Went here around 2:30pm on a Monday. Has parking available. Ordered a cheese personal pie. It was ready quickly and super delicious! Good place for a quick bite!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Pie
anna stern
I do not usually take time to write negative reviews but I thought the food was awful. No flavor and crust is as thin as thick paper. I’m not going back
Solomon M
I hate to do this to a kosher pizza store, I walked into this pizzeria, as I walked in, they got a phone call and the person there started taking the phone call before my order when I walked in before the call. Finally he was ready to take my order, I ordered one slice and I simply requested for the man to put on gloves or not to touch the slice I am about to eat with his bare hands that he was just on the phone with. He looked at me and told me if I am going to give him attitude we are closed. Walked out never again.
Service: 1
Rivky Greenspan
Best pizza in the world! This is according to my daughter who generally does not like pizza and asked for a second slice...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mamish Gishmak
Cool spot.In the winter, they're open only on select days (I know Thursday, not sure about other days). During the summer they're open all days.When I walked in, the pizza in the display did not appear too fresh, but I also did come in the late afternoon on a quiet day.I got a regular slice, jalapeño slice, and garlic knots. The service was extremely fast, and i did not wait long at all. The crust on the pizzas was super thin and extremely soft, almost felt like fresh bread. The taste was amazing as well. The jalapeños definitely gave a nice zing but not too strong, just the way I like it. The garlic knots were super soft as well and not lacking flavor.Although the service and food was amazing, I can't deny it's very pricey.It's not a huge store, but there's a decent amount of seating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
leah I
Pizza was good, albeit expensive, although that’s to be expected from a small town pizzeria. Could have been a friendlier experience.
Linda M.
Happy to see a new place took over by Shop rite in West Long Branch. Even happier to try the pizza, and it is amazing! I am very picky about my pizza! Family owned and very friendly! Will be back to try the other things on the Menu!
Leah Lowenstein
Went here today with my kids for the first time. This pizza was phenomenal. Great crust, the sauce was perfect. Not like the typical bottled sauce. Super delicious pizza will definitely be back again!! Ty!
Why is someone bashing the owner? All because he didn’t make eye contact with you? How self absorbed do you need to be to give a nasty review like that?Maybe the owner is just a little awkward. Maybe he was thinking. Occupied. But no- he MUST have been directly trying to offend you.
JustTheFactsNNJ
Whatever shop was there is now gone and Crust Co. Pizza has taken its place. Fresh, thin, delicious kosher pizza.
Bracha Buzali
Great Pizza, great friendly service. would definitely go again.
Veronica R
Not sure why someone bashed this business because they felt that the owner didn’t make any eye contact with them over their faith/what they believe in. My fiancé and I aren’t of any religion and went there for pizza and the owner treated us amazingly - even offered us to sit down and brought all our food out to us. The pizza was perfect and the fries were fresh and crispy. 10/10 will be going back to Crust Co.!
Its god
Very good
Went here around 2:30pm on a Monday. Has parking available. Ordered a cheese personal pie. It was ready quickly and super delicious! Good place for a quick bite!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Pie
I do not usually take time to write negative reviews but I thought the food was awful. No flavor and crust is as thin as thick paper. I’m not going back
I hate to do this to a kosher pizza store, I walked into this pizzeria, as I walked in, they got a phone call and the person there started taking the phone call before my order when I walked in before the call. Finally he was ready to take my order, I ordered one slice and I simply requested for the man to put on gloves or not to touch the slice I am about to eat with his bare hands that he was just on the phone with. He looked at me and told me if I am going to give him attitude we are closed. Walked out never again.
Service: 1
Best pizza in the world! This is according to my daughter who generally does not like pizza and asked for a second slice...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cool spot.In the winter, they're open only on select days (I know Thursday, not sure about other days). During the summer they're open all days.When I walked in, the pizza in the display did not appear too fresh, but I also did come in the late afternoon on a quiet day.I got a regular slice, jalapeño slice, and garlic knots. The service was extremely fast, and i did not wait long at all. The crust on the pizzas was super thin and extremely soft, almost felt like fresh bread. The taste was amazing as well. The jalapeños definitely gave a nice zing but not too strong, just the way I like it. The garlic knots were super soft as well and not lacking flavor.Although the service and food was amazing, I can't deny it's very pricey.It's not a huge store, but there's a decent amount of seating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was good, albeit expensive, although that’s to be expected from a small town pizzeria. Could have been a friendlier experience.
Happy to see a new place took over by Shop rite in West Long Branch. Even happier to try the pizza, and it is amazing! I am very picky about my pizza! Family owned and very friendly! Will be back to try the other things on the Menu!
Went here today with my kids for the first time. This pizza was phenomenal. Great crust, the sauce was perfect. Not like the typical bottled sauce. Super delicious pizza will definitely be back again!! Ty!
Restaurantji Recommends
Why is someone bashing the owner? All because he didn’t make eye contact with you? How self absorbed do you need to be to give a nasty review like that?Maybe the owner is just a little awkward. Maybe he was thinking. Occupied. But no- he MUST have been directly trying to offend you.
Whatever shop was there is now gone and Crust Co. Pizza has taken its place. Fresh, thin, delicious kosher pizza.
Great Pizza, great friendly service. would definitely go again.
Not sure why someone bashed this business because they felt that the owner didn’t make any eye contact with them over their faith/what they believe in. My fiancé and I aren’t of any religion and went there for pizza and the owner treated us amazingly - even offered us to sit down and brought all our food out to us. The pizza was perfect and the fries were fresh and crispy. 10/10 will be going back to Crust Co.!
Really good pizza, thanks for the experience