Cornerstone Pizzeria

71 E Mill Rd, Long Valley
(908) 876-1283

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Miranda Morales

I wanted to like this place so badly because the woman here is so sweet. But I'm not only upset but appalled by how terrible the service was, the food, and the price. The soda was gross. We ordered two entrees and after another (yelp) review my sister and I thought it came with the meal only for her to charge us $13.50 for this salad. (That we never asked for by the way) I also ordered garlic knots expecting six but she brought out 12. No problem she didn't ask and maybe I didn't clarify. The penne vodka was absolutely not all it was cracked up to be. And to make matters worse our drinks were empty long before we finished eating and the lady spent about 10 mins talking to a couple at the bar not checking in on us once. We asked the counter guy for to go boxes and to clear our check. He gave us the boxes and said the lady would close the check... we only waited about 5 more minutes for their convo to wrap up. I'm beyond mad and upset that this whole experience ran me $80.

The worst part was knowing it’s a small business and looked run down. I was going to tip $20 no matter what. But i really feel like i was conned and upcharged this whole meal.

Ken M

This used to be one of our favorite local restaurants. But our experience this past weekend was not good. We ordered our favorite dishes and it was not as good and the portions were much smaller. Then when we got our bill, the prices were more expensive than the menu. When we pointed this out, we were told - sorry but everything is more expensive than it used to be . Also there was something on our bill that we did not order. The menu was a simple paper printed sheet and easily could have been updated. When we ordered they could have told us what the prices were really going to be. This was unacceptable and a bad experience.

J G

Good local spot for pizza and a beer too

Rafael Alix

Maryanne and Antoinette were amazing hospitality was great and the food was amazing

linnea

Not bad, just not up to par with the other pizza places in the area. The garlic knots are very greasy and not fluffy enough

Yoon Lee

Fantastic couple who owns and operates the restaurant. Love the base red sauce flavor, warning though that it’s on the sweeter side.

Great pizza. Wife loves the penne vodka.

They also make Italian desserts for the holidays for takeout sale.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan, Regular Slice

Teresa M

Wow! The owners are so lovely! We came with a large party including 7 children. The owners were so accommodating and kind, and went above and beyond to make sure that our visit was wonderful, even getting out extra toys for them to play with after our meal. The kids took full advantage of the backyard toys that we were invited to use. The pizza was delicious and everything was so nice. Although we opted for the patio, the indoor dining room is also beautiful. Will definitely return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maldini Chavez

Good pizza and friendly service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gereon W

Friendly owners, great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken

Gereon Wiese

Friendly owners, great pizza

Mike Briggs

Great dinners, great sandwiches, great service. They also have a liquor license.

jenny june

Lots of pizza places to choose from in Long Valley, but this is our go-to. Love their pizza! And staff so friendly. For the 3rd year in a row, they let the middle school play have their cast party there. The kids run around on the grass and pizza and drink soda. Pizza has long been consumed, but they let us stay and celebrate and eat cake long after they have closed. Very supportive of kids and the community. I'm happy to recommend them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jimmy P

Dog food ,ate better Italian food in

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jim Mahoney

This is a nice small restaurant with a small bar. Very family friendly atmosphere. Prices are pretty good. Besides pizza the have a host of other meals, plenty to choose from.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dom Bastello

Ordered "The Special" pizza... Fantastic!!! Did not skimp on any of the toppings. I'm a new regular customer now.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...