Original Bagel Company

2 Fairfield Crescent, West Caldwell
(973) 227-5777

Recent Reviews

Sergio Jimenez

Good place but only one door to pick up and deliver

Catherine Navin Kelly

Found Original Bagels at Miller's in Manchester, MD and I agree that they are the best bagged bagels. They also test much better than the "bakery" bagels available at the local chain supermarkets.

Shooter McGavern

Sorry, can't give you 5 stars until you get the bagels cut in the middle, rather annoying, but the bagels are good.

Bob H

Fantastic place

Mark Dykstra

Work with BILL A. often, professional 100%.

Jonathan Sandi

Truck driver here, very nice and hardworking Latino guys in the shipping and recieving department. I basically arrived a day earlier, and they unloaded me past midnight. Very humble and hardworking guys. Unloading was pretty fast. Their yard is a little tight, but you will have no problem backing, very simple. Enter thru the main entrance. After that you'll You'll see a driveway next to some giant solar panels (to me it is a dryway lol), try to swing wide, drive straight ahead and then you'll just straight back onto the loading dock (be careful not to hit other trailers). Once you're done you'll just exit thru that same dryway. Very good and pleasant delivery. And they gave me bagels to take with me, OMG THEY ARE SO GOOD, SERIOUSLY. WILL DEFINITELY RECOMMEND THIS BRAND. Thank you so much!

Bill Grant

Smells delicious when picking up 1,000’s of bagels

Brad Stevens

Any chance to make the blueberry bagels taste like blueberry? It's literally a plain bagel.

Ross Fenwick

Living in Dubai where bagels resemble proper bagels in shape only. I had given up the hope of finding some until I stumbled across these in the freezer at Spinneys. Life is good again.

Jay Paster

Best bagels I have found. Just heat for a couple of minutes and they taste just baked

ron davis

These bagels I found in a stewarts in upstate ny. I'll tell you they're the best bag bagels I've had. Even after multiple freeze and unfreeze. Light crisp outside soft center truly a good ny style bagel I wish there was more locations up here to buy them. Corporate should contact price chopper Corp up here, they're the local leading super market chain. They'd be a huge business contract for sure.Great job and great bagels

Ronny Davis

best ny bagels hands down. found these in stewats in freezer they must use them for their sandwiches but they're the real deal and I'm assuming used commercially so kind of hidden from the shelves atleast on capital district upstate they are. but great bagel even after multiple freezes

Danica Thornton

Was loading there weekly until the Covid plandemic! Loved going there, the staff- starting with I believe his name is Bill to the guys loading us and I wish I could remember their names, they are all awesome guys! During a snow storm we arrived slightly behind schedule, there was one truck ahead of us that got stuck in the yard trying to get out. The guys all came out and did whatever they could do to help the driver get back onto the road. Nearly every trip in they gave us bagels to bring back to Maine with us. The BEST bagels ever!! We got extremely spoiled not only by the best bagels ever but also by the polite and friendly attitudes of all of the workers. I wish all of our stops employed folks like the folks here! Smiles aren’t always found when a girl arrives at the shipping desk or when backing into a loading dock. Thank you Original Bagel not only for the awesome bagels but also for the best customer service ever!! The one place I am anxious to pick up from again!! You guys are awesome!!

Momo Alyafi

Great people easy load & great bengals

Alfonzo Taylor

Fresh everything bagel, so good. Receiving department very professional loaded me quickly.

Load More