bagels by jarrett

451 Mt Pleasant Ave, West Orange
(973) 250-6155

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Everything Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese
Lord's Roundish Caesar Pizza
Pepperoni and Onion Pizza
Broccoli Alfredo Ravioli
Sesame Bagel with Bacon
The Roundish Plain Pie
Pork Roll Egg & Cheese
Deep Fried Turkey blt
Chicken Salad Platter
Scallion Cream Cheese

Menu

Bagel with Spread
Bagel with Spread
bagel of your choice with spread/salad and/or toppings
Plain Bagel with Nutella Peanut Butter
Chicken up in Da Club
Bagel of your choice with bacon chive cc, chicken salad and tomato.
Chicken Joe No Bacon
bagel of your choice with russian dressing, chicken salad and homemade coleslaw
Burrata Bagel
bagel of your choice with with arugula, roasted red peppers and tomato tossed in a house infused olive oil then topped with a 4oz burrata ball and balsamic glaze
Bruschetta Bagel
bagel of your choice with roasted garlic & shallot cc, tomato, red onion, basil and balsamic glaze
Lox Lox in a Box
bagel of your choice with spread of your choice, lox, tomato, red onion, capers and dill
Chicken Joe
bagel of your choice with russian dressing, bacon, chicken salad and coleslaw.
Veggie Joe
bagel of your choice with Russian dressing, coleslaw, tomato, onion, cucumber and bagel chips. It's very messy and very worth it.
Fried Chicken Joe
bagel of your choice with buttermilk fried chicken, coleslaw and russian dressing.

Bagels
Loose Bagels
single bagel with nothing on it

Containers
Plain Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Roasted Garlic and Shallot
Everything Butter
Small Bacon and Chive Cream Cheese
Small Chickpea Salad
Small Everything Honey Butter
Small Cinnilla Cream Cheese
Small Whitefish Salad
Butter
Veggie Cream Cheese
Chicken Salad
Small Lox Spread
Tuna Salad
The Mix

Specials
Buffalo Wings
12 fresh (never frozen, not breaded) fried wings in our homemade buffalo sauce. Gluten free.
Korean Fried Wings
12 fresh (never frozen, not breaded) wings in our homemade sweet and spicy sauce.
Fresh Turkey Club
in house deep fried turkey, cooled and sliced. Served on a bagel of your choice with mayo, lettuce, tomato and bacon
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Our buttermilk fried chicken coated in our homemade buffalo sauce on a bed of shredded lettuce with tomato and red onion
Lawsuit Sliders
3 lawsuit sliders - potato bun, buttermilk fried chicken, mayo and lettuce. comes with pickles and coleslaw
Lord's Caesar Salad
The Chicken Salad Club Box
Homemade Chicken Salad, lettuce, bacon, tomato, mayo across 3 layers of toasted bread. Homemade chips, coleslaw and pickles.

Salads
Burrata Salad
Chickpea Salad Platter
Savory salad with a seasoned legume base.
Chicken Salad Platter
Tuna Salad Platter

Fried Chicken
Buffalo Chicken Box
Our homemade buttermilk fried chicken tossed in our buffalo sauce. Comes with a side of homemade coleslaw and pickles.
The Lawsuit
Bagel of your choice, homemade buttermilk fried chicken, a generous portion of mayo and lettuce
Sweet Thai Chicken Box
Our homemade buttermilk fried chicken tossed in a sweet thai sauce. Served with a side of coleslaw and pickles.
The Countersuit
Korean Chicken Box
Our homemade buttermilk fried chicken tossed in our Korean sauce. Comes with a side of asian slaw.
Naked Chicken Box
Our homemade buttermilk fried chicken with no sauce. Comes with a side of homemade honey mustard or bbq sauce

Sides
Side of Ricotta
Side of Russian
Side of Blue Cheese
Side Pico
Hot Sauce
Lox Portion
3.3oz portion
Side of Ranch
White Sauce
Side Sour Cream

Coffee
16 oz. Coffee
Cold Brew Coffee
Nitro Coffee
96 oz. Coffee Box
Comes with 8 cups, milk, almond milk, half and half, sugar, equal and stevia

Drinks
16oz Snapple
Orange Juice
Red Gatorade
Soda
V8
Evian Water
Yoo-Hoo

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: grubhub
+36 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+35 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Love this place! We usually order from this place for work because there are so many great and flavorful options that answers everyone's craving! This truly is the most confused Bagel place in a good way! I have a lot of favorite dishes from here that range from breakfast, lunch, platters, and apps. Highly recommend!
August 2025
I’m a local native of WO and have been a customer ever since Bagels by Jarrett opened and it NEVER disappoints (I used to be obsessed with the lawsuit w/ honey mustard)! any time I bring a dish to an outing or have a party people always ask me where did I get the amazing food! The wings and Caesar salad never misses!! I recently tried the chicken parm and burger sliders and they were amazing! I love Bagels by Jarrett and proud to be a loyal customer!
July 2025
Wow- the food here is absolutely delicious. The flavors…. the way it’s cooked. This is not only a bagel shop, it’s more than that. The variety of food… there’s so much to choose from and you can’t go wrong.

Jarrett is also so attentive and the sweetest person ever. I witnessed him give a free slice of pizza to the mailman and it truly touched my heart.

Not only is he a great guy, but an amazing owner. 10/10 recommend!!!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Julio's Restaurant - 459 Mt Pleasant Ave
Italian
East Garden Chinese Restaurant - 981 Pleasant Valley Way
Chinese, Asian Fusion
Pepe's Bbq - 977 Pleasant Valley Way
Barbecue, Peruvian, Barbeque, Vegetarian

bagels by jarrett

451 Mt Pleasant Ave, West Orange, NJ 07052
(973) 250-6155