Stuffed and loaded sandwiches on choice of bread (semolina, round, seeded, etc). Best part is you can grab lunch, pickup artisanal sausage, fresh mozz and other custom cut meats, specialty ingredients and pasta...many items) in one convenient stop.
Kirk Bleich
Another great Sandwich... Never disappoints. Had the Coliseum... Which is Roasted pork, Broccoli Rabe, fresh Mozz on a garlic bread toasted/pressed semolina....
Daniel Siniscalchi
$15 For a chicken cutlet sandwich with bacon lettuce and tomato. Chicken was greasy and dried out. Much better chicken cutlets around for 2/3 the price.... ? If it wasn't for the chicken it would have been a great sandwich but that was kinda the main part ?
Lynn Emmolo
Great Italian sauces, pasta and groceries! Staff incredible!!
IROC MIKE
I always knew A&S was good but never went there for some reason. I recently received a store gift certificate and I'm thankful I did because it forced me to go there. Besides being one of the best Italian breads I've ever had, the sandwiches brought me back to Calabria Italy. The pix of them are NOT forced perspective, they are GINORMOUS! Wyckoff is fortunate to have a TRUE Italian salumeria as good as one you would find in Little Italy (or Big Italy).
Victor S.
Best fresh Mozzarella around. Also one of the few deli's I can think of with healthy options that taste great. Outstanding chicken meatballs, faro salad, balsamic chicken and seasoned veggies. Not to mention the seafood salad.
Mike Roz
Food is tasty, price on the salads is a bit high.Had a chicken cutlet w tomato , fresh mozz and balsamic on toasted ciabatta it was tasty.Also had venetian style salad w sopressata and cheese , roasted red peppers and olives. Also tasty but a-lot of oil.But it is a little over priced.
Susan K.
Delicious, authentic Italian foods! It is so worth the trip. Food was fresh, delicious and so much to chose from. Portion were generous. Plenty of Italian grocery items to chose from. Staff was nice, helpful and patient. I will be back!
Tim Sauceman
Way too busy on the weekend with no ticketing system in place. Got skipped over multiple times while waiting to place an order-I eventually left without being served or even acknowledged. Two other people left at the same time. The employees expect a busy store of customers to know who’s next while being excruciatingly slow to serve anyone. Of course everyone thinks they’re next, which leads to many frustrated patrons.The sandwiches are good and some of the prepared food is decent but can be very expensive. If you can afford to waste 30+ minutes waiting for the staff to figure it out it without getting skipped over- it could be worth it. Unfortunately, I can’t say I’ll be back anytime soon.
Delicious and generous sized sandwiches! We ordered the Italian and a chicken parmigiana on a hero and it was enough to feed 3 adults. The Italian was loaded with meat, cheese and peppers and everything just blended well together. Chicken parmigiana was good but a little soggy with the sauce wrapped in foil. Overall, you're still going to end up with a chicken park here than most pizza spots let's say.
Cheryl Silverman
We ordered a 7 foot sub for a party for about 30 adults and 20 kids. Sooooooo much food!! It was 3 large platters of amazing portion sliced sandwiches. Most was the Italian sub and the rest eggplant sub. Everyone loved both, I was surprised how popular the eggplant was. We did have a whole platter left over, we ordered way too much but better to have extra than not enough. Everyone gave compliments on the food and most plates were empty when cleaning up. We will definitely order another catered sub for our next party.
Stefan H.
Great local Italian deli & market! Great selection of specialty grocery items. Daily specials with food made with quality ingredients and prepared with care. Looking forward to going back!
Anthony J Gougoutris
A traditional old school Italian market with the Sicilian flair. Caponata is spot on, the gentleman behind the counter told me its his nonnas recipe. Awesome sandwiches and a case that sells scarole and beans. How can you beat that. Highly recommended!
Stuffed and loaded sandwiches on choice of bread (semolina, round, seeded, etc). Best part is you can grab lunch, pickup artisanal sausage, fresh mozz and other custom cut meats, specialty ingredients and pasta...many items) in one convenient stop.
Another great Sandwich... Never disappoints. Had the Coliseum... Which is Roasted pork, Broccoli Rabe, fresh Mozz on a garlic bread toasted/pressed semolina....
$15 For a chicken cutlet sandwich with bacon lettuce and tomato. Chicken was greasy and dried out. Much better chicken cutlets around for 2/3 the price.... ? If it wasn't for the chicken it would have been a great sandwich but that was kinda the main part ?
Great Italian sauces, pasta and groceries! Staff incredible!!
I always knew A&S was good but never went there for some reason. I recently received a store gift certificate and I'm thankful I did because it forced me to go there. Besides being one of the best Italian breads I've ever had, the sandwiches brought me back to Calabria Italy. The pix of them are NOT forced perspective, they are GINORMOUS! Wyckoff is fortunate to have a TRUE Italian salumeria as good as one you would find in Little Italy (or Big Italy).
Best fresh Mozzarella around. Also one of the few deli's I can think of with healthy options that taste great. Outstanding chicken meatballs, faro salad, balsamic chicken and seasoned veggies. Not to mention the seafood salad.
Food is tasty, price on the salads is a bit high.Had a chicken cutlet w tomato , fresh mozz and balsamic on toasted ciabatta it was tasty.Also had venetian style salad w sopressata and cheese , roasted red peppers and olives. Also tasty but a-lot of oil.But it is a little over priced.
Delicious, authentic Italian foods! It is so worth the trip. Food was fresh, delicious and so much to chose from. Portion were generous. Plenty of Italian grocery items to chose from. Staff was nice, helpful and patient. I will be back!
Way too busy on the weekend with no ticketing system in place. Got skipped over multiple times while waiting to place an order-I eventually left without being served or even acknowledged. Two other people left at the same time. The employees expect a busy store of customers to know who’s next while being excruciatingly slow to serve anyone. Of course everyone thinks they’re next, which leads to many frustrated patrons.The sandwiches are good and some of the prepared food is decent but can be very expensive. If you can afford to waste 30+ minutes waiting for the staff to figure it out it without getting skipped over- it could be worth it. Unfortunately, I can’t say I’ll be back anytime soon.
Best sandwiches and appetizers. End of story.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great local Italian deli!
Delicious and generous sized sandwiches! We ordered the Italian and a chicken parmigiana on a hero and it was enough to feed 3 adults. The Italian was loaded with meat, cheese and peppers and everything just blended well together. Chicken parmigiana was good but a little soggy with the sauce wrapped in foil. Overall, you're still going to end up with a chicken park here than most pizza spots let's say.
We ordered a 7 foot sub for a party for about 30 adults and 20 kids. Sooooooo much food!! It was 3 large platters of amazing portion sliced sandwiches. Most was the Italian sub and the rest eggplant sub. Everyone loved both, I was surprised how popular the eggplant was. We did have a whole platter left over, we ordered way too much but better to have extra than not enough. Everyone gave compliments on the food and most plates were empty when cleaning up. We will definitely order another catered sub for our next party.
Great local Italian deli & market! Great selection of specialty grocery items. Daily specials with food made with quality ingredients and prepared with care. Looking forward to going back!
A traditional old school Italian market with the Sicilian flair. Caponata is spot on, the gentleman behind the counter told me its his nonnas recipe. Awesome sandwiches and a case that sells scarole and beans. How can you beat that. Highly recommended!