You can’t go inside …. You get there at 1pm and “we don’t make bagels after 1pm.” For place that has “bagel” in its name that’s very strange.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Eric Gonzalez
Bagels are a little on the smaller side, but taste pretty good. Ordered a warm glazed donut to go with my hot coffee and enjoyed it. The curbside only service is efficient. Prices are a little on the high side (1.95/bagel) but interested in going back to try one of their breakfast sandwiches, which look solid.
Food: 3
Service: 5
andrea bongiovanni
I think I have just had the best chicken marsala of my lifetime(and I have had many). It was perfect—the chicken was tender and cooked perfectly, the sauce was delicious, generous portion, and the homemade fettuccine was the chef’s kiss 💋. My boyfriend has Celiac and was overjoyed with the gluten free pizza. THANK YOU 🙏🏻 for making something absolutely delicious for him to enjoy after being disappointed by so many other places. We will be regulars from this point on…can’t wait to try all of the other amazing options! Your hard work and dedication show in your food—worth every penny.
Dietary restrictions: Great place for gluten free—the homemade GF pizza ROCKS!! Asian chicken teriyaki also the bomb.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Kelly
Go figure — At first I could not fathom that this joint was serving pizza, pasta, and mexican along with everything you would normally associate with a bagel. Jarrett had the audacity to start this food bazaar with a good bagel sandwich (best in Essex County - for those of you keeping score) then expand to every cuisine that could bring your comfort - and then some. No matter what you’re in the mood for - You would be hard pressed to NOT find 5 things you can’t choose between to order if you read through the entire menu.
Each and every dish, app, and pie I have tried has been a banger. The pasta’s and pizza are best in 10 miles - no joke. From here on out , for each new order I’m trying new things just to find what isn’t delicious — but the menu is soo deep this may take awhile - if I am even successful.
you can take your name + add a single breakfast option (aka “Bagel”) and voila … you just named the most delicious 🤤 Italian, Mexican and breakfast sandwich joint in town (I just short changed this place on everything else that is on point here). The only suggestion I have is to change up the name …. At least add an “Esc” to the end.
Thanks Jarrett. Keep on keeping on. Good luck with the new slice venture too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Egg Roll, Sesame Bagel with Bacon, Broccoli Alfredo Ravioli, The Roundish Plain Pie, Chicken Joe, Chicken Sandwich
chris caraballo
Lil pricey but food is worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Masiello
I was looking to Door Dash dinner from someplace I haven't tried. The menu and their pics & descriptions lured me in. I ordered their truffle mushroom pizza, Buffalo wings, spaghetti with creamy garlic sauce, and fettuccine with chicken & broccoli in vodka sauce. (Yes, we were hungry!) Everything was absolutely delicious! We look forward to ordering from them again and trying different dishes. 😊
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Dough
Paul Fox
A really fantastic menu, and the food is consistently great. This place is a real gem! I wish they would open the shop to walk in service again… but short of that I will continue to do curbside.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Autumn Ives
I just moved to Jersey and saw Bagels by Jarrett on the news and decided to give it a try. My life has changed. It is my order at the end of a hard day. My comfort food. Don’t be fooled by the diverse menu because everything on it is a HIT! I may or may not have shed a tear when the delivery guy got here.
Todd Idashkin
tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lj Castellano
what happen to the bagel w the taylor ham inside of it that was odddeeee
This place is absolutely exceptional! A product of Covid. The food is out of this world amazing, better than some of the most Michelin star restaurants I’ve tried!
The menu is constantly changing, but the consistency and quality quality never waiver! Everything is amazing from the tacos, to the pasta, taste amazing chicken dishes! There is literally nothing that this man cannot make, his delicious food is always served with a smile making you feel like home with every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese, OOO Bun, Turkey Club Sandwich, Scallion Cream Cheese, Broccoli Alfredo Ravioli, Chicken Wings, Pork Roll Egg & Cheese, The Roundish Plain Pie, Fried Chicken Bagel, Everything Butter, Fried Dough, Chicken Joe, Chicken Sandwich, The Countersuit, The Lawsuit, Bagel Chips, Eggplant Flatatini
Brian Cleary
This is curb-side pick only business which seems a bit weird since COVID has been over for years. Good bagels though!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mel V
Delicious food and great customer service! Give them a try. Some of my favs include the bar pie and the chicken salad.
Try the gluten slice and rice balls! So yummy
Food: 5
Service: 5
Syan Castro
The food and the staff were amazing! I went for gluten free food (Celiac) for breakfast and it was delicious. Most importantly it was extremely safe with dedicated gluten free stations. I would 100% recommend and try out their gluten pizza too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelsey Van Heest
I would like to include a picture in my post but I'm not seeing the option. I paid $16 (that's a crazy price) for a wrap that was the size of my palm (why was it so small?). The establishment won't let you inside and the menu is gigantic and only available to be viewed online. If you have a menu of this size it would be courteous to provide paper copies if people unknowingly show up to order at your store front. The online menu is not optimized for mobile so it's a really poor experience. Besides the wrap being very small, it tasted just okay. With the fact that the food is mediocre and you are a curb side pick up only restaurant, how do you justify the prices?
