Leilo’s Sweet Shop

306 Main St, West Orange
(973) 666-3489

Recent Reviews

Gloria Robayo

Spoke to the owner regarding a cake for my daughter's 15 birthday. She only answer through email. We had agreed on everything I called her never answered the phone. She emailed me and i didn't get a notification, so I reach out to her the day that I was supposed yo pick up the cake she said it was not done since I didn't reply her last email. It seems like she couldn't even text to make sure if I was still interested. Not a good way to run a business

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Oby O

We ordered desserts here for Christmas and every single item was a hit! Cake pops, chocolate chip cookies and Santa cookies - every single item was a 10 out of 10. Customer service was excellent and the entire experience was seamless! Love it and can’t wait to order again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ebony Hubbard

Great communication and very professional. My custom theme pull apart cake matched the theme of the party perfectly and the cupcakes were delicious. I will be going back for future events

Ashley Gregory

Love this bakery! Nicole was very professional, kind and delivered our order on time. Just 6 days before our event on April 22nd we ordered with her and she exceeded our expectations. Very artistic and delicious! She will be our go to baker for future events!

Lauren N.

Leilo's Sweet Shop provided the desserts for my daughter's first birthday party. Firstly, Nicole is super responsive and answered my questions almost immediately. Now for the desserts themselves- WOW! We ordered cake pops, cookies, and a custom cake. Not only did everything look beautiful, but everything tasted DELICIOUS! Everyone was raving about how good everything was. When I saw the cake my jaw dropped- it was exactly what I had envisioned, and Nicole brought it perfectly to life. They even offered to deliver our order, which was incredibly helpful.I would highly recommend Leilo's Sweet Shop and I can't wait to use them again for delicious treats!

Google user

Love this bakery! Nicole was very professional, kind and delivered our order on time. Just 6 days before our event on April 22nd we ordered with her and she exceeded our expectations. Very artistic and delicious! She will be our go to baker for future events!

Kim Tunstall

Absolutely delicious baked goodies. From the cookies, cupcakes and beautiful candy apples. The candy apples are my absolute favorite!! There is also a beautiful selection of custom cake designs to choose form. Highly recommended!!

Kim T.

Absolutely delicious baked goodies. From the cookies, cupcakes and beautiful candy apples. The candy apples are my absolute favorite!! There is also a beautiful selection of custom cake designs to choose form. Highly recommended!!

Alexandra Christopher

The ONLY person I trust to make the best cake and sweet treats! If the cake’s not from Leilo’s, I don’t want it!

Beth Cosentino

A good friend bought me a variety of cake slices from Leilo's for my birthday and OMG they were seriously delicious! I had a hard time not eating them all in one sitting. I highly recommend Leilo's!!

Roseunique Howard

The cookies came out terribly done. I am not at all satisfied with how they came out. And no response when I messaged them about the cookies. I do not recommend them. Someone else will do a better job.

Roseunique Howard

The cookies came out badly done. I am not at all satisfied with how they came out. And no response when I messaged them about the cookies. I do not recommend them. Someone else will do a better job.

Z faith

Ordered vanilla cupcakes for a picnic and they were so good and not too sweet. Everyone asked where I got it from and said they were good. Return customer for sure!

Jerry D.

I'm all about supporting local businesses. But the experience here was blah! I did not feel the love or customer appreciation that you get at other neighborhood pastry selling businesses. Not sure how long this place has been open for. It was another bakery some time ago. The cupcakes were not up to par. They were hard and not that tasty. I've had better cupcakes made from the box. This is not the spot for me.

Laquiella Davis

This Bakery is amazing, even down to the customer service! Everything was tasty and fresh.

Load More