Jersey Mike's Subs

235 Prospect Ave, West Orange
(973) 325-3220

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Elizabeth Marchand

Huge serving of meat! Much more than we are used to in Nh! We would highly recommend this location!

Jay Gee

Got my food quickly, even though it was crowded. The owner or the manager with the blonde hair was very helpful to everyone and had a great attitude. My food was great and so was the service.

Frank Pronesti

1st time last time. Feels like an airport restaurant. ShopRite has better sandwiches

Crap small sandwich. Expected better from Jersey Mikes.

james p

Filthy

killa cam 25

She decided to make my sandwich her way, no matter how many times I requested it the other way.
Is food allergy a thing?

Michael Frank

I LOVE Jersey Mikes. This store is very professionally run. Staff super attentive and courteous. Quick service and very clean. I will eat here every week! you cant go wrong

Rebecca Carney

One of the Best Jersey Mikes out there!! Clean, well managed and super friendly staff. This location has an upbeat vibe and always professional.

Jessica Gee

I love this place! Quick, amazing food! Staff is always Pleasant!

Savanna Clarke

This place is amazing! Sandwiches are great, Service is amazing! Highly recommend

Florent Dalencourt

Terrible Customer Service. Closed before 9pm.

Food: 1

Service: 1

KevLar Da Don

The other day I got, Jersey Mike’s Subs, for lunch. I had ordered their Cancro Special in a wheat wrap. I also got a bag of MissVickies Jalapeño Chips, a brownie, and a drink. The wrap was fairly mid. The wrap itself tasted a bit stale, and lowers my score greatly. The meats and veggies were pretty good, and tasted fresh. The staff was really nice and attentive, they made sure my order was correct. They thought I was a Jersey Mike’s lifer because the item I ordered isn’t on their menu, it’s kind of a secret menu option. The brownie was ok too, prob wouldn’t get it again. All in all, this experience was fairly mid, and the staff and atmosphere greatly impacts my total score.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Honest T

This is an overall review of the franchise as a whole. The sandwiches are all underwhelming. I honestly don't know how this place is still in business. The price you pay for a good looking but meh tasting sandwich is just not adding up. Again, I have never had a good sandwich from this restaurant.

vicki weiss

We always get a really good sandwich.
This time the sandwiches were not made as ordered. And there was a hair that didn’t belong to us in one of the sandwiches. I called the store and told them. She didn’t offer a solution. Like maybe a sandwich to replace the hair sandwich. I am really surprised

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

J P

If my team ran this efficiently at work, I'd be a millionaire!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julie Kinner

They catered an event for work. Truly so easy to work with and the food was perfect. Loved the mini oil and vinegar bottles! Would absolutely order from them again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...