You can’t go inside …. You get there at 1pm and “we don’t make bagels after 1pm.” For place that has “bagel” in its name that’s very strange.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bagels are a little on the smaller side, but taste pretty good. Ordered a warm glazed donut to go with my hot coffee and enjoyed it. The curbside only service is efficient. Prices are a little on the high side (1.95/bagel) but interested in going back to try one of their breakfast sandwiches, which look solid.
Food: 3
Service: 5
I think I have just had the best chicken marsala of my lifetime(and I have had many). It was perfect—the chicken was tender and cooked perfectly, the sauce was delicious, generous portion, and the homemade fettuccine was the chef’s kiss 💋. My boyfriend has Celiac and was overjoyed with the gluten free pizza. THANK YOU 🙏🏻 for making something absolutely delicious for him to enjoy after being disappointed by so many other places. We will be regulars from this point on…can’t wait to try all of the other amazing options! Your hard work and dedication show in your food—worth every penny.
Dietary restrictions: Great place for gluten free—the homemade GF pizza ROCKS!! Asian chicken teriyaki also the bomb.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Go figure — At first I could not fathom that this joint was serving pizza, pasta, and mexican along with everything you would normally associate with a bagel. Jarrett had the audacity to start this food bazaar with a good bagel sandwich (best in Essex County - for those of you keeping score) then expand to every cuisine that could bring your comfort - and then some. No matter what you’re in the mood for - You would be hard pressed to NOT find 5 things you can’t choose between to order if you read through the entire menu.
Each and every dish, app, and pie I have tried has been a banger. The pasta’s and pizza are best in 10 miles - no joke. From here on out , for each new order I’m trying new things just to find what isn’t delicious — but the menu is soo deep this may take awhile - if I am even successful.
you can take your name + add a single breakfast option (aka “Bagel”) and voila … you just named the most delicious 🤤 Italian, Mexican and breakfast sandwich joint in town (I just short changed this place on everything else that is on point here). The only suggestion I have is to change up the name …. At least add an “Esc” to the end.
Thanks Jarrett. Keep on keeping on. Good luck with the new slice venture too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Egg Roll, Sesame Bagel with Bacon, Broccoli Alfredo Ravioli, The Roundish Plain Pie, Chicken Joe, Chicken Sandwich
Lil pricey but food is worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was looking to Door Dash dinner from someplace I haven't tried. The menu and their pics & descriptions lured me in. I ordered their truffle mushroom pizza, Buffalo wings, spaghetti with creamy garlic sauce, and fettuccine with chicken & broccoli in vodka sauce. (Yes, we were hungry!) Everything was absolutely delicious! We look forward to ordering from them again and trying different dishes. 😊
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Dough
A really fantastic menu, and the food is consistently great. This place is a real gem! I wish they would open the shop to walk in service again… but short of that I will continue to do curbside.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just moved to Jersey and saw Bagels by Jarrett on the news and decided to give it a try. My life has changed. It is my order at the end of a hard day. My comfort food. Don’t be fooled by the diverse menu because everything on it is a HIT! I may or may not have shed a tear when the delivery guy got here.
tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
what happen to the bagel w the taylor ham inside of it that was odddeeee
Food: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is absolutely exceptional! A product of Covid. The food is out of this world amazing, better than some of the most Michelin star restaurants I’ve tried!
The menu is constantly changing, but the consistency and quality quality never waiver! Everything is amazing from the tacos, to the pasta, taste amazing chicken dishes! There is literally nothing that this man cannot make, his delicious food is always served with a smile making you feel like home with every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese, OOO Bun, Turkey Club Sandwich, Scallion Cream Cheese, Broccoli Alfredo Ravioli, Chicken Wings, Pork Roll Egg & Cheese, The Roundish Plain Pie, Fried Chicken Bagel, Everything Butter, Fried Dough, Chicken Joe, Chicken Sandwich, The Countersuit, The Lawsuit, Bagel Chips, Eggplant Flatatini
This is curb-side pick only business which seems a bit weird since COVID has been over for years. Good bagels though!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food and great customer service! Give them a try. Some of my favs include the bar pie and the chicken salad.
Try the gluten slice and rice balls! So yummy
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and the staff were amazing! I went for gluten free food (Celiac) for breakfast and it was delicious. Most importantly it was extremely safe with dedicated gluten free stations. I would 100% recommend and try out their gluten pizza too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I would like to include a picture in my post but I'm not seeing the option. I paid $16 (that's a crazy price) for a wrap that was the size of my palm (why was it so small?). The establishment won't let you inside and the menu is gigantic and only available to be viewed online. If you have a menu of this size it would be courteous to provide paper copies if people unknowingly show up to order at your store front. The online menu is not optimized for mobile so it's a really poor experience. Besides the wrap being very small, it tasted just okay. With the fact that the food is mediocre and you are a curb side pick up only restaurant, how do you justify the prices?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...