Delicious and fast ! Perfect for footballSundays !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Annie Dollarton
The best pizza in NYC. Hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Mike Woodrow
Had Pie Guys for the first time today and I can hands down say it is the best pizza place in Wayne. I’ve been working in Wayne for a year now and have tried all the other joints around my office and they’ve all let me down. Pie Guys didn’t. My only regret is not trying here sooner. The pizza was cooked to perfection and was thin and crispy. The sauce was incredible- not too sweet, not too salty. They couldn’t have done it better. I’m done trying new places - Pie Guys has earned my loyalty after just this one visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Michelle Helena
I ordered ziti with Alfredo sauce and there was like 40 noodles in the container with barely no sauce. I literally saw the bottom of the container when I opened it. For the price you are charging and the cost of pasta you can definitely fill the container. I always used to order but no more. Not worth it. Very disappointed
Nick K
Pizza was good but the chicken parm and ziti was awful. The pasta was bland and the chicken tasted burnt. They should take it off the menu.
N K
Pizza was good but the chicken parm and ziti was awful. The pasta was bland and the chicken tasted burnt. They should take it off the menu.
Stephanie
Somewhere I will NEVER order from again.. I placed an order at 9:20 pm. & the pizzeria closes at 10pm. I placed the order at 9:22 and by 9:30 the order was out for delivery. The driver was extremely rude talking about “ the pizza mad had a lot of not nice words to say about your order “ and they sent a pizza that had been sitting for hours. It was horrible. I give this place 0/10. ??
D S.
The Best pizza baked to perfection! Now this is a pizza! The cheese stays on the dough and the sauce isn't salty. I've tried many pizzerias and I must say Pie Guys is the best! You know a great pizza when the cheese stays on the pie and doesn't fall off!
Levi Friend
I'm in town on a work trip. Ordered delivery after asking a local for a suggestion and excitedly receiving Pie Guys as the answer. For the review I'll just send what I responded with to my wife when she asked how my pizza was."It was terrible! Ha. It was paper thin, I think they used a single tbsn to measure the the sauce for the whole pizza, the pepperoni was cheap. It reminded me of what I remember Chucky Cheese pizza was like as a child. Also, my mild wings were super dry. The chicken was perfect but it barely had any sauce on it. If that place is what passes as good enough to brag about I feel so bad for these folks."Giving two stars because delivery was quick and the wings were cooked to perfection, just barely had sauce.
Stephanie Demetriou
Somewhere I will NEVER order from again.. I placed an order at 9:20 pm. & the pizzeria closes at 10pm. I placed the order at 9:22 and by 9:30 the order was out for delivery. The driver was extremely rude talking about “ the pizza mad had a lot of not nice words to say about your order “ and they sent a pizza that had been sitting for hours. It was horrible. I give this place 0/10. ??
Won't go anywhere else. Best dinners, pizza, , sandwiches and salads. Quick delivery, such a great staff to speak with when ordering.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
John Park
Pie Guys has the best pizza in North Jersey, hands down!! Their grandma pie, Buffalo chicken, fifth grader, chicken cheesesteak pizza are all fantastic! Kevin always treats all of his customers with respect and kindness, all while making the pizzas himself! I’ve personally seen him make my pies and would not want anyone to make them for me now. I’ve dined in, ordered takeout, and delivery, and all options were timely and I was always pleasantly surprised! Give Pie Guys a try if you want to eat the best pizza in New Jersey!!
Christina Ji
If you’re looking for the best pizza in NJ, Pie Guys is phenomenal for both dining in and delivery (always fast!!). Kevin offers great customer service (he just seems like a very genuine guy who loves what he does) — he always provide great recommendations and can answer any questions about the items on their menu! The pizzas, wings, garlic knots, and sandwiches here are can’t be beat, truly the top rated pizzeria in Wayne, NJ imo!
Christina J.
If you're looking for the best pizza in NJ, Pie Guys is phenomenal for both dining in and delivery (always fast!!). Kevin offers great customer service (he just seems like a very genuine guy who loves what he does) -- he always provide great recommendations and can answer any questions about the items on their menu! The pizzas, wings, garlic knots, and sandwiches here are can't be beat, truly the top rated pizzeria in Wayne, NJ imo!
John P.
Pie Guys has the best pizza in North Jersey, hands down!! Their grandma pie, Buffalo chicken, fifth grader, chicken cheesesteak pizza are all fantastic! Kevin always treats all of his customers with respect and kindness, all while making the pizzas himself! I've personally seen him make my pies and would not want anyone to make them for me now. I've dined in, ordered takeout, and delivery, and all options were timely and I was always pleasantly surprised! Give Pie Guys a try if you want to eat the best pizza in New Jersey!!
