West Orange Bake Shop

480 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange
(973) 243-1300

Recent Reviews

Chuck Mound

Place had a wide variety of baked goods that are fresh and taste great. Lindsor Tarts that I purchased were very good. People were nice as well.

Judy B.

They hate LGBTQIA community. Baked goods are sub-par and West Orange synagogues have boycotted them. Put them in the category with Chik-fil-A.

judybM6212JR

Used to go here often, for cakes and rugelach. This shop cancelled orders of rainbow cupcakes last-minute for synagogues in our town. They did it the prior year, but not this year for some reason. They don't care, either. If you are a member or support the community or equality, this is just like "Whites Only". Do not patronize this business if you care about your fellow human being. They absolutely don't.

Navanna A.

Go there if you appreciate the finer aspects of refusing service to LGBTQ I personally don't care what your politics are, but discriminating against a group and refusing to sell them. Food is not in the Bible.

mike frohlinger

I love the bakery always smiling and friendly

Jane J.

tasty treats and great service. prices are in line with other similar bakeries.

Geri W.

If I could give no stars I would. The owner of the shop is homophobic and refused to make me a same sex wedding cake. I was shocked! My synagogue will no longer be using this bakery. Very disappointed and disgusted.

Nathan E

Wonderful. Recommended by experts and advocates from many communities. The proprietor is super welcoming and accepting of all people without judgement and he's an all around great guy.

Carl Redfield

All baked goods are superb, excellent. As is their morality.

Mitchell Hecht

The best option for kosher baked goods in the area.

Daniel Fleisher

Their pretzel challah is the best I’ve had. I definitely plan on trying more of their products!

Bowser early

I love this bakery I'm not jewish but this is the best kosher bakery in America and the challah is so fluffy, fresh and good go to this bakery NOW.

Atara Schwartz

Best pan twist challah you'll ever taste. My kids won't let me buy it anywhere else.

Abraham Sharaby

Great food and great service! If you are looking for good Jewish bagel - this is the way to go.

Joey P

Best kosher bakery in NJ! Make sure you get there challah on Fridays it’s the best!

Load More