long Valley Pub & Brewery at Restaurant Village - 1 Fairmount Rd
![]()
Brewpubs, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian