Colonia Dairy Maid

1075 St Georges Ave, Colonia
(732) 634-5885

Recent Reviews

Michael Gerbery

A family go to! For custom ice cream cakes, to Delicious cones during the year, never disappointed! Great Staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sabiha Parveen

I had an awful experience there, ice had something dried things with tail , it was gray and white, my daughter eaten a bit and found weird thing, when I complained to the staff they were so rude and kept on saying that it is something against food code and it’s some topping from an other ice cream. She did not listen my concern and kept on saying get your refund or I can make a fresh one, that ice cream can cause a medical condition to my child but no one cares…… highly irresponsible and rude staff. I would not recommend anyone to shop there for kids, not safe and clean to eat

Nasty Roach

Went there constantly 47 years ago when Al Graber “Grabber” owned it. Waldo Pilutkiewicz and Joe Voelkel “JV” worked there. Glad it’s still open.

Atmosphere: 5

Allison Alberici

Great flavors-

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kushagra K

Awesome ice cream shop! Lots of flavors to pick from. The staff is super friendly. Whether you like regular or wild flavors, this place has yummy ice cream. Great spot for a sweet treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

R M

Great selection of hard and soft-serve ice cream. A vanilla and chocolate ice cream sundae with lots of black cherry topping is the best!?Custom made ice cream cakes are available from small to full sheetcake sizes and are reasonably priced.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DANIEL G.

Great Ice cream and service!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gummy Bears, Mango, Vanilla Cone, Mango Flavor, Sugar Free, Chocolate Marshmallow, Cherry Vanilla, Nutella, Hot Fudge, Coated Waffle Cone, Whipped Cream, Blueberry, Strawberry, Peach Ice Cream with Strawberries Walnuts and Hot Fudge, Banana Split, Cookie Dough, Nutella Ice Cream Cone, Italian Ice, Chocolate Chip

jerry

Lots of flavors. Very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gregory Searles

The most joyful experience for endurance you can ever have......❤️

emedjim

Oh my!Their monster shakes will keep you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Scott Zelazny

Many flavors to choose from, good service from everyone working there, but lines can be long in summer (for a good reason).

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karina Delgado

I called in to place an order for two 3 gallon tubs yesterday Wednesday. The lady on the phone was so irritated and had such a nasty attitude. I was told a month ago that they do sell the tubs and I had to call in 48 hours in advance. So, I began to place my order when I was told that I couldn’t get dulce de leche and I was only able to get rum raisin because It was going to be a busy weekend. What does me calling in on a Wednesday have to do with their store being busy on the weekend. I’m calling ahead of time. What if I wanted to place an ice cream cake order? Very disappointed with the service, I felt like your employee was just too lazy to complete an order and or prepare the ice cream tubs.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Asu Shah

Prices have gone up significantly but still one of the best places to get fresh homemade ice cream

Praveen Umamaheswaran

Amazing soft serves, fresh ice cream and the best I’ve had in the area. Unfortunately it’s a cash only place and has a ATM inside the store.

Lunch Time

I went there today but it's closed until Oct 7/23

Load More