Gaetano's of Penny Packer
224 Pennypacker Dr, Willingboro
(609) 871-6861
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Cheesesteak with Mozzarella
Chicken Cheese Steak
Cheese Burger Hoagie
Cheese Steak Hoagie
Philly Cheesesteak
Cheese Fries
Pizza Steak
Tuna Hoagie
Taco Wrap
Menu
Photos
+41 photos
+40 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
First time ordering! Order was ready and hot when I arrived and the staff is pleasant. The cheesesteak calzone is delish (no ricotta)! The steak was well-seasoned, good amount of mozz, and the bake was nearly perfect. Looking forward to trying their other items.
The cheesesteaks have a familiar taste, but they’re skimping on the meat. The whole point of a gaetanos cheesesteak was that it was BURSTING at the seams with meat (literally). The steaks are pretty decent, but 20$ for a footlong is pretty steep when it doesn’t live up to the gaetanos name. Still giving it 3 stars because they obviously have some really big shoes to fill, but i’d rather go to one of the gaetanos chains.
If this was rated on food alone, it is a 5. The food is good
BUT...I orded ahead and still had to wait an extra 35 min for my order though the place was empty and only 2 people came to get their order while I was waiting. The guy at the counter was not friendly
If I were rating based on food alone, it's a solid 5 and, no question. The food is good.
BUT…
I ordered ahead, expecting a smooth pickup, yet still had to wait...
BUT...I orded ahead and still had to wait an extra 35 min for my order though the place was empty and only 2 people came to get their order while I was waiting. The guy at the counter was not friendly
If I were rating based on food alone, it's a solid 5 and, no question. The food is good.
BUT…
I ordered ahead, expecting a smooth pickup, yet still had to wait...
You May Also Like
Island Jerk - 12 Charleston Rd
![]()
Jamaican, Caribbean
McDonald's - 4299 US South Route 130
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food, Coffee & Tea
Vincenzo's - 23 Charleston Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian