The Coffee Potter
24 Schooleys Mountain Rd, Long Valley
(201) 230-9890
Customers' Favorites
Sausage Egg and Cheese Breakfast Burrito
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Hot Chocolate Freeze
Milk Atlernatives
Blueberry Scone
Italian Soda
Coffee Cake
Coffee Shop
Crumb Cake
Croissant
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Having to detour through Long Valley due to the sinkhole issue on Rte 80 became a blessing in disguise; I found The Coffee Potter! Well brewed coffee, perfect muffins fairly priced and best of all served with genuine pride, care and smiles. Thankyou for making my commute an adventure to anticipate. Even when the roadwork is completed, I'll be making a few detours to The Coffee Potter.
I used to live in Hackettstown, and loved coming here for coffee cake, now I come all the time as I have clients nearby for my iced matcha. They are super friendly, and my drink is always amazing. I love supporting small businesses, and the prices are surprisingly more reasonable than Starbucks, etc for a much better experience!
Love this coffee shop after a run on Columbia trail. Always super busy but they move quickly and efficiently. I never feel like I'm waiting long.
Parking: Parking is limited and tight especially with drive thru lane. I recommend doing drive thru or parking at Columbia trail.
Parking: Parking is limited and tight especially with drive thru lane. I recommend doing drive thru or parking at Columbia trail.
You May Also Like
La Rienda Cafe - 5 W Mill Rd
![]()
Mexican, Latin American, Spanish, Pet Friendly
Chesapeake Tavern - 1 W Mill Rd
![]()
Seafood, Bar, Seafood Markets, American