The Coffee Potter
24 Schooleys Mountain Rd, Long Valley
(201) 230-9890
Customers' Favorites
Sausage Egg and Cheese Breakfast Burrito
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Hot Chocolate Freeze
Milk Atlernatives
Blueberry Scone
Italian Soda
Coffee Cake
Crumb Cake
Coffee Shop
Croissant
Menu
Photos
+37 photos
+36 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Stopped here during my cycling trip. It was in the morning, the place was packed, mostly drive through customers. Went in thinking that I have to wait awhile. But the gentlemen took my order and it was ready in no time. Egg & cheese on a roll, coffee cake and coffee. Inside was packed so I took it outside and sat on the provided chair. Again great service and great food.
We've been to this coffee shop multiple times, and it never disappoints. My latte is consistently well made. The service is always friendly, and the atmosphere is inviting, with plenty of seating space available.
Amazing coffee, great atmosphere, and friendly people! Everything I've tried had been great! They also carry gluten-free snacks like brownies.
Update however many years later and with the new owners - JUST AS GOOD!!! Still a must-go when in Long Valley!
Update however many years later and with the new owners - JUST AS GOOD!!! Still a must-go when in Long Valley!
You May Also Like
Long Valley Bagel - 6 W Mill Rd
![]()
Bagels, Pet Friendly
La Rienda Cafe - 5 W Mill Rd
![]()
Mexican, Latin American, Spanish, Pet Friendly
Chesapeake Tavern - 1 W Mill Rd
![]()
Seafood, Bar, Seafood Markets, American