We've dined here many times and it's always a great experience. Food is all excellent and the service is friendly.
wendy maurer
Service was non existent at a table the past 2 times-waited 40 minutes recently for nothing, waitress was no one to be found. I would only sit at the bar. Service is good there
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Tommy
We went to watch the Yankees clinch the ALCS, they did. Lots of TV's. Great pizza, enjoyed wings and sliders too. Margaritas and Stellas on tap were flowing. Live music was an added plus+. Will definitely go back.
Andrea Cedron
this place is amazing. I had my bridal shower and my rehearsal dinner here. you guys are the best. the place is perfect, nice and clean ?. you made it so easy for me. The food is amazing. Thank you guys again, love ❤️ ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Recchia
Good spot. 60% of the food is good, but they specialize in pizza & beer. If that's your thing, your in good hands. Start with the Classic "Mom's" pie or save some carbs with the super delicious "thinythin", probably only rivaled buy the original Star Tavern pizza. The staff is 100% good! Enjoy.
Recommended dishes: Pie
john
Had a great first time experience here. Wait staff was perfect, orders came out properly. No rushing and just an overall good time. Food was prepared as described and had great flavor. Overall, a do over for us.
Elegante Bellezza
This was my first time trythis restaurant and we loved . Everything was on point. The food was super good we ordered salmon with mando salad with avocado. And I ordered fig salad with grill chicken was so good. I recommend this place .plus the allagash beer. Thank u guys for your service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren S
?The Brook Tap House in West Caldwell, NJ. I love the famous "Thinny Thin" Pizza @thebrooktaphouse! It's always made to order and served piping hot. The "Thinny Thin" Pizza is one of my favorite bar pies in NJ. I was pleasantly surprised how good the other food was! @thebrooktaphouse prides themselves as a farm-to-table brew house using organic, locally farmed meat, fruit & vegetables! Who knew right? The avocado Caprese salad was soo good especially paired with the pizza. Come try their beer on tap of course featuring certified New Jersey brewers! • FAMOUS "THINNY THIN"-Paper thin, well done, no crust with a crown of crispy cheese to the end. AVOCADO CAPRESE SALAD-Mozzarella Balls, Tomatoed, Red Onion, Basil & Lemon Vinaigrette BRAISED SHORT RIB SANDWICH- Tender short rib with Fried Onions and Melted Cheese served with Au jus. BACON BLUE BURGER-Applewood Smoked Bacon, Blue Cheese with Lettuce &Tomatoes Insta: thehungrysw
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drewster R
More busy at the restaurant than the bar.
Parking: Lots of parking out back
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza
Angie Bussi
Greg & his staff made my office happy hour such an amazing experience. Everyone was so tentative, the food was great, the space was perfect, they even accommodated me with a vegan pizza. It was an overall 10/10 time. Thank you Brook Tap House!
I was pleasantly surprised abt this place. Yes, it is a bar but it was a very chill place. The menu offers a lot of options ( not just bar food) and the food was good. I would definitely go back. They did have entertainment there ( someone was singing) but it made for a good night.
StevenB
The food was great; service was great. I even got to watch the Stanley Cup playoffs. But once they turned on the music, our conversation had to end. We like to go there every couple of months. We will be back.
Anthony Pizzi
Loved my experience The Pickle pizza was so good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aimee Walker
Everything was great. Staff was helpful and friendly.
Mother's Day dinner party of 7 arrived table was ready on time, drinks were perfect , appetizers great candied bacon highly recommend, entrees cooked as ordered very tasty great choices on menu. Highly recommend. Thanks
We've dined here many times and it's always a great experience. Food is all excellent and the service is friendly.
Service was non existent at a table the past 2 times-waited 40 minutes recently for nothing, waitress was no one to be found. I would only sit at the bar. Service is good there
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
We went to watch the Yankees clinch the ALCS, they did. Lots of TV's. Great pizza, enjoyed wings and sliders too. Margaritas and Stellas on tap were flowing. Live music was an added plus+. Will definitely go back.
this place is amazing. I had my bridal shower and my rehearsal dinner here. you guys are the best. the place is perfect, nice and clean ?. you made it so easy for me. The food is amazing. Thank you guys again, love ❤️ ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good spot. 60% of the food is good, but they specialize in pizza & beer. If that's your thing, your in good hands. Start with the Classic "Mom's" pie or save some carbs with the super delicious "thinythin", probably only rivaled buy the original Star Tavern pizza.
The staff is 100% good!
Enjoy.
Recommended dishes: Pie
Had a great first time experience here. Wait staff was perfect, orders came out properly. No rushing and just an overall good time. Food was prepared as described and had great flavor. Overall, a do over for us.
This was my first time trythis restaurant and we loved . Everything was on point. The food was super good we ordered salmon with mando salad with avocado. And I ordered fig salad with grill chicken was so good. I recommend this place .plus the allagash beer. Thank u guys for your service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
?The Brook Tap House in West Caldwell, NJ. I love the famous "Thinny Thin" Pizza @thebrooktaphouse! It's always made to order and served piping hot. The "Thinny Thin" Pizza is one of my favorite bar pies in NJ. I was pleasantly surprised how good the other food was! @thebrooktaphouse prides themselves as a farm-to-table brew house using organic, locally farmed meat, fruit & vegetables! Who knew right? The avocado Caprese salad was soo good especially paired with the pizza. Come try their beer on tap of course featuring certified New Jersey brewers! •
FAMOUS "THINNY THIN"-Paper thin, well done, no crust with a crown of crispy cheese to the end.
AVOCADO CAPRESE SALAD-Mozzarella Balls, Tomatoed, Red Onion, Basil & Lemon Vinaigrette
BRAISED SHORT RIB SANDWICH- Tender short rib with Fried Onions and Melted Cheese served with Au jus.
BACON BLUE BURGER-Applewood Smoked Bacon, Blue Cheese with Lettuce &Tomatoes
Insta: thehungrysw
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
More busy at the restaurant than the bar.
Parking: Lots of parking out back
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza
Greg & his staff made my office happy hour such an amazing experience. Everyone was so tentative, the food was great, the space was perfect, they even accommodated me with a vegan pizza. It was an overall 10/10 time. Thank you Brook Tap House!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I was pleasantly surprised abt this place. Yes, it is a bar but it was a very chill place. The menu offers a lot of options ( not just bar food) and the food was good. I would definitely go back. They did have entertainment there ( someone was singing) but it made for a good night.
The food was great; service was great. I even got to watch the Stanley Cup playoffs. But once they turned on the music, our conversation had to end. We like to go there every couple of months. We will be back.
Loved my experience The Pickle pizza was so good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was great. Staff was helpful and friendly.
Mother's Day dinner party of 7 arrived table was ready on time, drinks were perfect , appetizers great candied bacon highly recommend, entrees cooked as ordered very tasty great choices on menu. Highly recommend. Thanks
Loading...