Delicious and fast ! Perfect for footballSundays !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza in NYC. Hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Had Pie Guys for the first time today and I can hands down say it is the best pizza place in Wayne. I’ve been working in Wayne for a year now and have tried all the other joints around my office and they’ve all let me down. Pie Guys didn’t. My only regret is not trying here sooner. The pizza was cooked to perfection and was thin and crispy. The sauce was incredible- not too sweet, not too salty. They couldn’t have done it better. I’m done trying new places - Pie Guys has earned my loyalty after just this one visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I ordered ziti with Alfredo sauce and there was like 40 noodles in the container with barely no sauce. I literally saw the bottom of the container when I opened it. For the price you are charging and the cost of pasta you can definitely fill the container. I always used to order but no more. Not worth it. Very disappointed
Pizza was good but the chicken parm and ziti was awful. The pasta was bland and the chicken tasted burnt. They should take it off the menu.
Pizza was good but the chicken parm and ziti was awful. The pasta was bland and the chicken tasted burnt. They should take it off the menu.
Somewhere I will NEVER order from again.. I placed an order at 9:20 pm. & the pizzeria closes at 10pm. I placed the order at 9:22 and by 9:30 the order was out for delivery. The driver was extremely rude talking about “ the pizza mad had a lot of not nice words to say about your order “ and they sent a pizza that had been sitting for hours. It was horrible. I give this place 0/10. ??
The Best pizza baked to perfection! Now this is a pizza! The cheese stays on the dough and the sauce isn't salty. I've tried many pizzerias and I must say Pie Guys is the best! You know a great pizza when the cheese stays on the pie and doesn't fall off!
I'm in town on a work trip. Ordered delivery after asking a local for a suggestion and excitedly receiving Pie Guys as the answer. For the review I'll just send what I responded with to my wife when she asked how my pizza was."It was terrible! Ha. It was paper thin, I think they used a single tbsn to measure the the sauce for the whole pizza, the pepperoni was cheap. It reminded me of what I remember Chucky Cheese pizza was like as a child. Also, my mild wings were super dry. The chicken was perfect but it barely had any sauce on it. If that place is what passes as good enough to brag about I feel so bad for these folks."Giving two stars because delivery was quick and the wings were cooked to perfection, just barely had sauce.
Somewhere I will NEVER order from again.. I placed an order at 9:20 pm. & the pizzeria closes at 10pm. I placed the order at 9:22 and by 9:30 the order was out for delivery. The driver was extremely rude talking about “ the pizza mad had a lot of not nice words to say about your order “ and they sent a pizza that had been sitting for hours. It was horrible. I give this place 0/10. ??
Restaurantji Recommends
Won't go anywhere else. Best dinners, pizza, , sandwiches and salads. Quick delivery, such a great staff to speak with when ordering.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Pie Guys has the best pizza in North Jersey, hands down!! Their grandma pie, Buffalo chicken, fifth grader, chicken cheesesteak pizza are all fantastic! Kevin always treats all of his customers with respect and kindness, all while making the pizzas himself! I’ve personally seen him make my pies and would not want anyone to make them for me now. I’ve dined in, ordered takeout, and delivery, and all options were timely and I was always pleasantly surprised! Give Pie Guys a try if you want to eat the best pizza in New Jersey!!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in NJ, Pie Guys is phenomenal for both dining in and delivery (always fast!!). Kevin offers great customer service (he just seems like a very genuine guy who loves what he does) — he always provide great recommendations and can answer any questions about the items on their menu! The pizzas, wings, garlic knots, and sandwiches here are can’t be beat, truly the top rated pizzeria in Wayne, NJ imo!
If you're looking for the best pizza in NJ, Pie Guys is phenomenal for both dining in and delivery (always fast!!). Kevin offers great customer service (he just seems like a very genuine guy who loves what he does) -- he always provide great recommendations and can answer any questions about the items on their menu! The pizzas, wings, garlic knots, and sandwiches here are can't be beat, truly the top rated pizzeria in Wayne, NJ imo!
Pie Guys has the best pizza in North Jersey, hands down!! Their grandma pie, Buffalo chicken, fifth grader, chicken cheesesteak pizza are all fantastic! Kevin always treats all of his customers with respect and kindness, all while making the pizzas himself! I've personally seen him make my pies and would not want anyone to make them for me now. I've dined in, ordered takeout, and delivery, and all options were timely and I was always pleasantly surprised! Give Pie Guys a try if you want to eat the best pizza in New Jersey!!